BACKGROUND: Patients with acute lower abdominal pain remain a diagnostic challenge. Although acute appendicitis is the most common surgical disorder, its accurate and timely diagnosis can be difficult. Historically, females of childbearing age are the most difficult patient group in whom to make the diagnosis of acute appendicitis; they have reported negative laparotomy rates ranging from 30 to 50 percent. Tc-99 hexamethylpropyleneamineoxide (HMPAO) labeled leukocyte scan has previously been shown to be very accurate in the detection of acute appendicitis. STUDY DESIGN: One year ago, a blinded study using Tc-99 HMPAO labeled leukocyte scan was reported for the detection of acute appendicitis. That study consisted of 27 patients who presented with abdominal pain. The present report is a follow-up study of 37 additional patients in whom the Tc-99 HMPAO leukocyte scan was used to diagnose or discount acute appendicitis. RESULTS: Twenty-seven patients had histologically proved acute appendicitis. Twenty-three of these were correctly diagnosed using the leukocyte scan, for a sensitivity rate of 85 percent. The overall specificity rate was 93 percent, with an overall accuracy rate of 89 percent. Thirty-one of 64 patients were females of reproductive age and represented 56 percent of all patients in the study with appendicitis. In this group, the Tc-99 HMPAO leukocyte scan had a sensitivity rate of 87 percent, specificity rate of 92 percent, and an overall accuracy rate of 89 percent. The Tc-99 HMPAO leukocyte scan also proved to be valuable in the diagnosis of other intra-abdominal inflammatory conditions. Eight scans interpreted as negative for acute appendicitis were positive for other conditions, including five that were positive for diverticulitis, one for a tumor, one for a tubo-ovarian abscess, and one for a small intestinal infarction. CONCLUSIONS: The Tc-99 HMPAO leukocyte scan is a highly accurate, diagnostic, and minimally invasive test of use in patients with abdominal pain of unclear cause, in which the differential diagnosis includes acute appendicitis. It is of particular value in females of childbearing age, in whom the cause of lower abdominal pain is unclear.
BACKGROUND:Patients with acute lower abdominal pain remain a diagnostic challenge. Although acute appendicitis is the most common surgical disorder, its accurate and timely diagnosis can be difficult. Historically, females of childbearing age are the most difficult patient group in whom to make the diagnosis of acute appendicitis; they have reported negative laparotomy rates ranging from 30 to 50 percent. Tc-99 hexamethylpropyleneamineoxide (HMPAO) labeled leukocyte scan has previously been shown to be very accurate in the detection of acute appendicitis. STUDY DESIGN: One year ago, a blinded study using Tc-99 HMPAO labeled leukocyte scan was reported for the detection of acute appendicitis. That study consisted of 27 patients who presented with abdominal pain. The present report is a follow-up study of 37 additional patients in whom the Tc-99 HMPAO leukocyte scan was used to diagnose or discount acute appendicitis. RESULTS: Twenty-seven patients had histologically proved acute appendicitis. Twenty-three of these were correctly diagnosed using the leukocyte scan, for a sensitivity rate of 85 percent. The overall specificity rate was 93 percent, with an overall accuracy rate of 89 percent. Thirty-one of 64 patients were females of reproductive age and represented 56 percent of all patients in the study with appendicitis. In this group, the Tc-99 HMPAO leukocyte scan had a sensitivity rate of 87 percent, specificity rate of 92 percent, and an overall accuracy rate of 89 percent. The Tc-99 HMPAO leukocyte scan also proved to be valuable in the diagnosis of other intra-abdominal inflammatory conditions. Eight scans interpreted as negative for acute appendicitis were positive for other conditions, including five that were positive for diverticulitis, one for a tumor, one for a tubo-ovarian abscess, and one for a small intestinal infarction. CONCLUSIONS: The Tc-99 HMPAO leukocyte scan is a highly accurate, diagnostic, and minimally invasive test of use in patients with abdominal pain of unclear cause, in which the differential diagnosis includes acute appendicitis. It is of particular value in females of childbearing age, in whom the cause of lower abdominal pain is unclear.
Authors: Eric B Rypins; Samuel L Kipper; Frederick Weiland; Charles Neal; Bruce Line; Robert McDonald; Andrew Klonecke; Bruce Barron; Christopher Palestro; Alan Waxman; Stephen Bunker; Robert F Carretta Journal: Ann Surg Date: 2002-02 Impact factor: 12.969