OBJECTIVE: To study the quality of diagnostic practice in rural Burkina Faso. METHOD: In 9 health centres of 3 districts, 313 outpatient consultations were observed, and 417 diagnoses by 15 nurses were analysed. Criteria for evaluation of patient history and clinical examination were based on the diagnostic guidelines distributed by the Ministry of Health. RESULTS: In only 20% of the diagnoses the nurses took a sufficient history and in only 40% they conducted a sufficient clinical examination. In 21% patients underwent no clinical examination at all. Only 12% of all diagnoses were based on sufficient history-taking and adequate clinical examinations. The individual elements of clinical examination were performed correctly in 82% of cases. The variation between nurses was immense, but no correlation could be found with regard to their basic training. However, nurses who had received the diagnostic guidelines examined patients more carefully than those who had not. Larger numbers of patients per day are not associated with shorter nurse-patient contact, and neither is sufficiency of patient history associated with duration of the consultation. CONCLUSION: The low diagnostic quality of the outpatient consultations in the studied area indicates that this issue has been neglected in national public health initiatives. But examination skills are good and diagnostic guidelines may have had a positive effect on the diagnostic quality.
OBJECTIVE: To study the quality of diagnostic practice in rural Burkina Faso. METHOD: In 9 health centres of 3 districts, 313 outpatient consultations were observed, and 417 diagnoses by 15 nurses were analysed. Criteria for evaluation of patient history and clinical examination were based on the diagnostic guidelines distributed by the Ministry of Health. RESULTS: In only 20% of the diagnoses the nurses took a sufficient history and in only 40% they conducted a sufficient clinical examination. In 21% patients underwent no clinical examination at all. Only 12% of all diagnoses were based on sufficient history-taking and adequate clinical examinations. The individual elements of clinical examination were performed correctly in 82% of cases. The variation between nurses was immense, but no correlation could be found with regard to their basic training. However, nurses who had received the diagnostic guidelines examined patients more carefully than those who had not. Larger numbers of patients per day are not associated with shorter nurse-patient contact, and neither is sufficiency of patient history associated with duration of the consultation. CONCLUSION: The low diagnostic quality of the outpatient consultations in the studied area indicates that this issue has been neglected in national public health initiatives. But examination skills are good and diagnostic guidelines may have had a positive effect on the diagnostic quality.
Authors: Donne Kofi Ameme; Edwin Andrews Afari; Kofi Mensah Nyarko; Keziah Laurencia Malm; Samuel Sackey; Fred Wurapa Journal: Pan Afr Med J Date: 2014-12-10
Authors: Paul Jacob Robyn; Till Bärnighausen; Aurélia Souares; Germain Savadogo; Brice Bicaba; Ali Sié; Rainer Sauerborn Journal: Int J Equity Health Date: 2013-05-16
Authors: Maurice Yé; Eric Diboulo; Moubassira Kagoné; Ali Sié; Rainer Sauerborn; Svetla Loukanova Journal: Glob Health Action Date: 2016-01-05 Impact factor: 2.640