A Sheikh1, T Brogan. 1. Department of Pediatrics, University of California, Davis, Medical Center, Sacramento 95817.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: The dismal survival rates of cardiac arrest in children managed with conventional closed-chest cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CC-CPR) have renewed interest in the use of open-chest CPR (OC-CPR). We determined the efficacy of the early use of OC-CPR in children after cardiac arrest. METHODS: A retrospective review of emergency medical services (EMS) and hospital records revealed 27 children who were brought to the emergency department under CPR after blunt trauma. RESULTS: Twelve children had CC-CPR and 15 children underwent OC-CPR. Prehospital resuscitation and transport of both groups of children was excellent by current standards, and OC-CPR was performed within 5 minutes of arrival in the emergency department. CPR was successful with restoration of spontaneous circulation in 17% of children after CC-CPR, whereas 20% of children had restoration of spontaneous circulation after OC-CPR. This difference was not statistically significant. None of the children regained consciousness or survived to discharge. The hospital charges for patients who underwent OC-CPR were significantly higher (P = .005). Less than 30% of the hospital charges were reimbursed in both groups. CONCLUSIONS: OC-CPR does not improve survival in children who sustain cardiac arrest and receive CPR for more than 20 minutes in the field. Under these circumstances OC-CPR is an expensive and futile procedure to undertake.
OBJECTIVE: The dismal survival rates of cardiac arrest in children managed with conventional closed-chest cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CC-CPR) have renewed interest in the use of open-chest CPR (OC-CPR). We determined the efficacy of the early use of OC-CPR in children after cardiac arrest. METHODS: A retrospective review of emergency medical services (EMS) and hospital records revealed 27 children who were brought to the emergency department under CPR after blunt trauma. RESULTS: Twelve children had CC-CPR and 15 children underwent OC-CPR. Prehospital resuscitation and transport of both groups of children was excellent by current standards, and OC-CPR was performed within 5 minutes of arrival in the emergency department. CPR was successful with restoration of spontaneous circulation in 17% of children after CC-CPR, whereas 20% of children had restoration of spontaneous circulation after OC-CPR. This difference was not statistically significant. None of the children regained consciousness or survived to discharge. The hospital charges for patients who underwent OC-CPR were significantly higher (P = .005). Less than 30% of the hospital charges were reimbursed in both groups. CONCLUSIONS:OC-CPR does not improve survival in children who sustain cardiac arrest and receive CPR for more than 20 minutes in the field. Under these circumstances OC-CPR is an expensive and futile procedure to undertake.
Authors: Monica E Kleinman; Allan R de Caen; Leon Chameides; Dianne L Atkins; Robert A Berg; Marc D Berg; Farhan Bhanji; Dominique Biarent; Robert Bingham; Ashraf H Coovadia; Mary Fran Hazinski; Robert W Hickey; Vinay M Nadkarni; Amelia G Reis; Antonio Rodriguez-Nunez; James Tibballs; Arno L Zaritsky; David Zideman Journal: Circulation Date: 2010-10-19 Impact factor: 29.690
Authors: Monica E Kleinman; Allan R de Caen; Leon Chameides; Dianne L Atkins; Robert A Berg; Marc D Berg; Farhan Bhanji; Dominique Biarent; Robert Bingham; Ashraf H Coovadia; Mary Fran Hazinski; Robert W Hickey; Vinay M Nadkarni; Amelia G Reis; Antonio Rodriguez-Nunez; James Tibballs; Arno L Zaritsky; David Zideman Journal: Pediatrics Date: 2010-10-18 Impact factor: 7.124
Authors: Andrew R Yates; Robert M Sutton; Ron W Reeder; Kathleen L Meert; John T Berger; Richard Fernandez; David Wessel; Christopher J Newth; Joseph A Carcillo; Patrick S McQuillen; Rick E Harrison; Frank W Moler; Murray M Pollack; Todd C Carpenter; Daniel A Notterman; J Michael Dean; Vinay M Nadkarni; Robert A Berg Journal: Pediatr Crit Care Med Date: 2019-12 Impact factor: 3.624