P C Young1. 1. Department of Pediatrics, University of Utah School of Medicine, Salt Lake City 84132, USA.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To determine primary-care pediatricians' management of febrile infants and compare them with published practice guidelines. DESIGN: Case scenarios were sent to 194 primary-care pediatricians in Utah, describing three febrile infants, ages 21 days, 60 days, and 20 months, corresponding to the three age groups: 0 to 28 days; 29 to 90 days, and 91 days to 36 months for which the guidelines suggest different strategies. RESULTS: Ninety-four pediatricians responded (response rate, 48%). Compliance with the guidelines was 39% for the 21 day old, 9.6% for the 60 day old, and 75% for the 20 month old. No respondent followed the guidelines for all three infants. Performance of tests to determine if an infant was low risk varied from 3%, for a stool white cell examination in a febrile 2 month old with diarrhea, to 75% for a complete blood count in a 20 month old with a temperature of 40 degrees C. Compliance did not differ between private and academic practitioners. Those in practice less than 5 years (n = 22) were more likely than those with more experience to follow the guidelines for the 21 day old but not the other two infants. CONCLUSION: Primary-care pediatricians in Utah manage febrile infants with fewer laboratory tests and less hospitalization than recent practice guidelines developed by an expert panel of academic specialists suggest.
OBJECTIVE: To determine primary-care pediatricians' management of febrile infants and compare them with published practice guidelines. DESIGN: Case scenarios were sent to 194 primary-care pediatricians in Utah, describing three febrile infants, ages 21 days, 60 days, and 20 months, corresponding to the three age groups: 0 to 28 days; 29 to 90 days, and 91 days to 36 months for which the guidelines suggest different strategies. RESULTS: Ninety-four pediatricians responded (response rate, 48%). Compliance with the guidelines was 39% for the 21 day old, 9.6% for the 60 day old, and 75% for the 20 month old. No respondent followed the guidelines for all three infants. Performance of tests to determine if an infant was low risk varied from 3%, for a stool white cell examination in a febrile 2 month old with diarrhea, to 75% for a complete blood count in a 20 month old with a temperature of 40 degrees C. Compliance did not differ between private and academic practitioners. Those in practice less than 5 years (n = 22) were more likely than those with more experience to follow the guidelines for the 21 day old but not the other two infants. CONCLUSION: Primary-care pediatricians in Utah manage febrile infants with fewer laboratory tests and less hospitalization than recent practice guidelines developed by an expert panel of academic specialists suggest.
Authors: Carrie L Byington; Carolyn C Reynolds; Kent Korgenski; Xiaoming Sheng; Karen J Valentine; Richard E Nelson; Judy A Daly; Russell J Osguthorpe; Brent James; Lucy Savitz; Andrew T Pavia; Edward B Clark Journal: Pediatrics Date: 2012-06-25 Impact factor: 7.124
Authors: Antoine C El Khoury; Emily Durden; Larry Ma; Leona E Markson; Andrew W Lee; Yinghui Duan; Kathleen Foley Journal: BMC Pediatr Date: 2010-12-22 Impact factor: 2.125