Literature DB >> 7264476

Why medicine cannot be a science.

R Munson.   

Abstract

My thesis is that, although medicine is scientific, it is not and can not become a science. After rejecting as flawed an argument attempting to show that medicine is already is science. I argue that a comparison of such basic, defining features as internal aims, criteria of success, and principles regulating the enterprises demonstrate that medicine and science are inherently different. I then argue that while it may be possible to reduce the cognitive content of medicine to biology, medicine itself cannot be reduced, for as an enterprise it possesses features that make it an inappropriate subject of reduction. I conclude by indicating four results that emerge from recognizing that medicine and science are basically distinct.

Mesh:

Year:  1981        PMID: 7264476     DOI: 10.1093/jmp/6.2.183

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  J Med Philos        ISSN: 0360-5310


  10 in total

Review 1.  Teaching science vs. the apprentice model--do we really have the choice?

Authors:  G Marckmann
Journal:  Med Health Care Philos       Date:  2001

2.  From art to science: a new epistemological status for medicine? On expectations regarding personalized medicine.

Authors:  Urban Wiesing
Journal:  Med Health Care Philos       Date:  2018-12

3.  The legitimacy of clinical knowledge: towards a medical epistemology embracing the art of medicine.

Authors:  K Malterud
Journal:  Theor Med       Date:  1995-06

4.  To test or not to test: a clinical dilemma.

Authors:  D B Resnik
Journal:  Theor Med       Date:  1995-06

Review 5.  Is medicine hermeneutics all the way down?

Authors:  M W Cooper
Journal:  Theor Med       Date:  1994-06

Review 6.  The undertreatment of pain: scientific, clinical, cultural, and philosophical factors.

Authors:  D B Resnik; M Rehm; R B Minard
Journal:  Med Health Care Philos       Date:  2001

7.  Problem-solving in general practice.

Authors:  J Ridderikhoff
Journal:  Theor Med       Date:  1993-12

8.  Clinical interpretation: the hermeneutics of medicine.

Authors:  D Leder
Journal:  Theor Med       Date:  1990-03

9.  The tacit dimension of clinical judgment.

Authors:  G M Goldman
Journal:  Yale J Biol Med       Date:  1990 Jan-Feb

10.  Managed care's reconstruction of human existence: the triumph of technical reason.

Authors:  James Phillips
Journal:  Theor Med Bioeth       Date:  2002
  10 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.