Deficient and delayed primary palatal fusion and mesenchymal bridge formation in cleft lip-liable strains of mice.

During mammalian primary palate formation, the facial prominences enlarge around the nasal pit, fuse and then merge to give rise to the tissue of the upper lip and premaxillary region. The mechanisms involved in successful primary palate formation and how they are affected in the cleft lip genotype remain poorly understood. The purpose of this study was to compare morphometrically internal development and growth of the primary palate in five different strains of mice. Two of the strains, BALB/cByJ, and C57BL/6J, have normal primary palate development, and three of the strains, A/J, A/WySn, and CL/Fr, have stable frequencies of cleft lip associated with genotype. In the present study, frequencies of 4, 23, and 24%, respectively, were observed on day 13. For palatal growth analysis, embryos were collected on days 10 and 11, staged by number of tail somites (TS), and the heads were photographed and serially sectioned for measurement of primary palate components. The heights of the epithelial seam and the mesenchyme bridge between the facial prominences were measured on serial sections and areas of contact were calculated. The position or depth of the maxillary prominence was determined from the number of frontal sections from its tip to the rostral end of the nasal fin. Analysis of measurements showed that in cleft lip strains enlargement of the epithelial seam and replacement of epithelia by a mesenchymal bridge were both delayed relative to somite stages. Measurements from day 11 embryos with complete failure of contact were excluded from the growth analyses. The mesenchymal bridge formed at 12--13 TS in noncleft strains, 14 TS in the A/J strains with higher cleft lip frequency, and 15--17 TS in A/WySn and CL/Fr strains with higher cleft lip frequency. Forward growth of the maxillary prominence was highly correlated with the primary palate measurements and mesenchymal bridge formation in all strains. In both cleft and noncleft strains, the primitive choanae open at 18--20 TS and the medial nasal region narrows with advancing embryonic development. As a result, cleft lip-liable strains have a narrower window in development in which a robust mesenchymal bridge must form, thus increasing the liability to cleft lip.