PURPOSE: To compare the differences in practice and outcome of all radiologically and surgically placed central venous catheters retrospectively over a 2-year period simultaneously, at a single institution. METHODS: A total of 253 Hickman catheters were inserted in 209 patients; 120 were placed radiologically in 102 patients and 133 were placed surgically in 107 patients. The indication was chemotherapy in 76% of radiological and in 47% of surgical cases; the remainder were for total parenteral nutrition and venous access. RESULTS: There were 6 (4.5%) primary surgical failures and a further 17 (13%) surgical cases requiring multiple placement attempts. Pneumothorax occurred once (0.8%) surgically and four times (3.3%) radiologically. There were no radiological primary misplacements but there were five (3.7%) surgical ones. Catheter or central vein thrombosis occurred in four (3.3%) radiological and five (3.7%) surgical cases. The rate of infection per 1000 catheter-days was 1.9 in radiologically placed catheters and 4.0 in surgically placed ones (p < 0.001). Average catheter life-span was similar for the two placement methods (100 +/- 23 days). CONCLUSION: Radiological placement is consistently more reliable than surgical placement. There are fewer placement complications and fewer catheter infections overall.
PURPOSE: To compare the differences in practice and outcome of all radiologically and surgically placed central venous catheters retrospectively over a 2-year period simultaneously, at a single institution. METHODS: A total of 253 Hickman catheters were inserted in 209 patients; 120 were placed radiologically in 102 patients and 133 were placed surgically in 107 patients. The indication was chemotherapy in 76% of radiological and in 47% of surgical cases; the remainder were for total parenteral nutrition and venous access. RESULTS: There were 6 (4.5%) primary surgical failures and a further 17 (13%) surgical cases requiring multiple placement attempts. Pneumothorax occurred once (0.8%) surgically and four times (3.3%) radiologically. There were no radiological primary misplacements but there were five (3.7%) surgical ones. Catheter or central vein thrombosis occurred in four (3.3%) radiological and five (3.7%) surgical cases. The rate of infection per 1000 catheter-days was 1.9 in radiologically placed catheters and 4.0 in surgically placed ones (p < 0.001). Average catheter life-span was similar for the two placement methods (100 +/- 23 days). CONCLUSION: Radiological placement is consistently more reliable than surgical placement. There are fewer placement complications and fewer catheter infections overall.
Authors: E P Efstathopoulos; I Pantos; M Andreou; A Gkatzis; E Carinou; C Koukorava; N L Kelekis; E Brountzos Journal: Br J Radiol Date: 2011-01 Impact factor: 3.039
Authors: Karolin J Paprottka; Jana Voelklein; Tobias Waggershauser; Maximilian F Reiser; Philipp M Paprottka Journal: Radiol Med Date: 2019-06-07 Impact factor: 3.469
Authors: Boris Böll; Enrico Schalk; Dieter Buchheidt; Justin Hasenkamp; Michael Kiehl; Til Ramon Kiderlen; Matthias Kochanek; Michael Koldehoff; Philippe Kostrewa; Annika Y Claßen; Sibylle C Mellinghoff; Bernd Metzner; Olaf Penack; Markus Ruhnke; Maria J G T Vehreschild; Florian Weissinger; Hans-Heinrich Wolf; Meinolf Karthaus; Marcus Hentrich Journal: Ann Hematol Date: 2020-09-30 Impact factor: 3.673