BACKGROUND: Although flow cytometry (FCM) has become a widely used technique for the measurement of DNA content in solid tumors, the correlation of ploidy analysis by FCM with cytogenetic analysis (CGA) is not well described. The sensitivities of G-banded CGA and FCM were compared to determine the accuracy of the DNA index value (DI) as a measurement of chromosome number. METHODS: Tumor specimens from 56 pediatric cases were analyzed for DNA content by both FCM and CGA. Nuclei for FCM were prepared from archival tissue in 53 specimens using a modification of the Hedley technique and from fresh tissue in 3 specimens. Metaphase chromosomes for CGA were prepared from standard solid tumor harvests and Giemsa-trypsin banding procedures. Ploidy status for this study was defined as (1) diploid--DI between 0.97 and 1.03 by FCM or chromosome number +/- 2 from normal by CGA (44-48); and (2) aneuploid--DI < 0.97 or > 1.03 by FCM or total chromosomes < 44 or > 48 by CGA. RESULTS: Forty-nine of the 56 pediatric specimens were evaluable by both techniques. Concordance was observed in 34 cases (69%) between the two techniques in assigning similar ploidy status to a tumor (22 diploid and 12 aneuploid). It also was observed that among the aneuploid concordant cases, the actual DI obtained from archival material could predict total chromosome number with 95% accuracy. The 15 discordant cases showed a distinct aneuploid population by FCM, but were diploid by CGA. CONCLUSIONS: A correlation of 69% was obtained between both techniques to assign a similar ploidy status (diploid versus aneuploid) in 56 pediatric solid tumors. These results support the combined use of CGA and FCM to obtain the most complete analysis of DNA content and chromosome abnormalities in pediatric solid tumors. FCM on formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissue can be used to measure total DNA content.
BACKGROUND: Although flow cytometry (FCM) has become a widely used technique for the measurement of DNA content in solid tumors, the correlation of ploidy analysis by FCM with cytogenetic analysis (CGA) is not well described. The sensitivities of G-banded CGA and FCM were compared to determine the accuracy of the DNA index value (DI) as a measurement of chromosome number. METHODS:Tumor specimens from 56 pediatric cases were analyzed for DNA content by both FCM and CGA. Nuclei for FCM were prepared from archival tissue in 53 specimens using a modification of the Hedley technique and from fresh tissue in 3 specimens. Metaphase chromosomes for CGA were prepared from standard solid tumor harvests and Giemsa-trypsin banding procedures. Ploidy status for this study was defined as (1) diploid--DI between 0.97 and 1.03 by FCM or chromosome number +/- 2 from normal by CGA (44-48); and (2) aneuploid--DI < 0.97 or > 1.03 by FCM or total chromosomes < 44 or > 48 by CGA. RESULTS: Forty-nine of the 56 pediatric specimens were evaluable by both techniques. Concordance was observed in 34 cases (69%) between the two techniques in assigning similar ploidy status to a tumor (22 diploid and 12 aneuploid). It also was observed that among the aneuploid concordant cases, the actual DI obtained from archival material could predict total chromosome number with 95% accuracy. The 15 discordant cases showed a distinct aneuploid population by FCM, but were diploid by CGA. CONCLUSIONS: A correlation of 69% was obtained between both techniques to assign a similar ploidy status (diploid versus aneuploid) in 56 pediatric solid tumors. These results support the combined use of CGA and FCM to obtain the most complete analysis of DNA content and chromosome abnormalities in pediatric solid tumors. FCM on formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissue can be used to measure total DNA content.
Authors: S J Hayes; S A Hinchliffe; J D Pope; P Eccles; M M Khine; R O Kaschula; A Sampedro; D van Velzen Journal: Virchows Arch Date: 1995 Impact factor: 4.064