Comparative effect of counterpulsation and bypass on left ventricular myocardial oxygen consumption and dynamics before and after coronary occlusion.

In this preparation counterpulsation effect was found equivalent to 42 +/- 7% of complete left ventricular bypass before, and 46 +/- 9% post-coronary occlusion. We conclude that counterpulsation is effective mainly by reducing a major determinant of myocardial oxygen consumption, i.e., afterload, whereas left ventricular bypass by reducing primarily preload results in secondary afterload reduction when peripheral resistance is unchanged. At the higher left ventricular bypass levels, reduction of myocardial oxygen consumption is far greater than during balloon counterpulsation. Acute functional loss of myocardium does not alter the effect of these assist methods regarding the reduction of myocardial oxygen consumption. Whether selection of either method for clinical application should be made only on the basis of its capability for reduction of myocardial oxygen consumption remains to be justified by conclusive demonstration of beneficial effect of reduction of myocardial oxygen consumption in the specific circulatory disorders.