M S Benninger1, J B Gillen, J S Altman. 1. Department of Otolaryngology, Head and Neck Surgery, Henry Ford Hospital, Detroit, Michigan 48202-2689, USA.
Abstract
HYPOTHESIS: Vocal fold immobility is a sign of underlying disease. When the etiology remains unclear, evaluation may become time consuming and costly, and directed work-up imperative. This study examined the hypothesis that the etiologies of vocal fold immobility are changing, with extralaryngeal malignancies and nonthyroidectomy surgical trauma having become more common causes. METHODS: A retrospective review of consecutive patients with vocal fold immobility who had an adequate workup to determine the etiology. RESULTS: Three hundred ninety-seven cases with a determined etiology were identified, yielding 280 unilateral and 117 bilateral immobilities. The largest single category in unilateral immobility was nonlaryngeal malignancy--69 patients (24.7%)--80% of which were pulmonary or mediastinal, followed by 67 patients (23.9%) with immobility secondary to surgical trauma. Thyroidectomy accounted for only 8.2%. The leading cause of bilateral immobility was surgical trauma-30 patients (25.7%)--21 (18%) of whom had thyroidectomy. Acute and chronic intubation injuries accounted for 21 unilateral (7.5%) and 18 bilateral (15.4%) cases. CONCLUSIONS: These data indicate a changing etiology of vocal fold immobility, with growing percentages of extralaryngeal malignancies and surgery-related injuries. These findings have implications for the timing and method of management based on anticipated outcome.
HYPOTHESIS: Vocal fold immobility is a sign of underlying disease. When the etiology remains unclear, evaluation may become time consuming and costly, and directed work-up imperative. This study examined the hypothesis that the etiologies of vocal fold immobility are changing, with extralaryngeal malignancies and nonthyroidectomy surgical trauma having become more common causes. METHODS: A retrospective review of consecutive patients with vocal fold immobility who had an adequate workup to determine the etiology. RESULTS: Three hundred ninety-seven cases with a determined etiology were identified, yielding 280 unilateral and 117 bilateral immobilities. The largest single category in unilateral immobility was nonlaryngeal malignancy--69 patients (24.7%)--80% of which were pulmonary or mediastinal, followed by 67 patients (23.9%) with immobility secondary to surgical trauma. Thyroidectomy accounted for only 8.2%. The leading cause of bilateral immobility was surgical trauma-30 patients (25.7%)--21 (18%) of whom had thyroidectomy. Acute and chronic intubation injuries accounted for 21 unilateral (7.5%) and 18 bilateral (15.4%) cases. CONCLUSIONS: These data indicate a changing etiology of vocal fold immobility, with growing percentages of extralaryngeal malignancies and surgery-related injuries. These findings have implications for the timing and method of management based on anticipated outcome.
Authors: Nikolay Sapundzhiev; György Lichtenberger; Hans Edmund Eckel; Gerhard Friedrich; Ivan Zenev; Robert J Toohill; Jochen Alfred Werner Journal: Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol Date: 2008-04-17 Impact factor: 2.503
Authors: Vyas M N Prasad; Raja Fakhoury; Diane Helou; Georges Lawson; Marc Remacle Journal: Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol Date: 2017-03-17 Impact factor: 2.503
Authors: H Dralle; E Kruse; W H Hamelmann; S Grond; H J Neumann; C Sekulla; C Richter; O Thomusch; H-P Mühlig; J Voss; W Timmermann Journal: Chirurg Date: 2004-08 Impact factor: 0.955
Authors: Farzad Masroor; Debbie R Pan; Julia C Wei; Miranda L Ritterman Weintraub; Nancy Jiang Journal: Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol Date: 2018-11-15 Impact factor: 2.503