PURPOSE: We analyzed current practice patterns and determined whether urologists are diagnosing and staging prostate cancer in accordance with one another and with available literature. MATERIALS AND METHODS: An anonymous questionnaire was mailed to 1,500 randomly selected practicing American Urological Association members throughout the United States, categorized according to practice setting and decade of residency training completion. RESULTS: There were 624 respondents (41.6%). Annual routine prostate cancer detection is being aimed toward the right of the age spectrum. More than half of respondents use age specific prostate specific antigen (PSA), while fewer than half use PSA density in determining need for biopsy. The vast majority will perform radical prostatectomy on patients whose age suggests that they will not benefit from surgery. High PSA values and Gleason scores often are disregarded as independent precluding factors when deciding to perform radical prostatectomy. Computerized tomography and radionuclide bone imaging are used routinely far in excess of what the literature suggests is appropriate. Regardless of preoperative staging results, most urologists still perform lymphadenectomy with all radical prostatectomies. CONCLUSIONS: Discrepancies exist in practice patterns between urologists as well as inconsistencies in logic within individuals. There is little variation between individuals in different practice settings. Our results reflect the often confusing and conflicting data published during the last decade.
PURPOSE: We analyzed current practice patterns and determined whether urologists are diagnosing and staging prostate cancer in accordance with one another and with available literature. MATERIALS AND METHODS: An anonymous questionnaire was mailed to 1,500 randomly selected practicing American Urological Association members throughout the United States, categorized according to practice setting and decade of residency training completion. RESULTS: There were 624 respondents (41.6%). Annual routine prostate cancer detection is being aimed toward the right of the age spectrum. More than half of respondents use age specific prostate specific antigen (PSA), while fewer than half use PSA density in determining need for biopsy. The vast majority will perform radical prostatectomy on patients whose age suggests that they will not benefit from surgery. High PSA values and Gleason scores often are disregarded as independent precluding factors when deciding to perform radical prostatectomy. Computerized tomography and radionuclide bone imaging are used routinely far in excess of what the literature suggests is appropriate. Regardless of preoperative staging results, most urologists still perform lymphadenectomy with all radical prostatectomies. CONCLUSIONS: Discrepancies exist in practice patterns between urologists as well as inconsistencies in logic within individuals. There is little variation between individuals in different practice settings. Our results reflect the often confusing and conflicting data published during the last decade.
Authors: Charlotte A Bolch; Haitao Chu; Stephanie Jarosek; Stephen R Cole; Sean Elliott; Beth Virnig Journal: BMC Med Res Methodol Date: 2017-07-10 Impact factor: 4.615
Authors: Ho Yun Lee; Hak Jong Lee; Seok-Soo Byun; Sang Eun Lee; Sung Kyu Hong; Seung Hyup Kim Journal: Korean J Radiol Date: 2009-04-22 Impact factor: 3.500