V Patel1, G de Moore. 1. Department of Psychiatry, Westmead Hospital, NSW, Australia.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Stabbing is an uncommon method of self-harm that has not been previously described in the psychiatric literature. The aim of this study was to describe the clinical features and management of patients presenting with self-inflicted stab injuries. METHOD: Case notes of all patients presenting with deliberate self-inflicted injuries during a 2-year period to a teaching general hospital were screened to identify the sample of interest. Clinical data were then collected by means of a detailed case-note study. RESULTS: Ten patients who deliberately stabbed themselves were identified. The patients fell into two distinct clinical groups: the first consisted mostly of young men with antisocial personalities who were intoxicated at the time of the self-stabbing and who reported ambivalent suicidal intent; the second consisted of psychotic patients, most of whom were actively ill at the time of the self-stabbing, and who reported clear suicidal intent. Patients in the first group were noncompliant with treatment and difficult to engage; those in the second group needed psychiatric hospitalization and often responded to antipsychotic medication. CONCLUSION: Persons who stab themselves tend to fall into two clinical groups that have different diagnoses and management. Distinctions between violent suicidal behavior and self-mutilation are blurred because suicidal intent can be difficult to assess.
BACKGROUND: Stabbing is an uncommon method of self-harm that has not been previously described in the psychiatric literature. The aim of this study was to describe the clinical features and management of patients presenting with self-inflicted stab injuries. METHOD: Case notes of all patients presenting with deliberate self-inflicted injuries during a 2-year period to a teaching general hospital were screened to identify the sample of interest. Clinical data were then collected by means of a detailed case-note study. RESULTS: Ten patients who deliberately stabbed themselves were identified. The patients fell into two distinct clinical groups: the first consisted mostly of young men with antisocial personalities who were intoxicated at the time of the self-stabbing and who reported ambivalent suicidal intent; the second consisted of psychoticpatients, most of whom were actively ill at the time of the self-stabbing, and who reported clear suicidal intent. Patients in the first group were noncompliant with treatment and difficult to engage; those in the second group needed psychiatric hospitalization and often responded to antipsychotic medication. CONCLUSION:Persons who stab themselves tend to fall into two clinical groups that have different diagnoses and management. Distinctions between violent suicidal behavior and self-mutilation are blurred because suicidal intent can be difficult to assess.
Authors: Aman Banerjee; Hannah Y Zhou; Katherine B Kelly; Bianca D Downs; John J Como; Jeffrey A Claridge Journal: Am J Surg Date: 2013-03 Impact factor: 2.565
Authors: Jeffrey J Leow; Pravin Lingam; Vanessa W Lim; Karen T S Go; Ming Terk Chiu; Li Tserng Teo Journal: Singapore Med J Date: 2016-01 Impact factor: 1.858