| Literature DB >> 36249226 |
Bolajoko O Olusanya1, Vijaya Kancherla2, Amira Shaheen3, Felix A Ogbo4, Adrian C Davis5,6.
Abstract
Objective: The United Nations' Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) require population-based data on children with disabilities to inform global policies and intervention programs. We set out to compare the prevalence estimates of disabilities among children and adolescents younger than 20 years as reported by the world's leading organizations for global health statistics.Entities:
Keywords: Global Burden of Disease; ICF; SDGs; developmental disabilities; functional impairments; global health; low-income and middle-income countries; statistical modeling
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 36249226 PMCID: PMC9554924 DOI: 10.3389/fpubh.2022.977453
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Front Public Health ISSN: 2296-2565
Summary of data sources for global estimates of disabilities in children and adolescents.
|
|
|
|
| |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Title | Multiple Indicator Cluster Survey (MICS) | Model Disability Survey (MDS) | Global Burden of Disease (GBD) | WHO Rehabilitation Need Estimator |
| Disability model | Biopsychosocial/ICF | Biopsychosocial/ICF | Medical | Medical |
| Disability measurement | Parent (or household member)-reported functional difficulties | Parent (or household member)-reported functional difficulties and known impairments | Diagnosis of impairments based on the International Classification of Diseases (ICD) codes | Diagnosis of impairments based on the International Classification of Diseases (ICD) codes |
| Sources of data input | Household surveys | Household surveys | Systematic reviews of the literature, hospital and claims databases, health surveys, case notification systems, cohort studies, and multinational survey data | Systematic reviews of the literature, hospital and claims databases, health surveys, case notification systems, cohort studies, and multinational survey data |
| Measurement tool(s) | UNICEF/Washington Group Child Functioning Module, Washington Group Short Set on Functioning, and Global Activity Limitation Indicator | Children version of the Model Disability Survey (MDS) questionnaire | Statistical modelling of sequelae of health conditions | Statistical modelling of sequelae of health conditions |
| Age group(s) | • 2–4 years • 5–17 years | • < 5 years • 5–12 years • 13–17 years | 0–19 years | 0–19 years |
| Countries covered | 43 | Not available | 193 | 193 |
| Included in analysis | Yes | No, data collection on-going | Yes | No. fewer impairments in children reported |
UNICEF, United Nations Children's Fund; IHME, Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation; WHO: World Health Organization.
ICF, International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health.
Global and regional prevalence estimates of disabilities among children younger than 18 years from UNICEF 2022.
|
|
|
| |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| North America | 4.4 | 3.9–4.9 | 943 | 12.0 | 11.3–12.7 | 7,073 | 9.9 | 9.5–10.4 | 8,016 |
| Europe and Central Asia | 2.7 | 2.4–3.1 | 1,515 | 6.5 | 5.6–7.4 | 9,299 | 5.5 | 4.9–6.0 | 10,814 |
| East Asia and the Pacific | 3.5 | 3.3–3.8 | 5,333 | 9.5 | 7.5–11.6 | 37,788 | 7.8 | 6.7–9.1 | 43,121 |
| Latin America and the Caribbean | 3.8 | 3.3–4.5 | 1,978 | 12.6 | 11.5–13.7 | 17,102 | 10.2 | 9.6–10.8 | 19,080 |
| South Asia | 3.7 | 2.9–4.7 | 6,254 | 13.0 | 10.2–16.1 | 58,177 | 10.5 | 9.0–12.2 | 64,431 |
| Middle East and North Africa | 4.5 | 3.3–6.0 | 2,246 | 16.9 | 13.5–20.5 | 18,694 | 13.1 | 11.3–15.1 | 20,940 |
| Sub-Saharan Africa | 6.0 | 5.2–7.0 | 10,648 | 15.9 | 13.3−18.6 | 59,300 | 12.7 | 11.2–14.3 | 69,948 |
| Eastern and Southern Africa | 5.2 | 4.5–6.0 | 4,509 | 12.8 | 11.2–14.4 | 24,356 | 10.4 | 9.5–11.3 | 28,865 |
| West and Central Africa | 6.8 | 5.8–7.9 | 6,139 | 18.9 | 15.3–22.7 | 34,944 | 14.9 | 12.8–17.2 | 41,083 |
| Global | 4.3 | 4.1–4.6 | 28,917 | 12.5 | 11.7–13.3 | 207,433 | 10.1 | 9.6–10.6 | 236,350 |
UNICEF 2022 (Reference 17).
