Survival of spleen colony-forming units (CFU-S) of irradiated bone marrow cells in mice: evidence for the existence of a radioresistant subfraction.

Because of increasing evidence of heterogeneity in the hematopoietic stem cell compartments, the radiosensitivity of spleen colony-forming units (CFU-S) was reevaluated to ascertain whether the classical single exponential curve for a graded dose of radiation is applicable at higher doses of radiation, 400-600 cGy. Bone marrow cells (BMC) removed from mice immediately after death under anesthesia were irradiated in vitro. Great care was taken to exclude anoxic effects during irradiation and to avoid any possible effects in the recipient mice from injection of excessive numbers of BMC. By estimating the number of cells to be injected to produce numbers of colonies within the evaluation range of the assay, we obtained a radiation survival curve that appeared to have a multiphasic concave shape; the D0 value for the 400-600 cGy range was estimated to be about 275 cGy, whereas the D0 for the lower doses was 95 cGy, the same value as previously reported. The reason a single exponential survival curve was previously obtained after graded doses of radiation is discussed, and a comparison of those results with the present data from in vitro radiation is made. Lacking experimental evidence, we speculate that the major factor that determines the slope of the survival curve is the degree to which the stem cells are in their normal hematopoietic environment during the irradiation. The probable existence of a fraction surviving after an exposure to 600 cGy, estimated by the limiting dilution assay, was about 1 per 2 x 10(6) BMC. Such radio-insensitive CFU-S appear to be primitive CFU-S, which can contribute materially to the long-term survival of lethally irradiated bone marrow recipients.