Combination chemotherapy of advanced colorectal cancer utilizing 5-fluorouracil, semustine, dacarbazine, vincristine, and hydroxyurea: a phase III trial by the Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group (EST: 4275).

Patients who had measurable evidence of recurrent or metastatic colorectal carcinoma following surgery and radiotherapy but no prior chemotherapy were randomized to one of five combination chemotherapy programs. Four of the treatments utilized five consecutive days of fluorouracil (FU) (days 1--5 and days 36--40) plus one oral dose of semustine (ME) (day 1) every ten weeks: (A) FU + ME; (B) FU + ME + vincristine (VC) (day 1 and day 36); (C) FU + ME + dacarbazine (DC) (days 1, 2, 36, 37); (D) FU + ME + VC + DC. The fifth treatment option(E) used a weekly treatment program of FU I.V. on day 1 plus hydroxyurea (HU) P.O. on day 4. The overall response rate was 13% (60/472) and the median survival time from start of therapy for all patients was 31 weeks. The response rate and the median survival time for each combination was (A) 9/103 = 9%, 26 weeks; (B) 10/92 = 11%, 28 weeks; (C) 15/101 = 15%, 37 weeks; (D) 11/91 = 12%, 27 weeks; (E) 15/85 = 18%, 38 weeks. There is no statistical difference in response rate or survival duration among any of the treatment options. The therapies containing DC produced the only complete responses (3 patients on treatment C and 2 on D). Treatment D was also associated with the longest median response duration (Treatment D = 55 weeks). Treatment A (FU + ME) was associated with the highest incidence of life-threatening toxicity.

RCT Entities:   Population Interventions Outcomes