STATEMENT OF PROBLEM: For laboratory production, it would be economically advisable to reuse excess cobalt-chromium alloys in manufacturing partial denture frameworks. Furthermore, discrepancies in fit, modifications, repairs, and also economic factors could lead to soldering procedure on the metal framework. PURPOSE: This study evaluated the influence of soldering and remelting procedures on the fatigue strength of Steldent, Dentorium, and Biosil cobalt-chromium alloys, as new alloys and in a mixture of new and previously casted alloy and when submitted or not submitted to conventional soldering procedure. MATERIAL AND METHODS: The soldering procedure was conducted in rod specimens 1.7 mm in diameter made with new, or with a mixture of new and reused alloy (n = 10 per group). The results were compared with those of intact rods. The fatigue strength was carried out with a cyclic testing machine simulating the insertion and the removal of partial dentures. After failure, the fracture surface was examined with a scanning electron microscope. RESULTS: The soldered specimens revealed 1119 loading cycles before fracture. These means differed statistically from those of intact alloys, which disclosed 2733 cycles before failure (p < 0.05). Statistical analysis indicated that the soldering procedure reduced fatigue strength of all new alloys or those in a mixture of new and previously casted alloys. It was also found that the soldering procedure may cause premature failure of a removable partial denture. Photomicrographs from fracture surfaces revealed the presence of inclusions and voids. Conversely, there were no significant differences between new and reused specimens, soldered or not (p > 0.05), which suggested that it may be possible to reuse excess cobalt-chromium alloys without compromising the fatigue strength of the framework.
STATEMENT OF PROBLEM: For laboratory production, it would be economically advisable to reuse excess cobalt-chromium alloys in manufacturing partial denture frameworks. Furthermore, discrepancies in fit, modifications, repairs, and also economic factors could lead to soldering procedure on the metal framework. PURPOSE: This study evaluated the influence of soldering and remelting procedures on the fatigue strength of Steldent, Dentorium, and Biosil cobalt-chromium alloys, as new alloys and in a mixture of new and previously casted alloy and when submitted or not submitted to conventional soldering procedure. MATERIAL AND METHODS: The soldering procedure was conducted in rod specimens 1.7 mm in diameter made with new, or with a mixture of new and reused alloy (n = 10 per group). The results were compared with those of intact rods. The fatigue strength was carried out with a cyclic testing machine simulating the insertion and the removal of partial dentures. After failure, the fracture surface was examined with a scanning electron microscope. RESULTS: The soldered specimens revealed 1119 loading cycles before fracture. These means differed statistically from those of intact alloys, which disclosed 2733 cycles before failure (p < 0.05). Statistical analysis indicated that the soldering procedure reduced fatigue strength of all new alloys or those in a mixture of new and previously casted alloys. It was also found that the soldering procedure may cause premature failure of a removable partial denture. Photomicrographs from fracture surfaces revealed the presence of inclusions and voids. Conversely, there were no significant differences between new and reused specimens, soldered or not (p > 0.05), which suggested that it may be possible to reuse excess cobalt-chromium alloys without compromising the fatigue strength of the framework.
Authors: André Gustavo Paleari; Cristina Dupim Presoto; Juliano Alencar Vasconcelos; José Maurício Dos Santos Nunes Reis; Lígia Antunes Pereira Pinelli; Regina Helena Barbosa Tavares da Silva; Cristiane Campos Costa Quishida Journal: Case Rep Dent Date: 2015-01-05