OBJECTIVES AND DESIGN: A prospective study of 709 patients undergoing carotid surgery in the U.K. and Ireland was performed to evaluate the performance of vascular surgeons. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Fifty-nine surgeons (range 2-39 cases each) were sampled and all patients undergoing surgery over a 6-month period (1 March 1994-31 August 1994) were included in the study. Indications for surgery were TIA (35.9%), AF (23.3%), CVA (21.4%) and "others" (19.6%). RESULTS: Mean ipsilateral stenosis was 82% (30%-99%). Thirty-one percent of patients had preoperative neurological consults. Shunts were used in 67.6%, tacking sutures in 40.1%, drains in 71.9% and patches in 54.4% of cases. At 30 days there were nine (1.3%) deaths (four cardiac, three neurological). There were 15 ipsilateral postoperative CVAs (2.1%); 19% of patients had one or more complication, usually minor. Statistical analysis showed no independent risk factor for CVA other than seniority of the surgeon. CONCLUSIONS: A combined stroke/death rate of 3% for the series was obtained at 30 days for all cases. This large, validated study suggests that members of the Vascular Society of G.B. and Ireland currently have a very low morbidity/mortality rate for performing carotid surgery. Continued audit is required to ensure that this quality of service does not deteriorate.
OBJECTIVES AND DESIGN: A prospective study of 709 patients undergoing carotid surgery in the U.K. and Ireland was performed to evaluate the performance of vascular surgeons. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Fifty-nine surgeons (range 2-39 cases each) were sampled and all patients undergoing surgery over a 6-month period (1 March 1994-31 August 1994) were included in the study. Indications for surgery were TIA (35.9%), AF (23.3%), CVA (21.4%) and "others" (19.6%). RESULTS: Mean ipsilateral stenosis was 82% (30%-99%). Thirty-one percent of patients had preoperative neurological consults. Shunts were used in 67.6%, tacking sutures in 40.1%, drains in 71.9% and patches in 54.4% of cases. At 30 days there were nine (1.3%) deaths (four cardiac, three neurological). There were 15 ipsilateral postoperative CVAs (2.1%); 19% of patients had one or more complication, usually minor. Statistical analysis showed no independent risk factor for CVA other than seniority of the surgeon. CONCLUSIONS: A combined stroke/death rate of 3% for the series was obtained at 30 days for all cases. This large, validated study suggests that members of the Vascular Society of G.B. and Ireland currently have a very low morbidity/mortality rate for performing carotid surgery. Continued audit is required to ensure that this quality of service does not deteriorate.
Authors: Alison W Halliday; Tim Lees; Dora Kamugasha; Robert Grant; Alex Hoffman; Peter M Rothwell; John F Potter; Michael Horrocks; Ross Naylor; Anthony G Rudd Journal: BMJ Date: 2009-06-04