Relationship of clonogenic capacity to plating efficiency and vital dye staining of human periodontal ligament cells: implications for tooth replantation.

The survival rate of avulsed permanent teeth following replantation is affected primarily by the duration of the extra-alveolar period and the nature of the storage conditions. These factors are believed to strongly affect the viability of periodontal ligament (PL) cells but in vitro assays of cell viability based on vital dye assays are only weakly correlated with the tooth survival rate after replantation. The aim of the present study was to examine the relative dependence of cell membrane integrity, attachment and clonogenic capacity of human PL cells on the temperature and duration of the extra-alveolar period and the type of storage medium. Twenty-four premolar teeth were extracted for orthodontic reasons from 9 patients 11-18 years of age. Teeth were maintained at 4 degrees C or 23 degrees C for 15, 30, 60 or 120 min in either milk or dry conditions. Cell membrane integrity was determined by BCECF/AM dye inclusion. Plating efficiency was determined by measurement of cell attachment at 3 and 6 h. The clonogenic capacity of progenitor cells was estimated by limiting dilution and colony counts. For all assays teeth stored in milk at 4 degrees C showed the highest percentages of BCECF positive, attached cells with clonogenic capacity. Increased storage time (15-120 min) was associated with a 50% relative reduction of BCECF staining and a 5-fold relative reduction of cell attachment regardless of storage conditions. However, the clonogenic capacity of progenitor cells decreased 25-fold over the same duration of storage. These data demonstrate that in vitro assays of clonogenic capacity are much more sensitive to extra-oral storage time and storage conditions than dye inclusion or cell attachment. We suggest that in comparison with in vitro measures of cell membrane integrity, the clonogenic capacity of PL cells is more closely liked to tooth survival rate, probably reflecting the capacity of PL progenitor cells to recolonize the root surface after replantation.