K A Raftery1, R Smith-Coggins, A H Chen. 1. Stanford University-Kaiser Permanente Emergency Medicine Residency Program, Department of Surgery, California, USA.
Abstract
STUDY OBJECTIVE: To determine whether patient or provider gender is associated with the number, type, and strength of medications received by emergency department patients with headache, neck pain, or back pain. DESIGN: Prospective cohort study. SETTING: Stanford University Hospital ED PARTICIPANTS: Patients 18 years and older who arrived at the ED with a chief complaint of headache, neck pain, or back pain between February 1, 1993, and September 30, 1993. Provider participants included medical students, interns, residents, nurse practitioners, and attending physicians. RESULTS: ED administration of analgesic versus no analgesic, strength of analgesic administered, and administration of multiple medications. The study group consisted of 190 patients, 110 of them female. The patients were evaluated by 84 providers, 60 of them male. According to the providers surveyed, female patients described more pain than did male patients (P < .01) and were perceived by providers to experience more pain (P = .03). Female patients received more medications (P < .01) and were less likely to receive no medication (P = .01). Female patients also received more potent analgesics (P = .03). Linear and logistic regression analysis showed that patient perception of pain was the strongest predictor of the number and strength of medications given; patient gender was not a predictor. CONCLUSION: Female patients with headache, neck pain, or back pain describe more pain and are perceived by providers to have more pain than male patients in the ED. Female patients also receive more medications and stronger analgesics. In this study, severity of patient pain rather than gender stereotyping appeared to correlate most with pain-management practices.
STUDY OBJECTIVE: To determine whether patient or provider gender is associated with the number, type, and strength of medications received by emergency department patients with headache, neck pain, or back pain. DESIGN: Prospective cohort study. SETTING: Stanford University Hospital ED PARTICIPANTS: Patients 18 years and older who arrived at the ED with a chief complaint of headache, neck pain, or back pain between February 1, 1993, and September 30, 1993. Provider participants included medical students, interns, residents, nurse practitioners, and attending physicians. RESULTS: ED administration of analgesic versus no analgesic, strength of analgesic administered, and administration of multiple medications. The study group consisted of 190 patients, 110 of them female. The patients were evaluated by 84 providers, 60 of them male. According to the providers surveyed, female patients described more pain than did male patients (P < .01) and were perceived by providers to experience more pain (P = .03). Female patients received more medications (P < .01) and were less likely to receive no medication (P = .01). Female patients also received more potent analgesics (P = .03). Linear and logistic regression analysis showed that patient perception of pain was the strongest predictor of the number and strength of medications given; patient gender was not a predictor. CONCLUSION: Female patients with headache, neck pain, or back pain describe more pain and are perceived by providers to have more pain than male patients in the ED. Female patients also receive more medications and stronger analgesics. In this study, severity of patientpain rather than gender stereotyping appeared to correlate most with pain-management practices.
Authors: Mitchell Kim; Stephen J Kaplan; Steven H Mitchell; Medley Gatewood; Itay Bentov; Katherine A Bennett; Carol A Crawford; Paul R Sutton; Diane Matsuwaka; Mamatha Damodarasamy; May J Reed Journal: Drugs Aging Date: 2017-10 Impact factor: 3.923
Authors: R A Desmond; N A Accortt; L Talley; S A Villano; S-J Soong; R J Whitley Journal: Antimicrob Agents Chemother Date: 2006-07 Impact factor: 5.191
Authors: Emily J Bartley; Jeff Boissoneault; Alison M Vargovich; Laura D Wandner; Adam T Hirsh; Benjamin C Lok; Marc W Heft; Michael E Robinson Journal: Pain Med Date: 2014-10-23 Impact factor: 3.750