| Literature DB >> 36196294 |
Marvin Mecwan1, Jinghang Li1, Natashya Falcone1, Menekse Ermis1, Emily Torres1,2, Ramon Morales1,3, Alireza Hassani1, Reihaneh Haghniaz1, Kalpana Mandal1, Saurabh Sharma1, Surjendu Maity1, Fatemeh Zehtabi1, Behnam Zamanian1, Rondinelli Herculano1,4, Mohsen Akbari1,5,6, Johnson V John1, Ali Khademhosseini1.
Abstract
Hemorrhage is the leading cause of trauma-related deaths, in hospital and prehospital settings. Hemostasis is a complex mechanism that involves a cascade of clotting factors and proteins that result in the formation of a strong clot. In certain surgical and emergency situations, hemostatic agents are needed to achieve faster blood coagulation to prevent the patient from experiencing a severe hemorrhagic shock. Therefore, it is critical to consider appropriate materials and designs for hemostatic agents. Many materials have been fabricated as hemostatic agents, including synthetic and naturally derived polymers. Compared to synthetic polymers, natural polymers or biopolymers, which include polysaccharides and polypeptides, have greater biocompatibility, biodegradability and processibility. Thus, in this review, we focus on biopolymer-based hemostatic agents of different forms, such as powder, particles, sponges and hydrogels. Finally, we discuss biopolymer-based hemostatic materials currently in clinical trials and offer insight into next-generation hemostats for clinical translation.Entities:
Keywords: biomaterials; coagulation; hemostasis; polypeptides; polysaccharides
Year: 2022 PMID: 36196294 PMCID: PMC9522468 DOI: 10.1093/rb/rbac063
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Regen Biomater ISSN: 2056-3426
Figure 1.The schematic representation of the coagulation cascade, which includes the intrinsic pathway, extrinsic pathway and common pathway. Both the intrinsic and extrinsic pathways converge at the common pathway and lead to factor X activation, which helps convert prothrombin to thrombin. Thrombin is necessary to convert fibrinogen to fibrin and activate factor XIII, which eventually leads to a crosslinked fibrin clot. Fibrinolysis helps regulate hemostasis and helps degrade the fibrin network via plasmin. HK, high molecular weight kininogen; uPA, urokinase plasminogen activator; tPA, tissue plasminogen activator. Image adapted with permission from Loof et al. [29].
Figure 2.The chemical structures of various polysaccharides discussed in this review article.
Summary of biopolymer-based hemostatic materials and their hemostasis time and blood loss in various in vivo animal models
| Biopolymer | Form | Animal model | Treatment | Hemostasis time | Blood loss | References |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chitosan (CTS) | Particle | Rat Liver Injury Model | PECs w/10 wt% CTS | 48 s | [ | |
| PECs w/20 wt% CTS | 67 s | |||||
| PECs w/30 wt% CTS | 82 s | |||||
| Control: Gelatin sponge in powder form | 121 s | |||||
| Film | Rabbit Femoral Artery and Vein Model | CTS/Kaolin Composite | 4.9 ± 1.6 min | 3.5 ± 1.9 g | [ | |
| Control: QuikClot Gauze | 26.1 ± 22.8 min | 25.1 ± 6.1 g | ||||
| Control: Gauze | 55.1 ± 13.8 min | 31.1 ± 9.7 g | ||||
| Rat Femoral Artery and Vein Model | CTS/Kaolin Composite | 3.8 ± 1.4 min | 1.3 ± 0.4 g | |||
| Control: QuikClot Gauze | 8 ± 1.9 min | 3.3 ± 0.7 g | ||||
| Control: Gauze | >10 min | 5.5 ± 1.4 g | ||||
| Particle | Rat Tail Amputation Model | CTS Microspheres | 214 ± 25 s | [ | ||
| CTS Microspheres w/thin layer of Calcium Alginate | 161 ± 17 s | |||||
| Control: Gauze | 725 ± 21 s | |||||
