| Literature DB >> 36247337 |
Atharva Shinde1, Gargi Deore1, Kedar P Navsariwala1, Heena Tabassum1, Minal Wani1.
Abstract
Here, through this review, we aim to serve this purpose by first discussing the statistics and aging demographics, including the life expectancy of the world and India, along with the gender life expectancy gap observed throughout the world, followed by explaining the hallmarks and integral causes of aging, along with the role played by senescent cells in controlling inflammation and the effect of senescence associated secretory phenotype on longevity. A few of the molecular pathways which are crucial in modulating the process of aging, such as the nutrient-sensing mTOR pathway, insulin signaling, Nrf2, FOXO, PI3-Akt, Sirtuins, and AMPK, and their effects are also covered in paramount detail. A diverse number of ingenious research methodologies are used in the modern era of longevity exploration. We have attempted to cover these methods under the umbrella of three broad categories: in vitro, in vivo, and in silico techniques. The drugs developed to attenuate the aging process, such as rapamycin, metformin, resveratrol, etc. and their interactions with the above-mentioned molecular pathways along with their toxicity have also been reviewed in detail.Entities:
Year: 2022 PMID: 36247337 PMCID: PMC9549314 DOI: 10.1002/agm2.12223
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Aging Med (Milton) ISSN: 2475-0360
FIGURE 1The above graph serves to provide a quantitative visualization of the number of deaths caused by aging and age‐associated diseases. Cardiovascular diseases claim the most lives in a given year, followed by cancer, chronic respiratory disease, digestive disease, dementias (including Alzhiemer's disease), diabetes mellitus, chronic liver disease, chronic kidney disease, and, last, Parkinson's disease.
FIGURE 2The figure above is the graphical representation of the trend observed in the yearly life expectancy around the globe from the year 1950 to 2021. The graph shows a gradual increase in the overall life expectancy due to many factors, some of which include the development of better healthcare systems, increased sanitation in third world countries, reduced accidental risk to life, etc. The data was retrieved from the United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs, Population Division (2022).
FIGURE 3The above figure graphically represents the trend of increase in life expectancy in India from the year 1950 to the year 2021. The data was retrieved from the United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs, Population Division (2022).
The above table is a compilation of experiments done in vitro, including aging related studies on mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs), fibroblasts, and adipocytes
| Sr No. | Overview | Author and year |
|---|---|---|
| In vitro research | ||
| 1. | The aging of human MSCs was analyzed in vitro. It was seen that they gradually lose their fibroblast‐like spindle shape and become inhomogeneous. The doubling rate of the population decreases over time. MSCs at both passages 4 and 8 could differentiate into adipocyte‐like cells, whereas the osteogenesis of aged MSCs was significantly compromised. | Yang et al (2018) |
| 2. | Oxidative stress and hypoxia are seen to increase in aging adipocytes with a senescent phenotype, the level of | Zoico et al (2019) |
| 3. | In vitro, fibroblasts are commonly utilized to research aging at the cellular level. The study of the effects of antioxidants on fibroblasts in vitro sparked interest because of the interest in the effects of antioxidants on human lifespan and skin aging. | Sadowaska‐Bartosz et al (2020) |
| 4. | It was inferred that MSCs enter senescence early on during in vitro culturing and gradually lose their stem cell features and characteristics. The abnormalities observed resembled those of the Hayflick model of aging. | Bonab et al (2006) |
| In vivo research | ||
| 1. |
The efficacy of a possible senolytic drug called seno‐7284 was tested in an atherosclerosis mice model and it was observed that it reduced the accumulation of senescent cells in visceral adipose tissue of dietary obese mice, which was shown to improve the defect of insulin tolerance and inflammation of adipose tissue. | Katsuumi et al (2020) |
| 2. | It was observed that the plasma concentration in the elderly population contains significantly higher levels of IL‐1 receptor antagonist (IL‐lra) and soluble TNF receptor (sTNFr) as compared to younger individuals, which are the antagonists of cytokines: interleukin 7 (IL‐1β) and tumor necrosis factor a (TNFa) respectively. This antagonistic effect is suspected to contribute to the immune related changes associated with aging. | Cantania et al (1997) |
| 3. | Stopping mitochondrial ROS mediated damage using MitoQ and BGP‐15 prevents defects in the meiotic spindle and chromosome in the oocytes of mice and humans | Al‐Zubaidi et al (2021) |
| 4. | The | Vougioukalaki et al (2022) |
| In silico research | ||
| 1. |
The developed model suggests that the somatic mutations in an organism are not the major contributor to aging, and an unrealistically high mutation rate is required to explain senescence if the mutation rate was assumed to be constant over time. However, if the mutation rate increased with time, it was predicted that senescence would occur after 60–100 population doublings. | Kirkwood et al (2003) |
| 2. | The goal of this model was to perceive situations in which aging or the presence of elderly individuals was beneficial to the population. The model predicted that the rapid decline in the number of weakened elderly individuals would save the younger individuals in the condition of resource shortage. | Chistyakov et al (2018) |
| 3. | The model suggests that multicellular aging cannot be avoided because there exists a competition and selection between somatic cells, which eliminates poorly functioning cells but can also lead to the selection of non‐compatible, non‐cooperative cells that do not work together with other cells. | Nelson and Masel (2017) |
| 4. |
This computational model aimed to elucidate the relationship between key genes and miRNAs regulating cardiac senescence processes | Politano et al (2017) |
Note: Examples of experiments done in vivo include analyzing the effects of new drugs and studies associated with age‐related immunological changes. The in silico experiments mentioned consist of a model‐based approach to study various aspects of aging and discovering age associated genes.