Global and regional prevalence estimates (95% uncertainty intervals) of disabilities among children younger than 5 years from GBD 2019.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| North America | Number | 216680 (178560–253606) | 144266 (111242–184772) | 116174 (86582–147558) | 365935 (288933–444460) | 163530 (137322–191935) | 88839 (57190–129131) | 1,095,424 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 1033 (852–1209) | 688 (531–881) | 554 (413–704) | 1745 (1378–2119) | 780 (655–915) | 424 (273–616) | 5,224 | |
| Europe and Central Asia | Number | 734399 (613799–844935) | 442598 (344672–561172) | 325486 (254438–405246) | 968321 (759685–1177813) | 288885 (241844–341950) | 129066 (85207–183064) | 2,888,755 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 1387 (1159–1596) | 836 (651–1060) | 615 (481–766) | 1829 (1435–2224) | 546 (457–646) | 244 (161–346) | 5,457 | |
| East Asia and the Pacific | Number | 3438113 (2956219–3913264) | 1297733 (1038429–1626274) | 823451 (609592–1057118) | 2727757 (2193412–3288485) | 655238 (536229–777688) | 494302 (328841–691713) | 9,436,594 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 2321 (1996–2642) | 876 (701–1098) | 556 (412–714) | 1842 (1481–2220) | 443 (362–525) | 334 (222–467) | 6,372 | |
| Latin America and the Caribbean | Number | 955072 (815257–1083241) | 537396 (425765–677756) | 407933 (314902–517147) | 920348 (751406–1093649) | 235268 (195519–280124) | 164888 (109929–235240) | 3,220,905 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 1810 (1545–2052) | 1018 (807–1284) | 773 (597–980) | 1744 (1424–2072) | 446 (371–531) | 313 (209–446) | 6,104 | |
| South Asia | Number | 3874622 (3255133–4475660) | 1957304 (1557653–2441206) | 1125281 (800287–1471321) | 10126841 (7607751–12675553) | 618664 (507916–741150) | 203205 (131076–295087) | 17,905,917 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 2245 (1886–2593) | 1134 (903–1415) | 652 (464–853) | 5866 (4407–7343) | 359 (295–430) | 118 (76–171) | 10,374 | |
| Middle East and North Africa | Number | 488204 (402462–571691) | 484094 (386408–607876) | 349893 (273786–431567) | 1495407 (1130592–1865688) | 163087 (134699–194489) | 93415 (62260–134040) | 3,074,100 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 1117 (921–1308) | 1107 (884–1390) | 801 (627–987) | 3420 (2586–4266) | 373 (308–445) | 214 (143–307) | 7,032 | |
| Sub-Saharan Africa | Number | 4430374 (3751757–5105139) | 1060410 (858727–1318551) | 1281867 (971635–1601732) | 4380762 (3367541–5401625) | 785503 (649093–939682) | 192373 (125070–284836) | 12,131,289 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 2591 (2194–2985) | 620 (503–771) | 750 (569–937) | 2562 (1969–3159) | 460 (380–550) | 113 (74–167) | 7,096 | |
| Western Sub-Saharan Africa | Number | 2056777 (1733992–2379728) | 486542 (396448–600924) | 535773 (412020–676979) | 1569783 (1214410–1929542) | 334776 (276395–400912) | 83100 (53414–123565) | 5,066,751 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 2828 (2385–3272) | 669 (546–827) | 737 (567–931) | 2159 (1670–2653) | 461 (381–552) | 115 (74–170) | 6,969 | |
