A M Gallon1. 1. Norfolk and Norwich Health Care NHS Trust, UK.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The use of acetylcysteine as a mucolytic agent is controversial. In 1962 it was claimed to be "the most effective agent ... for the liquefaction of ... secretions" but was subsequently taken off the market as a respirator solution. Normal saline, on the other hand, is becoming increasingly popular. A study was undertaken to determine which solution is more effective at clearing retained secretions following thoracotomy. METHODS: The study included 10 patients and was of single blind, two-way crossover design. Measurements taken before and after each treatment included sputum viscosity, difficulty of expectoration, weight of sputum expectorated, and oxygen saturation. RESULTS: Following nebulisation of acetylcysteine, sputum viscosity was reduced, difficulty of expectoration was reduced, the weight of sputum expectorated was increased, and oxygen saturation was increased. There were no changes after nebulisation of normal saline. CONCLUSIONS: This study shows that, following thoracotomy, nebulised acetylcysteine reduces sputum viscosity, making expectoration easier and improving oxygenation. Nebulised normal saline has no effect.
RCT Entities:
BACKGROUND: The use of acetylcysteine as a mucolytic agent is controversial. In 1962 it was claimed to be "the most effective agent ... for the liquefaction of ... secretions" but was subsequently taken off the market as a respirator solution. Normal saline, on the other hand, is becoming increasingly popular. A study was undertaken to determine which solution is more effective at clearing retained secretions following thoracotomy. METHODS: The study included 10 patients and was of single blind, two-way crossover design. Measurements taken before and after each treatment included sputum viscosity, difficulty of expectoration, weight of sputum expectorated, and oxygen saturation. RESULTS: Following nebulisation of acetylcysteine, sputum viscosity was reduced, difficulty of expectoration was reduced, the weight of sputum expectorated was increased, and oxygen saturation was increased. There were no changes after nebulisation of normal saline. CONCLUSIONS: This study shows that, following thoracotomy, nebulised acetylcysteine reduces sputum viscosity, making expectoration easier and improving oxygenation. Nebulised normal saline has no effect.
Authors: Young H Lim; Kristin M Tiemann; David A Hunstad; Mahmoud Elsabahy; Karen L Wooley Journal: Wiley Interdiscip Rev Nanomed Nanobiotechnol Date: 2016-03-25
Authors: Jung Soo Suk; Samuel K Lai; Nicholas J Boylan; Michelle R Dawson; Michael P Boyle; Justin Hanes Journal: Nanomedicine (Lond) Date: 2011-02 Impact factor: 5.307
Authors: Martin Koppitz; Charlotte Eschenburg; Emilia Salzmann; Martin Rosewich; Ralf Schubert; Stefan Zielen Journal: PLoS One Date: 2016-06-16 Impact factor: 3.240
Authors: Sophia M van der Hoeven; Jan M Binnekade; Corianne A J M de Borgie; Frank H Bosch; Henrik Endeman; Janneke Horn; Nicole P Juffermans; Nardo J M van der Meer; Maruschka P Merkus; Hazra S Moeniralam; Bart van Silfhout; Mathilde Slabbekoorn; Willemke Stilma; Jan Willem Wijnhoven; Marcus J Schultz; Frederique Paulus Journal: Trials Date: 2015-09-02 Impact factor: 2.279