AIM: The true morbidity, cost and disability of medical therapy for ulcerative colitis are seldom delineated and are even less frequently compared to analogous parameters associated with surgical therapy. Therefore, we sought to assess and contrast medical versus surgical therapy for patients hospitalized due to severe ulcerative colitis. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Patients were matched for age, duration and severity of disease based upon Truelove and Witts' activity index, colonoscopic and histologic appearance and APACHE (Acute Psychological and Chronic Health Evaluation) II scores. Morbidity, cost and disability of 20 medically treated patients who required at least one hospital admission were compared to 20 patients treated by a three stage restorative proctocolectomy. Demographic data, number of hospital admissions, length of stay, total hospital charges including consultant's, surgeon's, and anesthesiologist's fees, morbidity of each approach and disability were assessed. Statistical analysis was performed using Mann-Whitney and Fisher exact tests. Significance was considered as P < 0.05. RESULTS: The mean age was 53.6 years in the medical group and 48.1 years in the surgical group (P = NS) and the average duration of disease was 10.5 years and 9.5 years, respectively (P = NS). The same severity of pancolitis was noted in both groups; APACHE scores of 13 and 14 in the medical and surgical groups, respectively, were noted. The total number of hospital admissions and total combined length of stay per patient in each group were not significant. Total mean hospital cost for the medical group was $28,477.00 per patient versus $33,041.00 for the three stage restorative proctocolectomy (P = NS). The mean duration of disability in the medical group was 6.4 months per patient versus 5.0 months in the surgical group (P = NS). However, patients in the medical group required more transfusions (25%) than did those in the surgical group (0%) (P < 0.05) and significant weight loss was more common in the medical group (45%) compared to the surgical group (5%) (P < 0.01). All patients in the surgical group were permanently weaned from steroids. Furthermore, while 65% of patients in the medical group had significant steroid-related complications, the major surgical complication rate was only 15% (P < 0.01). CONCLUSION: Medical treatment was associated with a significantly higher overall morbidity than surgical therapy. Additionally, a three stage restorative proctocolectomy was performed at no additional hospital cost or subsequent disability in patients with severe ulcerative colitis. The value of prolonged medical therapy in this select group of patients is questionable.
AIM: The true morbidity, cost and disability of medical therapy for ulcerative colitis are seldom delineated and are even less frequently compared to analogous parameters associated with surgical therapy. Therefore, we sought to assess and contrast medical versus surgical therapy for patients hospitalized due to severe ulcerative colitis. MATERIALS AND METHODS:Patients were matched for age, duration and severity of disease based upon Truelove and Witts' activity index, colonoscopic and histologic appearance and APACHE (Acute Psychological and Chronic Health Evaluation) II scores. Morbidity, cost and disability of 20 medically treated patients who required at least one hospital admission were compared to 20 patients treated by a three stage restorative proctocolectomy. Demographic data, number of hospital admissions, length of stay, total hospital charges including consultant's, surgeon's, and anesthesiologist's fees, morbidity of each approach and disability were assessed. Statistical analysis was performed using Mann-Whitney and Fisher exact tests. Significance was considered as P < 0.05. RESULTS: The mean age was 53.6 years in the medical group and 48.1 years in the surgical group (P = NS) and the average duration of disease was 10.5 years and 9.5 years, respectively (P = NS). The same severity of pancolitis was noted in both groups; APACHE scores of 13 and 14 in the medical and surgical groups, respectively, were noted. The total number of hospital admissions and total combined length of stay per patient in each group were not significant. Total mean hospital cost for the medical group was $28,477.00 per patient versus $33,041.00 for the three stage restorative proctocolectomy (P = NS). The mean duration of disability in the medical group was 6.4 months per patient versus 5.0 months in the surgical group (P = NS). However, patients in the medical group required more transfusions (25%) than did those in the surgical group (0%) (P < 0.05) and significant weight loss was more common in the medical group (45%) compared to the surgical group (5%) (P < 0.01). All patients in the surgical group were permanently weaned from steroids. Furthermore, while 65% of patients in the medical group had significant steroid-related complications, the major surgical complication rate was only 15% (P < 0.01). CONCLUSION: Medical treatment was associated with a significantly higher overall morbidity than surgical therapy. Additionally, a three stage restorative proctocolectomy was performed at no additional hospital cost or subsequent disability in patients with severe ulcerative colitis. The value of prolonged medical therapy in this select group of patients is questionable.
Authors: Stefan D Holubar; Kirsten Hall Long; Edward V Loftus; Bruce G Wolff; John H Pemberton; Robert R Cima Journal: Dis Colon Rectum Date: 2009-11 Impact factor: 4.585