BACKGROUND: In this study we compared the accuracy of seven diagnostic tests in diagnosing Helicobacter pylori infection. METHODS: Over 1 year 351 consecutive dyspeptic patients were tested for H. pylori infection by means of antral biopsy specimens for the rapid urease test (RUT), culture, microscopy (acridine stain), and the laboratory urease test (LUT) and, in addition, with 14C urea breath test (UBT), IgG serology, and IgA serology (Orion Diagnostica Pyloriset New EIA-G and New EIA-A). The criterion for H. pylori infection was a minimum of three positive tests. Before being tested, 38% of the patients had used an H2-receptor antagonist (H2RA). RESULTS: Two-hundred and twenty-four patients (64%) were H. pylori-positive. The sensitivity and specificity of the tests were as follows (percentages): RUT, 85, 99; culture, 93, 100; microscopy, 81, 98; LUT, 80, 100; UBT, 95, 95; IgG serology, 99, 91; and IgA serology, 88, 91. The accuracy of the RUT and LUT was reduced in patients receiving H2RA therapy (P=0.04 and 0.01, respectively). CONCLUSIONS: Culture, UBT, and IgG serology were all superior to the other four tests in diagnosing H. pylori infection. Invasive urease-based tests were less accurate in patients receiving H2RAs.
BACKGROUND: In this study we compared the accuracy of seven diagnostic tests in diagnosing Helicobacter pylori infection. METHODS: Over 1 year 351 consecutive dyspeptic patients were tested for H. pyloriinfection by means of antral biopsy specimens for the rapid urease test (RUT), culture, microscopy (acridine stain), and the laboratory urease test (LUT) and, in addition, with 14C urea breath test (UBT), IgG serology, and IgA serology (Orion Diagnostica Pyloriset New EIA-G and New EIA-A). The criterion for H. pyloriinfection was a minimum of three positive tests. Before being tested, 38% of the patients had used an H2-receptor antagonist (H2RA). RESULTS: Two-hundred and twenty-four patients (64%) were H. pylori-positive. The sensitivity and specificity of the tests were as follows (percentages): RUT, 85, 99; culture, 93, 100; microscopy, 81, 98; LUT, 80, 100; UBT, 95, 95; IgG serology, 99, 91; and IgA serology, 88, 91. The accuracy of the RUT and LUT was reduced in patients receiving H2RA therapy (P=0.04 and 0.01, respectively). CONCLUSIONS: Culture, UBT, and IgG serology were all superior to the other four tests in diagnosing H. pyloriinfection. Invasive urease-based tests were less accurate in patients receiving H2RAs.
Authors: Pertti Aro; Jukka Ronkainen; Tom Storskrubb; Michael Vieth; Lars Engstrand; Sven-Erik Johansson; Elisabeth Bolling-Sternevald; Gunilla Bolinder; Kjell Alving; Nicholas J Talley; Lars Agréus Journal: Eur J Epidemiol Date: 2010-07-29 Impact factor: 8.082