BACKGROUND: The recent report of hepatitis B transmission between hematopoietic progenitor and putative stem cell (HPC) components stored in liquid nitrogen led to the questioning of whether evidence existed for similar contamination by bacterial or fungal elements. STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS: Microbial contamination rates were reviewed for 704 HPC components from 255 patients over an 18-month period. Five liquid nitrogen freezers were surveyed for microbial contamination. The literature was reviewed to ascertain the published experience of other laboratories with HPC component contamination first documented on thawing. RESULTS: Seven (1.2%) of 583 thawed components were found to be contaminated with a variety of environmental or waterborne organisms, despite a meticulous protocol to prevent contamination during thawing. All of these components had been sterile on cryopreservation. Literature review revealed a similar incidence of post-thaw contamination from other centers. Microbial survey of liquid nitrogen freezers revealed low-level contamination in four of five. The organisms represented were similar to those cultured from thawed HPC components. One freezer was heavily contaminated by Aspergillus species. CONCLUSION: Liquid nitrogen freezers are not sterile, and both the liquid and vapor phases are potential sources of microbial contamination of HPC components. While low-level contamination by environmental organisms may be common, the occurrence of heavy contamination by potential pathogens such as Aspergillus species suggests that monitoring of liquid nitrogen sterility may be indicated. Strategies to assess and prevent microbial transmission from liquid nitrogen to HPC components need further development.
BACKGROUND: The recent report of hepatitis B transmission between hematopoietic progenitor and putative stem cell (HPC) components stored in liquid nitrogen led to the questioning of whether evidence existed for similar contamination by bacterial or fungal elements. STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS: Microbial contamination rates were reviewed for 704 HPC components from 255 patients over an 18-month period. Five liquid nitrogen freezers were surveyed for microbial contamination. The literature was reviewed to ascertain the published experience of other laboratories with HPC component contamination first documented on thawing. RESULTS: Seven (1.2%) of 583 thawed components were found to be contaminated with a variety of environmental or waterborne organisms, despite a meticulous protocol to prevent contamination during thawing. All of these components had been sterile on cryopreservation. Literature review revealed a similar incidence of post-thaw contamination from other centers. Microbial survey of liquid nitrogen freezers revealed low-level contamination in four of five. The organisms represented were similar to those cultured from thawed HPC components. One freezer was heavily contaminated by Aspergillus species. CONCLUSION: Liquid nitrogen freezers are not sterile, and both the liquid and vapor phases are potential sources of microbial contamination of HPC components. While low-level contamination by environmental organisms may be common, the occurrence of heavy contamination by potential pathogens such as Aspergillus species suggests that monitoring of liquid nitrogen sterility may be indicated. Strategies to assess and prevent microbial transmission from liquid nitrogen to HPC components need further development.
Authors: H W G Baker; A Mijch; S Garland; S Crowe; M Dunne; D Edgar; G Clarke; P Foster; J Blood Journal: J Med Ethics Date: 2003-12 Impact factor: 2.903
Authors: Isobel Massie; Clare Selden; Humphrey Hodgson; Barry Fuller; Stephanie Gibbons; G John Morris Journal: Tissue Eng Part C Methods Date: 2014-02-24 Impact factor: 3.056