OBJECTIVE: Estimation of the accuracy of 1, 5 and 10 y body weight recall. DESIGN: Comparison of information on body weight history from a patient questionnaire with measured body weights retrieved in general practitioners' records. SUBJECTS: Among 729 newly diagnosed diabetic patients record information on measured body weight was found for 86, 141 and 122 patients recalling their body weight 1,5 and 10 y ago, respectively. Median age was 63.6 y. Median body mass index was 31.1 kg/m2. RESULTS: No average deviation between 1 y body weight recall and the corresponding measured weights is observed, but 5 and 10 y recall underestimates the measured weights by 1.89 kg and 1.98 kg on an average, respectively. On the individual level the agreement is less satisfactory with increasing variability the further back in time you go. The recall does not vary with age and sex and it is independent of weight status, marital status, smoking habits and self-reported health status in this obese group of individuals. CONCLUSIONS: The findings suggest that data from three standard questions may contribute with useful information on near weight history, independent of age, sex and current body weight.
OBJECTIVE: Estimation of the accuracy of 1, 5 and 10 y body weight recall. DESIGN: Comparison of information on body weight history from a patient questionnaire with measured body weights retrieved in general practitioners' records. SUBJECTS: Among 729 newly diagnosed diabeticpatients record information on measured body weight was found for 86, 141 and 122 patientsrecalling their body weight 1,5 and 10 y ago, respectively. Median age was 63.6 y. Median body mass index was 31.1 kg/m2. RESULTS: No average deviation between 1 y body weight recall and the corresponding measured weights is observed, but 5 and 10 y recall underestimates the measured weights by 1.89 kg and 1.98 kg on an average, respectively. On the individual level the agreement is less satisfactory with increasing variability the further back in time you go. The recall does not vary with age and sex and it is independent of weight status, marital status, smoking habits and self-reported health status in this obese group of individuals. CONCLUSIONS: The findings suggest that data from three standard questions may contribute with useful information on near weight history, independent of age, sex and current body weight.
Authors: Jonathan M Kocarnik; Xinwei Hua; Sheetal Hardikar; Jamaica Robinson; Noralane M Lindor; Aung Ko Win; John L Hopper; Jane C Figueiredo; John D Potter; Peter T Campbell; Steven Gallinger; Michelle Cotterchio; Scott V Adams; Stacey A Cohen; Amanda I Phipps; Polly A Newcomb Journal: Cancer Date: 2017-08-25 Impact factor: 6.860
Authors: Namgyal L Kyulo; Synnove F Knutsen; Serena Tonstad; Gary E Fraser; Pramil N Singh Journal: Ann Epidemiol Date: 2012-08-03 Impact factor: 3.797