Menadione toxicity in two mouse liver established cell lines having striking genetic differences in quinone reductase activity and glutathione concentrations.

Established cell lines derived from newborn livers of c14CoS/c14CoS and cch/cch mice were examined for differences in menadione toxicity. The 14CoS/14CoS cells exhibit 10-fold higher NAD(P)H:menadione oxidoreductase (NMO1) activity and 3-fold greater concentrations of reduced glutathione (GSH) than the ch/ch cells. In 14CoS/14CoS cells there are also 50% to 3-fold increases in glutathione transferase (GSTA1), UDP glucuronosyltransferase, and the copper, zinc-dependent superoxide dismutase activities. Catalase activity, on the other hand, is six times lower in the 14CoS/14CoS than the ch/ch line. The 14CoS/14CoS cells are two to four times more resistant to menadione killing than ch/ch cells. At concentrations of dicumarol that completely block NMO1 and GSTA1 activities, the 14CoS/14CoS cells show more than twice as much resistance to menadione toxicity than the ch/ch cells. Although superoxide formation is three times higher in untreated 14CoS/14CoS than ch/ch cells, menadione-induced superoxide formation is greater in the dying ch/ch than in the 14CoS/14CoS cells. Cellular resistance to menadione toxicity is correlated with intracellular GSH levels, rather than with the percentage of oxidized glutathione; cytotoxicity is not observed as long as GSH concentrations are sufficiently high (about 5-8 nmol/mg protein). For menadione, the results are consistent with a dominant role of GSH depletion in mediating toxicity and support a protective role for NMO1 activity. This report demonstrates the usefulness of these cell lines as a model system to study mechanisms of oxidative chemically induced toxicity, as well as to understand how intracellular levels of GSH are regulated.