Is fibroblast heterogeneity relevant to the health, diseases, and treatments of periodontal tissues?

There are wide variations of gene expression and strikingly different responses to extracellular signals among different fibroblast populations. This has prompted a large number of in vitro studies which suggest that fibroblasts are not homogeneous but instead comprise multiple subpopulations with extensive site-to-site and intra-site variations. Conceivably, either fibroblasts are not all created equal, or, alternatively, discrete subpopulations may emerge in development, inflammatory lesions, or wound healing. While the heterogeneous nature of cultured fibroblasts has been known for some time, are these variations relevant to our understanding of the biology of oral tissues, their involvement in disease, and their response to therapy? Since fibroblasts are the predominant cell type in soft connective tissue matrices, the regulation of their proliferative, synthetic, and degradative behavior is likely to be important in tissue physiology and pathology. In this review, we use the current literature to assess whether fibroblast subpopulations really make a difference in the health and disease of periodontal tissues. We address the following questions: (1) Is fibroblast heterogeneity a real in vivo phenomenon? (2) How can we advance our knowledge of phenotypic variations and the regulation of fibroblast differentiation? (3) Could a knowledge of fibroblast heterogeneity have an impact on the development of new approaches to pathogenesis and the treatment of periodontal tissues?