The cleavage step of ribonuclease P catalysis is determined by ribozyme-substrate interactions both distal and proximal to the cleavage site.

The cleavage step of bacterial RNase P catalysis involves concentration-independent processes after the formation of the ribozyme-substrate complex that result in the breaking of a phosphodiester bond. The 2'OH group at the cleavage site of a pre-tRNA substrate is an important determinant in the cleavage step. We determined here that in contrast to a tRNA substrate, the 2'OH at the cleavage site of two in vitro selected substrates has no effect, whereas a 2'OH located adjacent to the cleavage site has a similarly large effect on the cleavage step. This result indicates that a unique 2'OH in the vicinity of the cleavage site interacts with the ribozyme to achieve the maximal efficiency of the cleavage step. Individual modifications in a pre-tRNA substrate that disrupt ES interactions proximal to the cleavage site generally have little effect on the usage of this unique 2'OH. Ribozyme modifications that delete the interactions involving the T stem-loop of the tRNA have a large effect on the usage of this unique 2'OH and also alter the location of this 2'OH. We propose a new ES complex prior to the bond-breaking step in the reaction scheme to explain these results. This second ES complex is in fast equilibrium with the initial ES complex formed by bimolecular collision. The ribozyme interaction with this unique 2'OH shifts the equilibrium in favor of the second ES complex. The formation of the second ES complex may require optimal geometry of the two independently folding domains of this ribozyme to precisely position crucial functional groups and Mg2+ ions in the active site. Such a domain geometry is significantly favored by the RNase P protein. In the absence of the protein, spatial rearrangement of these domains in the ES complex may be necessary.