S Hallan1, A Asberg, T H Edna. 1. Department of Clinical Chemistry, Innherred Hospital, Levanger, Norway.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate physicians' probability estimates of acute appendicitis based on structured collection of clinical data. DESIGN: Open prospective study. SETTING: District hospital, Norway. SUBJECTS: 304 patients admitted with suspected acute appendicitis. INTERVENTIONS: Initial diagnostic accuracy of physicians was compared with corresponding results from a computer model. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The estimated probabilities of appendicitis in different testing groups were analysed using receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves. RESULTS: Physicians' estimates had a mean area under ROC-curve of 0.81 (95% CI 0.79 to 0.82), not significantly different from the computer model. Both correlated well with the actual rate of appendicitis, but the physicians tended to overestimate the probability by 10%. CONCLUSION: Physicians' probability estimates perform rather well. Further attempts to implement a probabilistic approach in the diagnostic process of acute appendicitis therefore seem justified.
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate physicians' probability estimates of acute appendicitis based on structured collection of clinical data. DESIGN: Open prospective study. SETTING: District hospital, Norway. SUBJECTS: 304 patients admitted with suspected acute appendicitis. INTERVENTIONS: Initial diagnostic accuracy of physicians was compared with corresponding results from a computer model. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The estimated probabilities of appendicitis in different testing groups were analysed using receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves. RESULTS: Physicians' estimates had a mean area under ROC-curve of 0.81 (95% CI 0.79 to 0.82), not significantly different from the computer model. Both correlated well with the actual rate of appendicitis, but the physicians tended to overestimate the probability by 10%. CONCLUSION: Physicians' probability estimates perform rather well. Further attempts to implement a probabilistic approach in the diagnostic process of acute appendicitis therefore seem justified.
Authors: Afina S Glas; Bas A C M Pijnenburg; Jeroen G Lijmer; Kjell Bogaard; Roos Marnix A J de; Johannes N Keeman; Rudolf M J M Butzelaar; Patrick M M Bossuyt Journal: CMAJ Date: 2002-03-19 Impact factor: 8.262