Comparison of standard tissue culture, tissue culture plus staining, and direct staining for detection of genital herpes simplex virus infection.

Genital herpes simplex virus infection in women was studied by using conventional tissue culture (TC) virus isolation compared with short-term (24-h) TC on Lab-Tek chamber slides followed by fluorescent-antibody (FA) staining. Three different staining techniques were used after TC: (i) staining with biotin-avidin (TC-BA/FA), (ii) direct FA (TC-FA), and (iii) indirect FA. The TC-BA/FA method showed complete correlation with the TC method. The TC-FA method showed no false-positive results but 31.5% false-negative results compared with the TC method. In contrast, the TC-indirect FA method showed 11.9% false-positive results and 11.7% false-negative results. The direct staining of specimens by the biotin-avidin technique (direct BA/FA) without prior tissue culture showed 37.7% false-positive results and 11.1% false-negative results. The TC-BA/FA technique thus was as sensitive as, but more rapid than, the TC method. The quality of fluorescence was far superior in TC-BA/FA staining as compared with TC-FA or TC-indirect FA procedures. The TC-BA/FA appears to be a valuable technique in laboratory diagnosis of genital herpes infections, especially in clinical situations requiring rapid detection of the virus.