OBJECTIVE: To examine whether the accuracy of bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA) to estimate body composition in overweight women is affected by the ethnicity of the individuals. DESIGN: Cross-sectional design to compare body composition estimated by BIA to body composition measured by dual energy x-ray absorptiometry (DEXA), which was the reference method. SUBJECTS: One hundred twenty three overweight women participated in this study, of which 43 women were African-American (aged 37.2+/-5.6 y; BMI, 32.3+/-4.9 kg/m2) and 80 were Caucasian (aged 36.1+/-5.7 y; BMI, 31.9+/-3.5 kg/m2). MEASUREMENTS: Body composition was estimated from BIA using both a generalized and an obesity-specific equation. These estimations were compared to body composition measured by DEXA, which was the reference method. RESULTS: The generalized BIA equation underestimated lean body mass (LBM) by 2.6+/-3.1 kg in Caucasian women and 0.4+/-3.2 kg in African-American women, with the difference between the ethnic groups being significant (P < 0.001). The obesity-specific equation underestimated LBM in Caucasians by 0.9+/-3.1 kg and overestimated LBM in African-Americans by 1.2+/-2.8 kg (P < 0.001). An ethnic-specific equation is proposed, and cross-validation of this equation indicates that it provides a reasonable estimate of body composition in overweight women. CONCLUSIONS: The accuracy of BIA to estimate body composition appears to be affected by the ethnicity of the individual. Therefore, an ethnic-specific equation for overweight women is proposed. However, further validation of this prediction model in an ethnically diverse population is necessary.
OBJECTIVE: To examine whether the accuracy of bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA) to estimate body composition in overweight women is affected by the ethnicity of the individuals. DESIGN: Cross-sectional design to compare body composition estimated by BIA to body composition measured by dual energy x-ray absorptiometry (DEXA), which was the reference method. SUBJECTS: One hundred twenty three overweight women participated in this study, of which 43 women were African-American (aged 37.2+/-5.6 y; BMI, 32.3+/-4.9 kg/m2) and 80 were Caucasian (aged 36.1+/-5.7 y; BMI, 31.9+/-3.5 kg/m2). MEASUREMENTS: Body composition was estimated from BIA using both a generalized and an obesity-specific equation. These estimations were compared to body composition measured by DEXA, which was the reference method. RESULTS: The generalized BIA equation underestimated lean body mass (LBM) by 2.6+/-3.1 kg in Caucasian women and 0.4+/-3.2 kg in African-American women, with the difference between the ethnic groups being significant (P < 0.001). The obesity-specific equation underestimated LBM in Caucasians by 0.9+/-3.1 kg and overestimated LBM in African-Americans by 1.2+/-2.8 kg (P < 0.001). An ethnic-specific equation is proposed, and cross-validation of this equation indicates that it provides a reasonable estimate of body composition in overweight women. CONCLUSIONS: The accuracy of BIA to estimate body composition appears to be affected by the ethnicity of the individual. Therefore, an ethnic-specific equation for overweight women is proposed. However, further validation of this prediction model in an ethnically diverse population is necessary.
Authors: P Cugini; A Salandri; M Cilli; P Ceccotti; A Di Marzo; A Rodio; S Fontana; A M Pellegrino; G P De Francesco; S Coda; F De Vito; L Colosi; C M Petrangeli; C Giovannini Journal: Eat Weight Disord Date: 1999-06 Impact factor: 4.652
Authors: Catherine L Carpenter; Eric Yan; Steve Chen; Kurt Hong; Adam Arechiga; Woo S Kim; Max Deng; Zhaoping Li; David Heber Journal: J Obes Date: 2013-04-08