BACKGROUND: Laparoscopy and laparoscopic ultrasonography (lapUS) have been shown to improve the staging of patients with oesophagogastric cancer but there remains doubt as to whether most benefit follows laparoscopy alone and how much is contributed by the addition of lapUS. METHODS: The role of lapUS in surgical decision making was evaluated prospectively in a consecutive series of patients with oesophagogastric cancer following conventional radiological assessment. The results of the lapUS findings over and above the laparoscopic findings were documented in order to identify the additional benefit of lapUS. RESULTS: After initial conventional assessment 41 patients were considered unsuitable for surgery and treated by palliation, with a further 25 patients proceeding to surgery without laparoscopy. Of the 93 patients who underwent laparoscopy, 18 were shown to have irresectable disease and avoided further surgery; a further seven avoided inappropriate surgery by the addition of lapUS. The open-close laparotomy rate was reduced from five of 25 in patients who did not undergo laparoscopy to nine (12 per cent) of 75 by the introduction of laparoscopy and to two (3 per cent) of 68 with the addition of lapUS. CONCLUSION: Laparoscopy alone prevented unnecessary surgery in 18 (19 per cent) of 93 patients with oesophagogastric cancer and the addition of lapUS identified a further seven patients (8 per cent) in whom unnecessary surgery was avoided.
BACKGROUND: Laparoscopy and laparoscopic ultrasonography (lapUS) have been shown to improve the staging of patients with oesophagogastric cancer but there remains doubt as to whether most benefit follows laparoscopy alone and how much is contributed by the addition of lapUS. METHODS: The role of lapUS in surgical decision making was evaluated prospectively in a consecutive series of patients with oesophagogastric cancer following conventional radiological assessment. The results of the lapUS findings over and above the laparoscopic findings were documented in order to identify the additional benefit of lapUS. RESULTS: After initial conventional assessment 41 patients were considered unsuitable for surgery and treated by palliation, with a further 25 patients proceeding to surgery without laparoscopy. Of the 93 patients who underwent laparoscopy, 18 were shown to have irresectable disease and avoided further surgery; a further seven avoided inappropriate surgery by the addition of lapUS. The open-close laparotomy rate was reduced from five of 25 in patients who did not undergo laparoscopy to nine (12 per cent) of 75 by the introduction of laparoscopy and to two (3 per cent) of 68 with the addition of lapUS. CONCLUSION: Laparoscopy alone prevented unnecessary surgery in 18 (19 per cent) of 93 patients with oesophagogastric cancer and the addition of lapUS identified a further seven patients (8 per cent) in whom unnecessary surgery was avoided.
Authors: Abeezar I Sarela; Thomas J Miner; Martin S Karpeh; Daniel G Coit; David P Jaques; Murray F Brennan Journal: Ann Surg Date: 2006-02 Impact factor: 12.969