| Central Sub-Saharan Africa | Number | 476231 (403059–544899) | 105598 (83203–135057) | 159777 (112730–212478) | 569843 (436073–705495) | 94749 (77403–113592) | 22322 (14378–32171) | 1,428,520 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 2301 (1948–2633) | 511 (402–653) | 772 (545–1027) | 2753 (2107–3409) | 458 (374–549) | 108 (70–156) | 6,903 | |
| Eastern Sub-Saharan Africa | Number | 1622747 (1369967–1865589) | 358640 (289879–446935) | 489671 (362217–625240) | 1824540 (1391859–2248468) | 299975 (247740–358721) | 68924 (44638–101370) | 4,664,497 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 2531 (2136–2909) | 560 (452–697) | 764 (565–975) | 2845 (2171–3506) | 468 (387–560) | 108 (70–159) | 7,276 | |
| Southern Sub-Saharan Africa | Number | 214764 (182842–247327) | 55604 (44030–69664) | 63914 (44593–86373) | 154615 (122342–186165) | 37204 (30649–44371) | 8776 (5687–13128) | 534,877 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 2653 (2259–3055) | 687 (544–861) | 790 (551–1067) | 1910 (1512–2300) | 460 (379–549) | 109 (71–163) | 6,609 | |
| Global | Number | 14148322 (12036835–16216298) | 5928288 (4749336–7364009) | 4433545 (3376788–5567220) | 20998409 (16142819–25947466) | 2912437 (2418074–3461585) | 1367582 (898677–1947054) | 49,788,583 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 2135 (1816–2447) | 895 (717–1111) | 669 (510–840) | 3168 (2436–3915) | 440 (365–523) | 207 (136–294) | 7,514 |
95% uncertainty intervals not available for all disabilities.
Global and regional prevalence estimates (95% uncertainty intervals) of disabilities among children aged 5 to 19 years from GBD 2019.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| North America | Number | 1226942 (1069237–1389908) | 829331 (673427–1015300) | 464116 (377040–566934) | 1127243 (881538–1386467) | 509875 (428720–599971) | 3365797 (2261084–4803878) | 7,523,304 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 1780 (1551–2016) | 1203 (977–1473) | 674 (547–823) | 1635 (1279–2011) | 740 (622–871) | 4882 (3280–6967) | 10,914 | |
| Europe and Central Asia | Number | 4583297 (4026175–5148943) | 2222942 (1818252–2714517) | 1158295 (896858–1486995) | 2744266 (2120532–3364352) | 838512 (701345–993733) | 4550322 (3110708–6365862) | 16,097,634 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 2843 (2498–3194) | 1379 (1128–1684) | 719 (557–923) | 1703 (1316–2087) | 521 (436–617) | 2823 (1930–3949) | 9,988 | |
| East Asia and the Pacific | Number | 22128237 (19553458–24940194) | 5991479 (4904617–7257251) | 2552101 (1987366–3300801) | 7356504 (5854718–8964365) | 1770957 (1461017–2120794) | 15649369 (10849799–21465647) | 55,448,647 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 5181 (4578–5840) | 1403 (1149–1700) | 598 (466–773) | 1723 (1371–2099) | 415 (343–497) | 3664 (2541–5026) | 12,984 | |
| Latin America and the Caribbean | Number | 6648994 (5902702–7477938) | 2930755 (2386395–3569863) | 1438411 (1127718–1831419) | 2550241 (2058769–3060952) | 670370 (555365–798010) | 6064849 (4188888–8551760) | 20,303,620 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 4153 (3687–4671) | 1831 (1491–2230) | 899 (705–1144) | 1593 (1286–1912) | 419 (347–499) | 3788 (2617–5342) | 12,683 | |
