PURPOSE: To test the hypothesis that metastatic cervical lymph nodes arising from nasopharyngeal carcinoma (NPC) are more readily controlled with radiotherapy than comparable nodes from squamous cell carcinomas of other head and neck sites (SCC). METHODS AND MATERIALS: One hundred four NPC patients with metastatic cervical nodes (mean size of the largest node equals 4.1 cm) were randomly selected from radiation treatment files for two time periods, 1969-1976 and 1983-1988, when radiation alone was the first line treatment. Candidate controls were selected randomly from radiation treatment files of node positive squamous cell carcinomas arising from the oropharynx, hypopharynx, oral cavity or larynx who were also treated by radical radiation therapy as sole initial treatment in the 1970s and 1980s. Each NPC case was matched with a control using the size of the largest involved node as the matching criterion. The median follow-up of all 208 patients was 3 years (4.2 years in NPC cases and 1.4 years in the matched controls). For those who were alive at last follow-up, the median follow-up for both arms was 7.7 years (6.7 years in NPC cases and 10.2 years in the matched controls). Nodal control was evaluated by clinical neck examination in both arms. Nodal recurrence was defined as relapse or persistence of metastatic nodal disease from day 1 of radiotherapy treatment. RESULTS: Despite a similar mean delivered dose to involved neck nodes (52.9 Gy for the NPC group and 53.9 Gy for the matched controls), the SCC group had significantly worse nodal control with radiation when compared to the NPC group (p < 0.0001, relative risk 3.0, 95% [1.8, 5.1]). The 3-year nodal recurrence-free rate among NPC cases was 71 +/- 5%, compared to 43 +/- 5% among matched controls. CONCLUSION: The result of this study supports the hypothesis that metastatic cervical nodes from NPC are more readily controlled by irradiation than cervical nodes of similar size arising from other head and neck squamous cell carcinomas. Further study is required to explore the reasons for this apparent radiosensitivity.
PURPOSE: To test the hypothesis that metastatic cervical lymph nodes arising from nasopharyngeal carcinoma (NPC) are more readily controlled with radiotherapy than comparable nodes from squamous cell carcinomas of other head and neck sites (SCC). METHODS AND MATERIALS: One hundred four NPC patients with metastatic cervical nodes (mean size of the largest node equals 4.1 cm) were randomly selected from radiation treatment files for two time periods, 1969-1976 and 1983-1988, when radiation alone was the first line treatment. Candidate controls were selected randomly from radiation treatment files of node positive squamous cell carcinomas arising from the oropharynx, hypopharynx, oral cavity or larynx who were also treated by radical radiation therapy as sole initial treatment in the 1970s and 1980s. Each NPC case was matched with a control using the size of the largest involved node as the matching criterion. The median follow-up of all 208 patients was 3 years (4.2 years in NPC cases and 1.4 years in the matched controls). For those who were alive at last follow-up, the median follow-up for both arms was 7.7 years (6.7 years in NPC cases and 10.2 years in the matched controls). Nodal control was evaluated by clinical neck examination in both arms. Nodal recurrence was defined as relapse or persistence of metastatic nodal disease from day 1 of radiotherapy treatment. RESULTS: Despite a similar mean delivered dose to involved neck nodes (52.9 Gy for the NPC group and 53.9 Gy for the matched controls), the SCC group had significantly worse nodal control with radiation when compared to the NPC group (p < 0.0001, relative risk 3.0, 95% [1.8, 5.1]). The 3-year nodal recurrence-free rate among NPC cases was 71 +/- 5%, compared to 43 +/- 5% among matched controls. CONCLUSION: The result of this study supports the hypothesis that metastatic cervical nodes from NPC are more readily controlled by irradiation than cervical nodes of similar size arising from other head and neck squamous cell carcinomas. Further study is required to explore the reasons for this apparent radiosensitivity.
Authors: Guan Qiao Jin; Jun Yang; Li Dong Liu; Dan Ke Su; Duo Ping Wang; Sheng Fa Zhao; Zhi Ling Liao Journal: Medicine (Baltimore) Date: 2016-08 Impact factor: 1.889