PURPOSE OF THE STUDY: The purpose of this study was to measure the serum cobalt levels and their correlation with clinical and radiological findings in patients with metal on metal hip articulating surfaces. METHOD: Forty-one patients with metal on metal hip arthroplasty were reviewed retrospectively at mean follow-up of 12.9 months. Serum cobalt levels were determined for each patient by atomic absorption spectrometry at the maximal follow-up and were compared to a control group (19 patients). Two patients and one control subjects also performed exercise on a treadmill in order to appreciate the influence of physical activity on serum cobalt levels. RESULTS: The metal on metal group presented higher serum cobalt levels than those of the control group (p < 0.0001). There was no correlation between serum cobalt and clinical and radiological findings at the exception of patient age (n = 40, r = 0.37). However, when the follow-up was greater than 18 months, mean serum cobalt was significantly higher compared to a follow-up less than 18 months. The physical exercise test led to a moderate elevation (around 10 p. 100) of cobalt in the two patients but not in the control subject. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION: The interpretation of an elevated cobalt serum level is difficult. Cobalt-containing drugs, other implants, excess of activity and diseases (renal failure) may influence serum cobalt level. In this study, the high serum cobalt levels seem not linked to a failure of the implant, mainly because of the short follow-up. They could rather be attributed to an increase of the patient activity beginning 18 months after the surgery. Because potential long-term cobalt toxicity and carcinogenicity is not well known, careful medical follow-up should be emphasized specially in young patients.
PURPOSE OF THE STUDY: The purpose of this study was to measure the serum cobalt levels and their correlation with clinical and radiological findings in patients with metal on metal hip articulating surfaces. METHOD: Forty-one patients with metal on metalhip arthroplasty were reviewed retrospectively at mean follow-up of 12.9 months. Serum cobalt levels were determined for each patient by atomic absorption spectrometry at the maximal follow-up and were compared to a control group (19 patients). Two patients and one control subjects also performed exercise on a treadmill in order to appreciate the influence of physical activity on serum cobalt levels. RESULTS: The metal on metal group presented higher serum cobalt levels than those of the control group (p < 0.0001). There was no correlation between serum cobalt and clinical and radiological findings at the exception of patient age (n = 40, r = 0.37). However, when the follow-up was greater than 18 months, mean serum cobalt was significantly higher compared to a follow-up less than 18 months. The physical exercise test led to a moderate elevation (around 10 p. 100) of cobalt in the two patients but not in the control subject. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION: The interpretation of an elevated cobalt serum level is difficult. Cobalt-containing drugs, other implants, excess of activity and diseases (renal failure) may influence serum cobalt level. In this study, the high serum cobalt levels seem not linked to a failure of the implant, mainly because of the short follow-up. They could rather be attributed to an increase of the patient activity beginning 18 months after the surgery. Because potential long-term cobalttoxicity and carcinogenicity is not well known, careful medical follow-up should be emphasized specially in young patients.
Authors: Anastasia K Skipor; Patricia A Campbell; Leslie M Patterson; Harlan C Anstutz; Thomas P Schmalzried; Joshua J Jacobs Journal: J Mater Sci Mater Med Date: 2002-12 Impact factor: 3.896