Both O4-methylthymine and O4-ethylthymine preferentially form alkyl T.G pairs that do not block in vitro replication in a defined sequence.

The mutagenic potential of O4-methylthymine (m4T) and O4-ethylthymine (e4T) was determined by a primer extension assay on a 25mer oligonucleotide containing a single site-specifically incorporated modified thymine. The e4T-containing oligonucleotide was prepared by using a new synthetic procedure suitable for large alkyl groups on thymine. The second-order rate constants, K(app)m and V(rel)max, permitted calculation of the frequency of formation and extension of modified base pairs compared to Watson-Crick pairing. With both m4T and e4T, the T.G type pairing was formed at least 10-fold more frequently than the nonmutagenic alkyl T.A pairing. However, there was a small but reproducible preference for m4T.G pairing. In both cases T-->C transitions would result. There was no evidence for formation of alkyl T.C or T.T. These data suggest that reported T-->A transversions by ethylation are not likely to result from O4-alkylthymine. In contrast to insertion, extension beyond alkylthymine under kinetic conditions did not occur with alkyl T.A. but only with the alkyl T.G termini. For this latter T.G type pairing, the larger ethyl group did not hinder extension compared to that of the methyl group, in the sequence studied. Under non-limiting conditions of dNTP concentration and time, complete replication could be demonstrated for both methyl- and ethyl-containing oligonucleotides. We conclude that the increase in size of the alkyl group from methyl to ethyl does not significantly affect the mutagenic potential and type of mutations of O4-alkylthymine in vitro.