G von Wendt1, K Heikkilä, P Summanen. 1. Diabetic Retinopathy Photographic Screening Unit, Municipal Eye Clinic of Helsinki, Department of Ophthalmology, Herttoniemi Hospital, Finland.
Abstract
PURPOSE: To assess the severity of diabetic retinopathy and maculopathy by comparing two different photographic methods; two-field 60 degrees photography using red-free, black-and-white prints and colour transparencies. METHODS: Two ophthalmologists independently graded the photographs of 74 patients using grading scales for retinopathy and maculopathy designed for 60 degrees photography. A set of nine 60 degrees red-free, black-and-white standard photographs were chosen to represent the severity of principal diabetic retinopathy and maculopathy abnormalities. RESULTS: The inter-observer agreement for five pooled retinopathy severity levels was 88% (kappa 0.83, weighted kappa 0.96) and 81% (kappa 0.73, weighted kappa 0.89) using red-free, black-and-white prints and colour transparencies respectively. The corresponding figures for six pooled maculopathy levels were 96% (kappa 0.84, weighted kappa 0.97) and 93% (kappa 0.67, weighted kappa 0.86). The analyses revealed that red-free, black-and-white prints disclosed a higher severity level of retinopathy in 83% (Grader 1) and 76% (Grader 2) in those eyes for which the grading was discordant. CONCLUSION: High-quality monochrome, red-free, wide-angle fundus photographs may be useful for the detection of early and advanced diabetic retinopathy.
PURPOSE: To assess the severity of diabetic retinopathy and maculopathy by comparing two different photographic methods; two-field 60 degrees photography using red-free, black-and-white prints and colour transparencies. METHODS: Two ophthalmologists independently graded the photographs of 74 patients using grading scales for retinopathy and maculopathy designed for 60 degrees photography. A set of nine 60 degrees red-free, black-and-white standard photographs were chosen to represent the severity of principal diabetic retinopathy and maculopathy abnormalities. RESULTS: The inter-observer agreement for five pooled retinopathy severity levels was 88% (kappa 0.83, weighted kappa 0.96) and 81% (kappa 0.73, weighted kappa 0.89) using red-free, black-and-white prints and colour transparencies respectively. The corresponding figures for six pooled maculopathy levels were 96% (kappa 0.84, weighted kappa 0.97) and 93% (kappa 0.67, weighted kappa 0.86). The analyses revealed that red-free, black-and-white prints disclosed a higher severity level of retinopathy in 83% (Grader 1) and 76% (Grader 2) in those eyes for which the grading was discordant. CONCLUSION: High-quality monochrome, red-free, wide-angle fundus photographs may be useful for the detection of early and advanced diabetic retinopathy.
Authors: Gunvor von Wendt; Paula Summanen; Kerstin Hallnäs; Peep Algvere; Kauko Heikkilä; Stefan Seregard Journal: Graefes Arch Clin Exp Ophthalmol Date: 2004-11-30 Impact factor: 3.117