BACKGROUND: Conventional contact investigation and molecular fingerprinting of Mycobacterium tuberculosis isolates in tuberculosis (TB) outbreaks have facilitated recognition as well as application of public health control activities. Singing in a choir as an activity that promotes TB transmission has been occasionally recognized. Such avocational transmission in a middle class community can occur with attendant difficulties encountered in contact investigation. METHODS: Five cases of TB (one index case; three secondary cases; one unassociated case) were identified among members of a famous church gospel choir in Newark, NJ. DNA fingerprinting and susceptibility testing were done on all retrieved strains. Of 306 choir members who had tuberculin tests, 19% were reactors. The presumed outbreak site was investigated. RESULTS: Four of the five patients were tenors, and one was an alto. Tenors were approximately twice as likely to be tuberculin reactors than subjects with other vocal ranges combined (relative risk, 2.04; 95% confidence interval, 1.17 to 3.56). An air ventilation outlet was directly in front of the tenor section. Some limited extra-church activity between choir members may have contributed to transmission. CONCLUSION: Conventional contact investigation must be supplemented by newer techniques, such as DNA fingerprinting, in identifying possible outbreak transmission. Singing, location of a ventilation outlet, and exposure time may have contributed to TB transmission in this outbreak. Transmission need not only be in congregate settings among well-defined socioeconomic groups but may occur unexpectedly in middle class communities.
BACKGROUND: Conventional contact investigation and molecular fingerprinting of Mycobacterium tuberculosis isolates in tuberculosis (TB) outbreaks have facilitated recognition as well as application of public health control activities. Singing in a choir as an activity that promotes TB transmission has been occasionally recognized. Such avocational transmission in a middle class community can occur with attendant difficulties encountered in contact investigation. METHODS: Five cases of TB (one index case; three secondary cases; one unassociated case) were identified among members of a famous church gospel choir in Newark, NJ. DNA fingerprinting and susceptibility testing were done on all retrieved strains. Of 306 choir members who had tuberculin tests, 19% were reactors. The presumed outbreak site was investigated. RESULTS: Four of the five patients were tenors, and one was an alto. Tenors were approximately twice as likely to be tuberculin reactors than subjects with other vocal ranges combined (relative risk, 2.04; 95% confidence interval, 1.17 to 3.56). An air ventilation outlet was directly in front of the tenor section. Some limited extra-church activity between choir members may have contributed to transmission. CONCLUSION: Conventional contact investigation must be supplemented by newer techniques, such as DNA fingerprinting, in identifying possible outbreak transmission. Singing, location of a ventilation outlet, and exposure time may have contributed to TB transmission in this outbreak. Transmission need not only be in congregate settings among well-defined socioeconomic groups but may occur unexpectedly in middle class communities.
Authors: Sara A Lowther; Roque Miramontes; Barbara Navara; Nadya Sabuwala; Milayna Brueshaber; Sarah Solarz; Maryam B Haddad; Deborah Sodt; Ruth Lynfield Journal: Public Health Rep Date: 2011 Sep-Oct Impact factor: 2.792
Authors: C N Classen; R Warren; M Richardson; J H Hauman; R P Gie; J H Ellis; P D van Helden; N Beyers Journal: Thorax Date: 1999-02 Impact factor: 9.139
Authors: James R Hargreaves; Delia Boccia; Carlton A Evans; Michelle Adato; Mark Petticrew; John D H Porter Journal: Am J Public Health Date: 2011-02-17 Impact factor: 9.308
Authors: Sarah E Smith-Jeffcoat; Sadia Sleweon; Mitsuki Koh; George M Khalil; Marcos C Schechter; Paulina A Rebolledo; Vyjayanti Kasinathan; Adam Hoffman; Rebecca Rossetti; Talya Shragai; Kevin O'Laughlin; Catherine C Espinosa; Bettina Bankamp; Michael D Bowen; Ashley Paulick; Amy S Gargis; Jennifer M Folster; Juliana da Silva; Caitlin Biedron; Rebekah J Stewart; Yun F Wang; Hannah L Kirking; Jacqueline E Tate Journal: Front Public Health Date: 2022-03-24
Authors: Jack Schijven; Lucie C Vermeulen; Arno Swart; Adam Meijer; Erwin Duizer; Ana Maria de Roda Husman Journal: Environ Health Perspect Date: 2021-04-01 Impact factor: 9.031
Authors: Shelly L Miller; William W Nazaroff; Jose L Jimenez; Atze Boerstra; Giorgio Buonanno; Stephanie J Dancer; Jarek Kurnitski; Linsey C Marr; Lidia Morawska; Catherine Noakes Journal: Indoor Air Date: 2020-10-13 Impact factor: 6.554