OBJECTIVE: To evaluate if methotrexate (MTX) can slow disease progression, as determined radiographically, in comparison to other disease modifying drugs in rheumatoid arthritis (RA) patients. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Pairs of hand and wrist radiographs from 30 patients treated with MTX and 30 treated with D-penicillamine (DP) were evaluated blindly and separately by two radiologists (A and B) using reference radiographs for scoring. A scale scoring similar to Larsen's standard radiographs with minor modifications was used. The radiographs studied were obtained at the beginning and 5 years after therapy in both groups. RESULTS: A significantly greater worsening was found in the DP-treated patients (p = 0.025), as compared to MTX patients. Methotrexate showed a slower rate of disease progression than DP. Furthermore, in the MTX group 15 patients remained radiographically stable, 9 worsened and 6 were healed. In contrast, in the DP group 22 patients remained radiographically stable, 8 worsened and none improved. CONCLUSIONS: The rate of radiographic progression in RA patients was lower in MTX-treated patients compared to those treated with DP. Six patients showed radiological improvement after MTX treatment. Therefore, it seems that MTX could be considered a disease modifying drug.
RCT Entities:
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate if methotrexate (MTX) can slow disease progression, as determined radiographically, in comparison to other disease modifying drugs in rheumatoid arthritis (RA) patients. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Pairs of hand and wrist radiographs from 30 patients treated with MTX and 30 treated with D-penicillamine (DP) were evaluated blindly and separately by two radiologists (A and B) using reference radiographs for scoring. A scale scoring similar to Larsen's standard radiographs with minor modifications was used. The radiographs studied were obtained at the beginning and 5 years after therapy in both groups. RESULTS: A significantly greater worsening was found in the DP-treated patients (p = 0.025), as compared to MTXpatients. Methotrexate showed a slower rate of disease progression than DP. Furthermore, in the MTX group 15 patients remained radiographically stable, 9 worsened and 6 were healed. In contrast, in the DP group 22 patients remained radiographically stable, 8 worsened and none improved. CONCLUSIONS: The rate of radiographic progression in RApatients was lower in MTX-treated patients compared to those treated with DP. Six patients showed radiological improvement after MTX treatment. Therefore, it seems that MTX could be considered a disease modifying drug.
Authors: C H van Jaarsveld; J W Jacobs; M J van der Veen; A A Blaauw; A A Kruize; D M Hofman; H L Brus; G A van Albada-Kuipers; A H Heurkens; E J ter Borg; H C Haanen; C van Booma-Frankfort; Y Schenk; J W Bijlsma Journal: Ann Rheum Dis Date: 2000-06 Impact factor: 19.103