Abbreviations: ISCs, intestinal stem cells; MSCs, mesenchymal stem cells.
FIGURE 4The above figure, made in the standard Systems Biology Graphical Notation (SBGN), represents the key players of the densely connected network of the mTOR signaling, energy deficit, and other signals activating the two complexes mTORC1 and mTORC2, producing a range of effects.
FIGURE 5A wealth of studies to date has revealed that FOXOs target a range of genes involved in multiple cellular processes, including metabolism, cell cycle, apoptosis, stress resistance, DNA repair, and the immune system.
FIGURE 6The above figure, in the largely accepted Systems Biology Graphical Notation (SBGN) format, represents the interconnected network of pathways while focusing on the densely connected node: AMPK. AMPK is shown to be activated by low nutrient conditions and genotoxic stress. The end effect of AMPK activation leads to ROS cleaning, inhibition of cell growth, and promotes longevity.
FIGURE 7Akt is a densely associated pathway which is connected to a number of aging pathways such as the foxO pathway, JAK–STAT pathway, AMPK pathway, and the MAPK pathway. It regulates cell features such as DNA repair, cell proliferation, angiogenesis, cell cycle regulation, cell survival, etc.
FIGURE 8Sirtuin molecule is activated in the presence of NAD+ and is also shown to be activated by the intake of the drug resveratrol. Sirtuin has a wide‐ranging effect by controlling cellular senescence, proliferation, metabolism, DNA repair, apoptosis, and cell survival.
The table contains drugs used in anti‐aging therapies compartmentalized into synthetic, natural, and hormonal drugs along with their mode of action, structure, side effects, and the model organism in which they were tested for their efficacy
| Sr. No. | Drug name | Model organism(s) | Method of action | Side effects | Author and date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Synthetic drugs | |||||
| 1 | Tanespimycin |
| Impedes Hsp90 as a way to adjourn aging. Inhibition of Hsp90 causes the expression of heat shock proteins, which are known to promote protein homeostasis | Tanespimycin has been shown to cause a confusional state, hyperhidrosis, and edema | Fuentealba et al (2019), Janssens et al (2019) |
| 2 |
Valproic acid
|
| Valproic acid therapy may influence the insulin/IGF‐1 growth factor signaling pathway. The combination of valproic acid with the heterocyclic anticonvulsant trimethadione resulted in a life expectancy increase that was much greater than treatment with either medicine alone. | The side effects of valproic acid include adenoma, agitation, amenorrhea, amnesia, an increase in amylase, anaphylactic shock, atrioventricular block, atrophy, breast enlargement, bronchitis, catatonia, congenital anomaly, abnormal coordination, and drug withdrawal syndrome. | Evason et al (2008) |
| 3 |
Allantoin |
| CR mimetics | Like Tanespimycin, Allantoin has been shown to cause a confusional state, along with constipation, erythema, hemorrhage, oedema, pruritus, somnolence, and urticaria | Admasu et al (2018), Calvert et al (2016) |
| 4 |
Trolox/S,S‐trolox‐carnosine
|
| Confers thermal stress resistance and extended life span | Decreased appetite was observed on the reaction of Trolox, along with diarrhea, hypertension, and edema | Benedetti et al (2008), Stvolinsky et al (2010) |
| 5 |
Aspirin |
| Aspirin reduces age‐related functional decays, prevents oxidative stress, and extends | Hearing loss, leukopenia, melaena, edema, thirst, thrombocytopenia, tinnitus, and ulcer are all side effects of aspirin | Strong et al (2008), Ayyadevara et al (2013), Hans et al (2015) |
| 6 |
Fenofibrate |
| Fibrates improve longevity in | Studies on fenofibrate showed after effects like bronchitis, bursitis, cardiac fibrillation, cardiovascular disorder, deep vein thrombosis, dermatitis, ecchymosis, electrocardiogram abnormal, and eye disorders | Brandstädt et al (2013) |
| 7 |
Vinpocetine |
| Reduces oxidative stress and inflammation, thus inhibiting cellular aging, improves cognitive function and has anti‐inflammatory function | Side effects such as stomach discomfort, sleep problems, flushing of the face were observed | Medina (2010), Szatmari and Whitehouse (2003) |
