Comparative analysis of various proposed models of the receptor-bound conformation of H-Tyr-Tic-Phe-OH related delta-opioid antagonists.

A molecular mechanics study (grid search and energy minimization) was performed with six delta opioid peptide antagonists containing a tetrahydroisoquinoline-3-carboxylic acid (Tic) residue in the 2-position of the peptide sequence. Compounds examined were the highly potent and selective TIP(P) peptides H-Tyr-Tic-Phe-OH (TIP), H-Tyr-Tic psi[CH2-NH]Phe-OH (TIP[psi]), H-Tyr-Tic-Phe-Phe-OH (TIPP), and H-Tyr-Tic psi[CH2-NH]Phe-Phe-OH (TIPP[psi]), and the weakly active analogues H-Tyr-Tic-NH2 and H-Tyr-Tic-Ala-OH. Low energy conformers of the peptides were examined for their compatibility with three proposed models of the delta receptor-bound conformation. Model 1, based on spatial overlap of the Tyr1 and Phe3 aromatic rings and N-terminal amino group of the peptides with the corresponding aromatic rings and nitrogen atom of the nonpeptide delta-antagonist naltrindole, was ruled out because of the demonstrated importance of the Tic2 aromatic ring for delta antagonism and because of the somewhat elevated energies of the conformers consistent with this model. Models of the receptor-bound conformation based on superimposition of the Tyr1 and Tic2 aromatic rings and N-terminal amino group of the peptides with the corresponding moieties in naltrindole included an all-trans peptide bond conformer [model 2, proposed by B.C. Wilkes and P.W. Schiller (1994) Biopolymers, Vol. 34, pp. 1213-1219] and a conformer with a cis peptide bond between the Tyr1 and Tic2 residues (model 3, originally proposed by P.A. Temussi et al. [(1994) Biochemical and Biophysical Research Communications, Vol. 198, pp. 933-939]. For all six peptides low energy conformers consistent with both model 2 and model 3 were identified; however, peptide conformers corresponding to model 2 showed better coplanarity of the Tyr1 aromatic ring and the phenol ring in naltrindole than peptide conformers corresponding to model 3. Both models remain plausible candidate structures for the receptor-bound conformation of delta antagonists of the TIP(P) class. TIP(P) analogues containing additional conformational constraints need to be developed in order to arrive at a unique model.