AIMS: Most secundum atrial septal defects, once diagnosed, are corrected at a young age. The evidence to justify early vs delayed or even non-closure is equivocal and little is known regarding long-term effects of later closure. This is particularly pertinent to those patients awaiting transcatheter closure of their defect for whom a device is only just becoming available. We examined the exercise cardiorespiratory physiology of children surgically treated for an isolated secundum defect. METHODS AND RESULTS: One hundred and six healthy control children and 22 children more than 6 months after surgical repair for an isolated secundum atrial septal defect were studied. All were asymptomatic. Measurements of effective pulmonary blood flow, stroke volume, arteriovenous oxygen difference, minute ventilation, heart rate, oxygen consumption and carbon dioxide production were made using a quadrupole mass spectrometer during rest and graded exercise. Data from the normal children allowed calculation of z scores for the atrial septal defect group matched for age, sex, pubertal stage and surface area. Maximal exercise performance was equal between control and atrial septal defect groups, however, the atrial septal defect group had a significantly greater effective pulmonary blood flow and stroke volume but a lower heart rate than controls at a given exercise stage. Stroke volume abnormalities were most closely related to duration of follow-up (29% of the variance explained, P < 0.01) rather than age at surgery. CONCLUSIONS: We were unable to show a medium term benefit from early surgery for an asymptomatic secundum atrial septal defect during exercise. The clinical relevance of the haemodynamic differences that do exist remains unclear.
AIMS: Most secundum atrial septal defects, once diagnosed, are corrected at a young age. The evidence to justify early vs delayed or even non-closure is equivocal and little is known regarding long-term effects of later closure. This is particularly pertinent to those patients awaiting transcatheter closure of their defect for whom a device is only just becoming available. We examined the exercise cardiorespiratory physiology of children surgically treated for an isolated secundum defect. METHODS AND RESULTS: One hundred and six healthy control children and 22 children more than 6 months after surgical repair for an isolated secundum atrial septal defect were studied. All were asymptomatic. Measurements of effective pulmonary blood flow, stroke volume, arteriovenousoxygen difference, minute ventilation, heart rate, oxygen consumption and carbon dioxide production were made using a quadrupole mass spectrometer during rest and graded exercise. Data from the normal children allowed calculation of z scores for the atrial septal defect group matched for age, sex, pubertal stage and surface area. Maximal exercise performance was equal between control and atrial septal defect groups, however, the atrial septal defect group had a significantly greater effective pulmonary blood flow and stroke volume but a lower heart rate than controls at a given exercise stage. Stroke volume abnormalities were most closely related to duration of follow-up (29% of the variance explained, P < 0.01) rather than age at surgery. CONCLUSIONS: We were unable to show a medium term benefit from early surgery for an asymptomatic secundum atrial septal defect during exercise. The clinical relevance of the haemodynamic differences that do exist remains unclear.