| South Asia | Number | 28211185 (24273897–32232474) | 8138965 (6764205–9851146) | 4151288 (3099984–5359019) | 30468226 (22914705–38180927) | 1834585 (1512061–2209420) | 7824749 (5139601–11183238) | 80,628,998 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 5126 (4410–5856) | 1479 (1229–1790) | 755 (564–974) | 5536 (4163–6937) | 334 (275–402) | 1422 (934–2032) | 14,652 | |
| Middle East and North Africa | Number | 2813081 (2427661–3208346) | 2477027 (2036894–2992981) | 957295 (764983–1203938) | 4016620 (3022254–5024694) | 435499 (359818–520101) | 3169552 (2163344–4468032) | 13,869,074 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 2258 (1949–2575) | 1988 (1635–2403) | 769 (614–967) | 3224 (2426–4033) | 350 (289–418) | 2544 (1737–3586) | 11,133 | |
| Sub-Saharan Africa | Number | 22442961 (19306417–25523614) | 4073575 (3435394–4846169) | 3459890 (2673539–4485332) | 9863944 (7536483–12220930) | 1807381 (1487757–2159942) | 5801510 (3840848–8271417) | 47,449,261 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 5314 (4571–6043) | 965 (814–1148) | 820 (633–1062) | 2336 (1785–2894) | 428 (353–512) | 1374 (910–1959) | 11,237 | |
| Western Sub-Saharan Africa | Number | 10039827 (8585704–11437723) | 1772251 (1501258–2105376) | 1358388 (1023033–1787672) | 3372979 (2584303–4197495) | 750778 (618519–898133) | 2446774 (1607405–3493043) | 19,740,997 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 5720 (4891–6516) | 1010 (856–1200) | 774 (583–1019) | 1922 (1473–2392) | 428 (353–512) | 1394 (916–1990) | 11,248 | |
| Central Sub-Saharan Africa | Number | 2440218 (2112922–2752972) | 412296 (342047–495657) | 448016 (286390–650824) | 1279151 (971797–1596102) | 215881 (176255–257883) | 655630 (431619–945625) | 5,451,192 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 4836 (4188–5456) | 818 (678–983) | 888 (568–1290) | 2535 (1926–3164) | 428 (350–512) | 1300 (856–1874) | 10,805 | |
| Eastern Sub-Saharan Africa | Number | 8396926 (7232002–9572424) | 1380137 (1157587–1644255) | 1370261 (1044622–1785873) | 4146836 (3166775–5147128) | 696321 (574120–831487) | 2096146 (1388361–3004361) | 18,086,627 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 5269 (4538–6006) | 866 (727–1032) | 860 (656–1121) | 2602 (1987–3230) | 437 (361–522) | 1316 (872–1885) | 11,350 | |
| Southern Sub-Saharan Africa | Number | 1233551 (1062885–1402959) | 241357 (200575–289619) | 202537 (153864–262472) | 400906 (317513–486844) | 96865 (79345–115927) | 297468 (195820–427506) | 2,472,684 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 5479 (4721–6231) | 1072 (891–1287) | 900 (684–1166) | 1781 (1411–2163) | 431 (353–515) | 1322 (870–1899) | 10,985 | |
| Global | Number | 88121532 (76891578–99618793) | 26684718 (21991143–32187072) | 14192633 (11172414–18071433) | 58160929 (44335927–72217829) | 7873281 (6532083–9413240) | 46477791 (31750591–64830750) | 241,510,884 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 4599 (4013–5199) | 1393 (1148–1680) | 741 (583–943) | 3035 (2314–3769) | 411 (341–492) | 2426 (1657–3383) | 12,605 |
95% uncertainty intervals not available for all disabilities.
