The conserved ninth C-terminal heptad in thyroid hormone and retinoic acid receptors mediates diverse responses by affecting heterodimer but not homodimer formation.

The receptors for thyroid hormone (T3R), all-trans-retinoic acid (RAR), and 9-cis-retinoic acid (RXR) bind DNA response elements as homo- and heterodimers. The ligand-binding domains of these receptors contain nine conserved heptads proposed to play a role in dimerization. Mutant receptors with changes in the first or last hydrophobic amino acids in the highly conserved ninth heptad of chick T3R alpha [cT3R alpha(L365R) and cT3R(L372R)] and human RAR alpha (hRAR alpha) [hRAR(M377R) and hRAR(L384R)] reveal that this heptad is essential for certain heterodimeric interactions and for diverse functional activities. Without ligands, wild-type receptors form both homodimers and heterodimers, while these mutants form only homodimers. Surprisingly, the cognate ligand for each mutant enables heterodimer formation between cT3R(L365R) and RAR or RXR and between hRAR(M377R) and T3R or RXR. Both cT3R(L365R) and hRAR(M377R) mediate ligand-dependent transcriptional regulation. However, unlike the wild-type receptor, non-ligand-associated cT3R(L365R) does not suppress the basal activity of certain promoters containing thyroid hormone response elements, suggesting that this silencing effect of T3R is mediated by unliganded heterodimers of T3R and endogenous RXR or related factors. Heterodimerization is also necessary for the strong ligand-independent inhibition between T3R and RAR on a common response element, since the ninth-heptad mutants function as poor inhibitors. However, with a T3R-specific response element, hRAR(M377R) acts as a retinoic acid-dependent inhibitor of cT3R, indicating the importance of heterodimerization for this inhibition. Our studies also suggest that the ninth heptad is necessary for the dominant inhibition of wild-type T3Rs by mutant T3Rs, as has been found for the thyroid hormone-resistant syndrome in humans. Thus, the ninth heptad repeat is required for heterodimerization, suppression of basal promoter activity, and dominant negative effects of T3R and RAR. Lastly, the finding that cT3R(L365R) and hRAR(M377R) require ligands for heterodimer formation also raises the possibility that heterodimeric interactions are mediated by the ninth heptad without ligands but by a second region of these receptors with ligands.