| 8 |
Nicotinamide riboside/Niagen |
| The Nrk and Urh1/Pnp1/Meu1 routes to NAD+ trigger Sir2 silencing, which increases longevity | In human studies, taking 1000–2000 mg per day had no harmful effects, some people have reported mild to moderate side effects, such as fatigue, stomach discomfort, and indigestion | Belenky et al (2007), Airhart et al (2017), Dellinger et al (2017) |
| 9 |
Hydralazine |
| By stimulating the NRF2/SKN‐1 signaling pathway in | Common side effects include headache, loss of appetite, fast heart rate, and chest pain | Snell et al (2016), Dehghan et al (2017) |
| 10. |
Metformin | Human trials | Metformin works by inhibiting the 5′‐AMP‐activated protein kinase enzyme (AMPK). The AMPK signaling pathway's ability to activate decreases with age, which disrupts autophagy, raises cellular stress, and promotes inflammation, all of which contribute to numerous age‐related illnesses like cardiovascular disease, diabetes, and cancer. It is a common treatment for type 2 diabetes. | Metformin induced the following side effects‐ asthenia, diarrhea, gas (flatulence), weakening symptoms, muscle pain (myalgia), upper respiratory tract infection, low blood sugar (hypoglycemia) | Podhorecka et al (2017), Torres et al (2020), Wang et al (2020), Fatemi et al (2018) |
| 11. |
Enoxacin |
| Enoxacin inhibits miR‐34‐5p and promotes mitohormesis, Enoxacin treatment down‐regulated miR‐34‐5p and did not further extend life span of long‐lived mir‐34 mutants | A state of drowsiness, ringing in the ears, or heightened skin sensitivity to sunlight are all symptoms of lightheadedness | Rocha et al (2020) |
| Natural drugs | |||||
| 1. |
Curcumin |
| Inhibits mTOR pathway, increase superoxide dismutase activity | The TOR pathway is blocked in curcumin‐fed larvae and early to midlife adults, but several other genes implicated in longevity extension are also affected, according to gene expression data from curcumin‐fed larvae | Soh et al (2013), Shen et al (2013), Arking (2015) |
| 2. |
Lithocholic acid |
|
Lithocholic acid has been shown to enhance the lifespan of chronologically aging yeast in studies. LCA disrupts the mitochondrial lipidome and proteome, enlarges mitochondria, reduces mitochondrial number, modifies mitochondrial cristae structure, and changes essential elements of mitochondrial activity, according to new research. In yeast, LCA extends lifespan in a TOR‐independent manner | Constipation, decreased appetite, dyspepsia, erythema, headache, infection, edema, thrombocytopenia, urticaria, visual impairment are all side effects of Lithocholic acid | Arlia‐Ciommo et al (2018), Staats et al (2018), Arlia‐Ciommo et al (2014), Burstein et al (2012), Beach et al (2015) |
| 3 |
Coenzyme Q10 |
| Lowers oxidative stress, it acts as an antioxidant to dismutate the free radical superoxide anion, it positively affects mitochondrial deficiency syndrome, and the antioxidant effect of CoQ10 relieves cardiovascular disease and inflammation | Digestive problems such as: upper abdominal pain, loss of appetite, nausea and vomiting, diarrhea | Ishii et al (2004), Yang et al (2009), Hernández‐Camacho et al (2018) |
| 4 |
Fisetin |
| Fisetin reduces the amount of senescent cells, which are cells that increase during aging and damage healthy surrounding cells, accelerating the aging process | Although there is no evidence that fisetin causes negative effects, no human research has been undertaken. Fisetin supplementation has no safety data in humans, however, no toxicity has been documented in animals. | Yousefzadeh et al (2018) |
| 5 |
Catechins |
| Has an antioxidant action, it enhances antioxidant defense systems, modulates factors of brain growth, reduces of the neuroinflammatory pathway, and regulates apoptosis. In cellular and animal models of neurodegenerative disorders like Alzheimer's, MS, and Parkinson's disease, catechins were found to be beneficial. | Irregular heartbeat and headache. Green tea extract also contains a substance that, in large amounts, has been related to liver harm | Farzaei et al (2019), Unno et al (2008) |
| 6 |
Glutathione |