Global and regional prevalence estimates (95% uncertainty intervals) of disabilities among children younger than 20 years from GBD 2019.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| North America | Number | 1443622 (1260095–1623672) | 973597 (801351–1171707) | 580289 (474814–694717) | 1493177 (1172810–1827421) | 673405 (566292–791760) | 3454636 (2317514–4930022) | 8,618,726 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 1606 (1402–1806) | 1083 (892–1303) | 646 (528–773) | 1661 (1305–2032) | 749 (630–881) | 3842 (2577–5482) | 9,587 | |
| Europe and Central Asia | Number | 5317696 (4661136–5957133) | 2665540 (2220754–3201168) | 1483781 (1161312–1851246) | 3712587 (2885054–4541304) | 1127397 (943188–1336345) | 4679388 (3206381–6539742) | 18,986,389 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 2483 (2177–2782) | 1245 (1037–1495) | 693 (543–865) | 1734 (1347–2121) | 527 (441–624) | 2185 (1497–3054) | 8,867 | |
| East Asia and the Pacific | Number | 25566349 (22666249–28615270) | 7289211 (6079418–8726594) | 3375552 (2681974–4248571) | 10084260 (8052049–12264190) | 2426195 (1995116–2897387) | 16143670 (11192831–22148095) | 64,885,237 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 4445 (3941–4975) | 1268 (1057–1517) | 587 (467–739) | 1753 (1400–2132) | 422 (347–504) | 2807 (1946–3850) | 11,282 | |
| Latin America and the Caribbean | Number | 7604066 (6768579–8453553) | 3468151 (2896484–4159632) | 1846344 (1478702–2287072) | 3470589 (2818649–4153597) | 905637 (753110–1077016) | 6229737 (4299528–8776093) | 23,524,524 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 3572 (3180–3971) | 1629 (1361–1954) | 868 (695–1075) | 1631 (1324–1951) | 426 (354–506) | 2927 (2020–4123) | 11,053 | |
| South Asia | Number | 32085806 (27728413–36385664) | 10096269 (8439115–11984658) | 5276568 (4094348–6599348) | 40595067 (30539944–50842037) | 2453248 (2019630–2962215) | 8027954 (5266209–11471660) | 98,534,912 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 4438 (3835–5032) | 1397 (1168–1658) | 730 (567–913) | 5615 (4224–7032) | 340 (280–410) | 1111 (729–1587) | 13,631 | |
| Middle East and North Africa | Number | 3301284 (2862269–3746353) | 2961120 (2494463–3525529) | 1307187 (1063318–1619453) | 5512026 (4148436–6892949) | 598586 (495243–713797) | 3262966 (2224812–4598774) | 16,943,169 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 1962 (1701–2226) | 1760 (1482–2095) | 777 (632–963) | 3275 (2465–4095) | 356 (295–425) | 1939 (1322–2732) | 10,069 | |
| Sub-Saharan Africa | Number | 26873334 (23225530–30370158) | 5133984 (4380184–6041603) | 4741756 (3782633–5953097) | 14244706 (10926006–17570979) | 2592883 (2136090–3099711) | 5993883 (3966944–8542723) | 59,580,546 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 4529 (3914–5118) | 866 (739–1019) | 800 (638–1004) | 2401 (1842–2961) | 437 (360–523) | 1010 (669–1440) | 10,043 | |
| Western Sub-Saharan Africa | Number | 12096603 (10409381–13721117) | 2258793 (1943559–2638917) | 1894161 (1469697–2416851) | 4942762 (3802172–6119971) | 1085553 (896738–1299438) | 2529873 (1663706–3611220) | 24,807,745 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 4873 (4193–5527) | 910 (783–1063) | 763 (592–974) | 1991 (1532–2466) | 438 (362–524) | 1019 (671–1455) | 9,994 | |
