What impact do annual public health reports have?

Each district health authority is required to produce an annual report on the health of their population. Although they consume considerable resources, there is little evidence as to their impact on their intended audiences. We describe the results of a postal survey of how these reports are viewed by health authority and local government managers in one region. Eighty-nine out of 139 responded (64%). Over half of the managers had read the reports in their entirety. Most were discussed by health authorities but few by relevant local government committees. There was some disagreement between directors of public health and other health authority managers about the impact of the reports on commissioning. The paper discusses the difficulties in evaluating the impact of annual public health reports. The survey reveals a fundamental disagreement about whether the intended audience should be health care purchasers or the public. This reflects an underlying tension about the role of public health and the debate about its independence.