BACKGROUND: Since the first attempts at resection of Klatskin tumours, an increasingly aggressive surgical treatment has been proposed. Results obtained after examination of the specimen have shown that a significant proportion of resections were palliative. Curative resection appears to be difficult to perform selectively. METHODS: This retrospective study evaluates the results of a surgically-oriented management of hilar bile duct cancers. Thirty-nine patients were operated on in the period 1982-1994. Eighteen resections were carried out, requiring liver resection in 13 cases. Pathology of the specimen showed that the resection had been curative in 14 cases. The remaining 21 patients had surgical palliation, i.e. bypass and/or stenting. RESULTS: In the resection group, there was no death but four patients suffered severe complications. The 1- and 5-year survival rates were 67 and 47 per cent respectively, with a median survival of 26 months. In the palliation group, the mortality rate was 14 per cent and median survival was 7 months. CONCLUSION: In the absence of evident contraindications, surgical exploration is worthwhile as it allows detection of the cases where curative resection is possible. Curative resection often requires a major hepatectomy, but mortality and morbidity may be kept low, and it offers a real hope of cure.
BACKGROUND: Since the first attempts at resection of Klatskin tumours, an increasingly aggressive surgical treatment has been proposed. Results obtained after examination of the specimen have shown that a significant proportion of resections were palliative. Curative resection appears to be difficult to perform selectively. METHODS: This retrospective study evaluates the results of a surgically-oriented management of hilar bile duct cancers. Thirty-nine patients were operated on in the period 1982-1994. Eighteen resections were carried out, requiring liver resection in 13 cases. Pathology of the specimen showed that the resection had been curative in 14 cases. The remaining 21 patients had surgical palliation, i.e. bypass and/or stenting. RESULTS: In the resection group, there was no death but four patients suffered severe complications. The 1- and 5-year survival rates were 67 and 47 per cent respectively, with a median survival of 26 months. In the palliation group, the mortality rate was 14 per cent and median survival was 7 months. CONCLUSION: In the absence of evident contraindications, surgical exploration is worthwhile as it allows detection of the cases where curative resection is possible. Curative resection often requires a major hepatectomy, but mortality and morbidity may be kept low, and it offers a real hope of cure.
Authors: Harald Puhalla; Thomas Gruenberger; Herwig Pokorny; Thomas Soliman; Fritz Wrba; Ulrike Sponer; Thomas Winkler; Meinhard Ploner; Markus Raderer; Rudolf Steininger; Ferdinand Mühlbacher; Friedrich Laengle Journal: World J Surg Date: 2003-05-13 Impact factor: 3.352