| Glutathione is a crucial cofactor in enzymatic activities and the primary thiol‐disulfide redox buffer in human cells. Glutathione is also an important defense system for protecting cells from a variety of stresses. In Parkinson's disease and after a stroke, it is shown to decrease | Long‐term glutathione supplementation has been associated to zinc deficiency. People with asthma may experience asthma attacks if they inhale glutathione. | Maher (2005), Jahoor et al (2019), Hazelton & Lang (1980) |
| 7 |
Quercetin | Human dermal fibroblast cell | Natural Quercetin treatment improved antioxidant, mitochondrial dysfunction in aged HDFs. Quercetin has a restorative effect on cellular senescence by down‐regulating senescence activities and up‐regulating gene expressions of antioxidant enzymes in aged HDFs. In mice, quercetin has been demonstrated to boost cognitive performance. | Headache and stomach discomfort. According to preliminary research, a byproduct of quercetin can cause protein function loss. High dosages of quercetin may cause kidney damage. | Sohn et al (2018), Chondrogianni et al (2010), Zoico et al (2021) |
| 8 |
Trichostatin A |
| Elevates hsp22 expression, histone deacetylase (HDAC) inhibitor Trichostatin A (TSA) | Alopecia, convulsion, decreased appetite, erythema, fatigue, malaise, neutropenia, oedema, urticaria are the common side effects | Tao et al (2004), Calvert et al (2016) |
| 9 |
L‐Carnitine |
| Carnitine is necessary for fatty acid transport into the mitochondria for oxidation. L‐carnitine enhances mobility and survival in response to H2O2 and human amyloid (A) poisoning and facilitates recovery from oxidative stress generated by paraquat or juglone. L‐carnitine reduces oxidative stress during aging, resulting in a mild but considerable lifetime extension that was reliant on SKN‐1 and DAF‐16. Long‐lived worms with germline loss (glp‐1) or decreased insulin receptor function (daf‐2) recover from aging‐related oxidative stress faster than wild‐type controls, and L‐carnitine had no effect on their long life spans. | Stomach upset, heartburn, and seizures. L‐Carnitine can also cause urine, breath, and sweat to have a “fishy” odor. | Liu et al (2020) |
| 10 |
Resveratrol |
| It is projected to improve cognitive and kidney function. It is believed that resveratrol activates SIRT1 gene and is responsible to generate stress response. | Short‐term dosages of resveratrol appear to have no negative effects (1.0 g). Otherwise, adverse effects such as liver damage in people with non‐alcoholic fatty liver disease may arise at dosages of 2.5 g or higher per day. | Chu et al (2021), Kasiotis et al (2013), Brown et al (2010) |
| 11 |
Rapamycin |
| Slows the onset of age‐related illnesses by inhibiting cell senescence. The medicine works by focusing on mTOR, a master regulator of cell proliferation in our cells | Rapamycin caused side effects include abdominal distension, acidosis, acne, agitation, anemia, atrial fibrillation, basal cell carcinoma, kin neoplasm that is benign. A rise in blood creatinine levels, blood urea levels, and body temperature was observed. Bone ache, bronchitis carcinogenicity, heart failure cardiomegaly, chest discomfort, chills, state of perplexity, constipation, deafness, reduced appetite, thrombosis of the deep veins were some of the other side effects seen. | Zhang et al (2021), Ehninger et al (2014) |
| Hormones | |||||
| 1. |
Melatonin |
| Stress resistance, antioxidant and free radical scavenger properties of melatonin | In female CBA mice, melatonin enhances both life span and tumor incidence | Bonilla et al (2002), Thomas & Smith‐Sonneborn (1997), Anisimov et al (2001) |
| 2. |
17β‐Estradiol |
| The loss of 17‐Estradiol during menopause has a negative impact on cognitive performance via changing the Alternative Receptor System. Splicing of ER in the female rat brain, 17‐estradiol (E2) protects against hypoxia by indirectly regulating HSP production through fast activation of nuclear factor‐B (NF‐B) and HSF‐1. | Anxiety, abdominal cramps, bloating, bleeding through the skin, breast augmentation, depression, dry mouth, extreme thirst, lightheadedness or fainting, headache, blood pressure problems (hypertension). | Shults et al (2015), Stice et al (2011) |
Abbreviations: HDF, human dermal fibroblast; MS, multiple sclerosis.