A G Renouf1, M Kovacs, P Mukerji. 1. Humboldt County Mental Health, Children, Youth, and Family Services, Eureka, CA, USA.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To examine the relationship of depressive, conduct, and comorbid disorders and social functioning in psychiatrically referred youths. METHOD: Subjects were 94 boys and 67 girls (mean age at initial assessment = 11.5 years) who were repeatedly evaluated with standardized instruments during a mean interval of 4.4 years. On the basis of their diagnoses during the follow-up, children were designated as having had depressive, conduct, or both (comorbid) disorders or other conditions. Two domains of social functioning were assessed: social competence and self-esteem. RESULTS: Longitudinal analyses revealed that at any given point in time, depressive, conduct, and comorbid disorders were associated with low social competence and depressive disorder also was associated with low self-esteem. At the approximate age of 15 years, on average, children with a history of conduct or comorbid disorders had lower social competence than did children with a history of depressive disorder, but these groups endorsed similar levels of self-esteem. CONCLUSION: Some areas of social dysfunction associated with comorbid depressive and conduct disorders appear to reflect mostly the effects of conduct disorder. The latter condition has a more severe and longer-term impact on children's social competence than does depression. In addition, whereas depression has an adverse effect on self-esteem, this effect appears to be temporary.
OBJECTIVE: To examine the relationship of depressive, conduct, and comorbid disorders and social functioning in psychiatrically referred youths. METHOD: Subjects were 94 boys and 67 girls (mean age at initial assessment = 11.5 years) who were repeatedly evaluated with standardized instruments during a mean interval of 4.4 years. On the basis of their diagnoses during the follow-up, children were designated as having had depressive, conduct, or both (comorbid) disorders or other conditions. Two domains of social functioning were assessed: social competence and self-esteem. RESULTS: Longitudinal analyses revealed that at any given point in time, depressive, conduct, and comorbid disorders were associated with low social competence and depressive disorder also was associated with low self-esteem. At the approximate age of 15 years, on average, children with a history of conduct or comorbid disorders had lower social competence than did children with a history of depressive disorder, but these groups endorsed similar levels of self-esteem. CONCLUSION: Some areas of social dysfunction associated with comorbid depressive and conduct disorders appear to reflect mostly the effects of conduct disorder. The latter condition has a more severe and longer-term impact on children's social competence than does depression. In addition, whereas depression has an adverse effect on self-esteem, this effect appears to be temporary.
Authors: Bradley D Stein; Lisa Sontag-Padilla; Karen Chan Osilla; Michelle W Woodbridge; Courtney Ann Kase; Lisa H Jaycox; Elizabeth J D'Amico; Jennifer L Cerully; Nicole K Eberhart; Shari Golan Journal: Rand Health Q Date: 2013-02-28
Authors: Timothy E Wilens; MaryKate Martelon; Markus J P Kruesi; Tiffany Parcell; Diana Westerberg; Mary Schillinger; Martin Gignac; Joseph Biederman Journal: J Clin Psychiatry Date: 2009-02-10 Impact factor: 4.384
Authors: Rachel H Jacobs; Emily G Becker-Weidman; Mark A Reinecke; Neil Jordan; Susan G Silva; Paul Rohde; John S March Journal: J Clin Child Adolesc Psychol Date: 2010