| Central Sub-Saharan Africa | Number | 2916448 (2512575–3258254) | 517894 (433288–616952) | 607792 (401690–844674) | 1848993 (1407885–2300062) | 310629 (253551–371262) | 677951 (445679–977406) | 6,879,707 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 4099 (3531–4579) | 728 (609–867) | 855 (565–1187) | 2599 (1979–3233) | 437 (357–522) | 953 (627–1374) | 9,671 | |
| Eastern Sub-Saharan Africa | Number | 10019673 (8666559–11379839) | 1738777 (1488881–2044281) | 1859931 (1438907–2348494) | 5971376 (4562094–7412340) | 996295 (821527–1190208) | 2165070 (1432587–3105380) | 22,751,122 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 4483 (3878–5092) | 778 (667–915) | 833 (644–1051) | 2672 (2041–3317) | 446 (368–533) | 969 (641–1390) | 10,181 | |
| Southern Sub-Saharan Africa | Number | 1448315 (1250897–1636349) | 296961 (249538–352908) | 266451 (207123–340369) | 555520 (438187–673890) | 134069 (109930–160120) | 306243 (201417–440151) | 3,007,559 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 4731 (4087–5346) | 971 (816–1153) | 871 (677–1112) | 1815 (1432–2202) | 438 (360–524) | 1001 (658–1438) | 9,827 | |
| Global | Number | 102269853 (89657165–115064557) | 32613006 (27412553–38676284) | 18626177 (15136201–23044362) | 79159337 (60490508–98168458) | 10785718 (8953061–12859912) | 47845372 (32634830–66892474) | 291,299,463 |
| Cases per 100,000 | 3966 (3477–4462) | 1265 (1063–1500) | 723 (587–894) | 3070 (2346–3807) | 419 (348–499) | 1855 (1266–2594) | 11,298 |
95% uncertainty intervals not available for all disabilities.
Comparison of global and regional prevalence estimates (%) between UNICEF 2022 and GBD 2019.
|
|
|
| ||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| North America | 4.4 | 12.0 | 9.9 | 5.2 | 10.9 | 9.6 | 1.2 |
|
|
| – | – |
| Europe and Central Asia | 2.7 | 6.5 | 5.5 | 5.5 | 10.0 | 8.9 | 2.0 | 1.5 | 1.6 |
|
|
|
| East Asia and the Pacific | 3.5 | 9.5 | 7.8 | 6.4 | 13.0 | 11.3 | 1.8 | 1.4 | 1.4 |
|
|
|
| Latin America and the Caribbean | 3.8 | 12.6 | 10.2 | 6.1 | 12.7 | 11.1 | 1.6 |
|
|
|
|
|
| South Asia | 3.7 | 13.0 | 10.5 | 10.4 | 14.7 | 13.6 | 2.8 |
| 1.3 | 6.7 |
|
|
| Middle East and North Africa | 4.5 | 16.9 | 13.1 | 7.0 | 11.1 | 10.1 | 1.6 |
|
|
| −5.8 | – |
| Sub-Saharan Africa | 6.0 | 15.9 | 12.7 | 7.1 | 11.2 | 10.0 | 1.2 |
|
|
| – | – |
| Global | 4.3 | 12.5 | 10.1 | 7.5 | 12.6 | 11.3 | 1.7 |
|
|
|
|
|
t-Test for statistical difference in overall mean in each age group: < 5 years (t = 4.185, df = 11.4, p = 0.001); 5 to 19 years (t = 0.264, df = 9.71, p = 0.797); < 20 years (t = 0.746, df = 11.37, p = 0.471).
Two one-sided test (TOST) for statistical equivalence of overall mean in each age group, GBD vs UNICEF: < 5 years (6.9% vs 4.1%, p = 0.375); 5 to 19 years (12.0 vs. 12.4%, p = 0.0.032); < 20 years (10.7 vs. 10.0%, p = 0.024).
Figure 1Prevalence estimates of disabilities among children under 5 years by UNICEF and GBD 2019.
Figure 2Prevalence estimates of disabilities among children aged 5 to 19 years by UNICEF and GBD 2019.
Figure 3Prevalence estimates of disabilities among children under 20 years by UNICEF and GBD 2019.
Figure 4Global population of children with and without disabilities in the reported age groups.