OBJECTIVE: To assess ipsilateral spermatogenesis in men with malignant and benign nongerm cell tumors of the testis. DESIGN, PATIENTS: Histologic review of radical orchiectomy specimens performed for 20 men with malignant nongerm cell tumors and 15 with benign testicular lesions, including five Leydig cell tumors with benign clinical features. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Degree of spermatogenesis was determined on a 1 to 10 scale, with 10 representing mature sperm within a seminiferous tubule. For each patient "near" and "far" scores were determined by obtaining the mean score of 50 tubules adjacent (< 3 mm) to the tumor and 50 tubules distant (> 3 mm) from the tumor, respectively. RESULTS: Total, near, and far scores were all lower for malignant tumors than for benign lesions. Scores for Leydig cell tumors were similar to benign lesions. Malignant tumors demonstrated a gradient effect, with greatest impairment of spermatogenesis occurring adjacent to tumor. In contrast, a distinction between near and far scores was not observed for benign lesions or Leydig cell tumors. CONCLUSIONS: Malignant nongerm cell tumors of the testis were associated with significant impairment of ipsilateral spermatogenesis, particularly in areas adjacent to tumor. These findings are similar to those observed for testicular germ cell tumors, suggesting a generalized negative influence on ipsilateral spermatogenesis by malignant tumors.
OBJECTIVE: To assess ipsilateral spermatogenesis in men with malignant and benign nongerm cell tumors of the testis. DESIGN, PATIENTS: Histologic review of radical orchiectomy specimens performed for 20 men with malignant nongerm cell tumors and 15 with benign testicular lesions, including five Leydig cell tumors with benign clinical features. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Degree of spermatogenesis was determined on a 1 to 10 scale, with 10 representing mature sperm within a seminiferous tubule. For each patient "near" and "far" scores were determined by obtaining the mean score of 50 tubules adjacent (< 3 mm) to the tumor and 50 tubules distant (> 3 mm) from the tumor, respectively. RESULTS: Total, near, and far scores were all lower for malignant tumors than for benign lesions. Scores for Leydig cell tumors were similar to benign lesions. Malignant tumors demonstrated a gradient effect, with greatest impairment of spermatogenesis occurring adjacent to tumor. In contrast, a distinction between near and far scores was not observed for benign lesions or Leydig cell tumors. CONCLUSIONS: Malignant nongerm cell tumors of the testis were associated with significant impairment of ipsilateral spermatogenesis, particularly in areas adjacent to tumor. These findings are similar to those observed for testicular germ cell tumors, suggesting a generalized negative influence on ipsilateral spermatogenesis by malignant tumors.