A comparison of direct, indirect, and fiberoptic laryngoscopy to evaluate vocal cord paralysis after thyroid surgery.

After thyroidectomy, the anesthesiologist usually performs a laryngoscopy to detect laryngeal edema and nerve palsies. The goal of this study was to compare three different methods of laryngeal examination after tracheal extubation of the patients. For that purpose, between 1990 and 1995, a prospective series of 1608 patients operated for thyroidectomy has been studied. The series was divided into 4 groups. In group I (n = 200), four anesthesiologists have evaluated the efficiency of the immediate postextubation direct laryngoscopy. In group II (n = 100), one anesthesiologist has compared the direct, indirect, and flexible laryngoscopies in every patient in a fixed and timed fashion. In group III (n = 100), the four examiners have evaluated the flexible laryngoscopy at a different timing so as to eliminate the possible temporal relationship of the ease of visualization in group II. In group IV (n = 1208), the four examiners have evaluated flexible laryngoscopy, on a large scale, at any time during the 1-h stay in the recovery room. Special attention was directed to the patients with known cardiovascular diseases. Direct and indirect laryngoscopies were only effective in 76 and 73%, respectively, of the patients, whereas flexible laryngoscopy was effective in 99.6% of them. Flexible laryngoscopy was easy to perform in 96.5% of the patients versus 65 and 55% with direct and indirect laryngoscopies. Finally, variations in monitored cardiovascular parameters were significantly lower with flexible and indirect laryngoscopies than with direct laryngoscopy. These mild variations induced by flexible laryngoscopy were well tolerated by patients with known cardiovascular diseases. Flexible laryngoscopy is the best method for an immediate laryngoscopic examination after thyroidectomy.