OBJECTIVE: To establish explicit criteria for MR imaging diagnosis of discoid lateral menisci of the knee. SUBJECTS: Materials included surgically proved 38 discoid lateral menisci and 36 normal lateral menisci of adult patients. A discriminant analysis was used to identify the optimal cut-off points of the following eight parameters: (1) transverse width of a lateral meniscus on the coronal image at the midportion of a meniscal body; (2) ratio of transverse width between a lateral meniscus and a tibia; (3) height of the lateral margin of a lateral meniscus; (4) difference in height between lateral and medial menisci; (5) transverse area of a lateral meniscus; (6) the number of consecutive sagittal slices demonstrating continuity of the meniscus between the anterior and posterior horns (bow tie appearance); (7) height of the anterior horn of a lateral meniscus on the sagittal image; (8) height of the posterior horn of a lateral meniscus on the same sagittal image. RESULTS: The transverse width of a lateral meniscus on the coronal image was the best parameter, with a cut-off point of 14 mm. Using this criterium, 33 knees of 38 discoid lateral menisci and all 36 normal menisci were correctly identified, yielding an overall accuracy of 93%. CONCLUSION: A discoid lateral meniscus should be present if the transverse width of a lateral meniscus at the midportion of a meniscal body exceeds 14 mm, independent of the tibial width.
OBJECTIVE: To establish explicit criteria for MR imaging diagnosis of discoid lateral menisci of the knee. SUBJECTS: Materials included surgically proved 38 discoid lateral menisci and 36 normal lateral menisci of adult patients. A discriminant analysis was used to identify the optimal cut-off points of the following eight parameters: (1) transverse width of a lateral meniscus on the coronal image at the midportion of a meniscal body; (2) ratio of transverse width between a lateral meniscus and a tibia; (3) height of the lateral margin of a lateral meniscus; (4) difference in height between lateral and medial menisci; (5) transverse area of a lateral meniscus; (6) the number of consecutive sagittal slices demonstrating continuity of the meniscus between the anterior and posterior horns (bow tie appearance); (7) height of the anterior horn of a lateral meniscus on the sagittal image; (8) height of the posterior horn of a lateral meniscus on the same sagittal image. RESULTS: The transverse width of a lateral meniscus on the coronal image was the best parameter, with a cut-off point of 14 mm. Using this criterium, 33 knees of 38 discoid lateral menisci and all 36 normal menisci were correctly identified, yielding an overall accuracy of 93%. CONCLUSION: A discoid lateral meniscus should be present if the transverse width of a lateral meniscus at the midportion of a meniscal body exceeds 14 mm, independent of the tibial width.
Authors: Sang Hee Choi; Jin Hwan Ahn; Kang Il Kim; Suk-Kyeong Ji; Su Min Kang; Jung Suk Kim; Sang Hak Lee Journal: Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc Date: 2014-03-12 Impact factor: 4.342