OBJECTIVES: To assess the utility of radiographs taken immediately after the application of a cast in the management of pediatric torus (or buckle) fractures and to determine the need for serial radiographs taken at follow-up visits. DESIGN: Retrospective medical record review; survey questionnaire of a panel of experts. SETTING: The pediatric emergency department (PED) and the pediatric orthopedic clinic at an urban, tertiary care hospital. PATIENTS: All children with torus fractures referred to the pediatric orthopedic clinic for follow-up visits between February 1995 and February 1997. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The number of patients whose postcast studies was obtained in the PED; number of follow-up visits and studies conducted at the pediatric orthopedic clinic; usual regional practices as extracted from a panel of experts by survey questionnaire. RESULTS: Of 70 patients, 46 (66%) were evaluated by a single, precast study in the PED, and 24 (34%) were evaluated by both precast and postcast studies in the PED. The time range of the first follow-up study was the first to fifth week after the patient's injury. The range of the number of follow-up studies for each patient was 0 to 5. Our cohort's total radiology charges for 70 patients were $27251. Regional directors of pediatric orthopedic surgery unanimously agreed that postcast studies in the PED are unnecessary. The range of the number of follow-up studies they obtained is 0 to 3 per patient. CONCLUSIONS: Postcast studies of torus fractures are unnecessary. Multiple radiographs taken during follow-up visits, especially early in the healing process, do not change fracture management. Relying on the clinical examination, perhaps combined with a single follow-up study, is a more appropriate regimen for the management of pediatric torus fractures and translates into a cost savings of over $ 10000 for our 70 patients.
OBJECTIVES: To assess the utility of radiographs taken immediately after the application of a cast in the management of pediatric torus (or buckle) fractures and to determine the need for serial radiographs taken at follow-up visits. DESIGN: Retrospective medical record review; survey questionnaire of a panel of experts. SETTING: The pediatric emergency department (PED) and the pediatric orthopedic clinic at an urban, tertiary care hospital. PATIENTS: All children with torus fractures referred to the pediatric orthopedic clinic for follow-up visits between February 1995 and February 1997. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The number of patients whose postcast studies was obtained in the PED; number of follow-up visits and studies conducted at the pediatric orthopedic clinic; usual regional practices as extracted from a panel of experts by survey questionnaire. RESULTS: Of 70 patients, 46 (66%) were evaluated by a single, precast study in the PED, and 24 (34%) were evaluated by both precast and postcast studies in the PED. The time range of the first follow-up study was the first to fifth week after the patient's injury. The range of the number of follow-up studies for each patient was 0 to 5. Our cohort's total radiology charges for 70 patients were $27251. Regional directors of pediatric orthopedic surgery unanimously agreed that postcast studies in the PED are unnecessary. The range of the number of follow-up studies they obtained is 0 to 3 per patient. CONCLUSIONS: Postcast studies of torus fractures are unnecessary. Multiple radiographs taken during follow-up visits, especially early in the healing process, do not change fracture management. Relying on the clinical examination, perhaps combined with a single follow-up study, is a more appropriate regimen for the management of pediatric torus fractures and translates into a cost savings of over $ 10000 for our 70 patients.
Authors: Nikki L Weil; M Frank Termaat; Sidney M Rubinstein; Mostafa El Moumni; Wietse P Zuidema; Robert Jan Derksen; Pieta Krijnen; Leti van Bodegom-Vos; Klaus W Wendt; Cornelis van Kuijk; Frits R Rosendaal; Roelf S Breederveld; J Carel Goslings; Inger B Schipper; Maurits W van Tulder Journal: Trials Date: 2015-02-27 Impact factor: 2.279