| Rat Liver Laceration Model | CTS Microspheres | 107 ± 9 s | ||||
| CTS Microspheres w/thin layer of Calcium Alginate | 53 ± 10 s | |||||
| Control: Gauze | 238 ± 12 s | |||||
| Cellulose | Film | Rabbit Liver Model | Oxygen Regenerated Cellulose (ORC) film (oxidized 16 h) | 192 ± 30 s | 3.48 ± 0.82 g | [ |
| ORC film 44 h | 178 ± 25 s | 2.46 ± 0.66 g | ||||
| ORC film 64 h | 205 ± 40 s | 3.06 ± 0.22 g | ||||
| ORC film 88 h | 233 ± 38 s | 3.66 ± 0.54 g | ||||
| Control: Gauze | 300 ± 40 s | 4.78 ± 0.53 g | ||||
| Sponge | Mouse Tail Amputation Model | 1 wt% Chitosan-Cellulose (CTS-Cel) Sponge | 67 s | 95 mg* | [ | |
| Control: Gelatin Sponge | 159 s | 170 mg* | ||||
| Control: Gauze | 168 s | 150 mg* | ||||
| Control: No treatment | 320* | 210 mg* | ||||
| Rat Liver Trauma Model | 1 wt% CTS-Cel Sponge | 89 s | 400 mg* | |||
| Control: Gelatin Sponge | 131 s | 600 mg* | ||||
| Control: Gauze | 172 s | 700 mg* | ||||
| Control: No treatment | 225 s* | 900 mg* | ||||
| Rat Leg Artery Model | 1 wt% CTS-Cel Sponge | 105 s | ||||
| Control: Gelatin Sponge | 372 s | |||||
| Control: Gauze | 486 s | |||||
| Control: No treatment | 840 s* | |||||
| Dextran | Sponge | NZ White Rabbit Marginal Vein Cut | Dextran-derived PDA Sponge | 54 ± 6.0 s | 0.11 ± 0.14 g | [ |
| Control: Celox | >420 s | 2.65 ± 0.36 g | ||||
| NZ White Rabbit Femoral Artery Cut | Dextran-derived PDA Sponge | <120 s | 4.6 ± 0.55 g | |||
| Control: Celox | >180 s | 0.1 ± 0.24 g | ||||
| Hydrogel | Rat Liver Hemorrhaging Model | 0.5 wt% Chitosan/Oxidized Dextran | 53 mg | [ | ||
| 1.0 wt% Chitosan/Oxidized Dextran | 15 mg | |||||
| 0.5 wt% Chitosan | 136 mg | |||||
| Sponge | Rat Liver Hemorrhaging Model | Dextran-derived sponge | 59.2 ± 3.8 s | 0.52 g | [ | |
| Control: Celox | 108.7 ± 8.0 s | 3.8 g | ||||
| Control: Gauze | 128 ± 8.0 s | 4.7 g | ||||
| Alginate | Microspheres | Porcine Liver Punch | Thrombin-loaded Alginate-Calcium Microspheres | 1.5 ± 1 min | [ | |
| Thrombin-loaded Whole Blood | >10 min | |||||
| Hydrogel | Rat Liver Hemorrhaging Model | Pept-1 (cell adhesive peptide) and Alginate | 38 mg | [ | ||
| Control: No treatment | 208 mg | |||||
| Sponge | Mice Liver Hemorrhaging Model | Compressed Bi-Layer Alginate Sponge | 18.3 mg | [ | ||
| Uncompressed Bi-Layer Alginate Sponge | 232.4 mg | |||||
| Control: TachoSil® | 10.6 mg | |||||
| Control: Surgicel® | 19.0 mg | |||||
| HA | Hydrogel | Rat Liver Hemorrhaging Model | Self-crosslinking Gelatin Hydrogel | 194.7 ± 140.5 mg | [ | |
| HA/Gelatin Hydrogel | 120.4 ± 149.5 mg | |||||
| Control: Fibrin Glue | 119.1 ± 77.6 mg | |||||
| Control: No Treatment | 233.8 ± 181.4 mg | |||||
| Chondroitin Sulfate (CS) | Powder | Porcine Liver Punch | CS, Collagen and Thrombin | 0.46 g/min | [ | |
| Gelatin-Thrombin matrix with smooth particles | 0.14 g/min | |||||
| Hydrogel | Mouse Liver Hemorrhage Model | CS–Serotonin Hydrogel | 14.2 ± 0.8 mg | [ | ||
| Control: Chitosan-gelatin hemostatic agent | 31.0 ± 7.7 mg | |||||
| Control: No treatment | 69.2 ± 11 mg | |||||
| Gelatin | Sponge | Dog spleen bleeding model | 2-layer Gelatin sheet | 104 ± 115 s | [ | |
| Control: TachoSil® | 277 ± 117 s | |||||
| Sponge | NZ white rabbit ear bleeding model | Gelatin nanofiber sponge | 112 ± 19 s | 199 ± 32 mg | [ | |
| Control: TachoSil® | 133 ± 12 s | 285 ± 34 mg | ||||
| Gelatin nanofiber membrane | 169 ± 20 s | 318 ± 41 mg | ||||
| Control: Gauze | 266 ± 25 s | 668 ± 108 mg | ||||
| NZ white rabbit liver bleeding model | Gelatin nanofiber sponge | 99 ± 11 s | 131 ± 21 mg | |||
| Control: TachoSil® | 128 ± 10 s | 226 ± 27 mg | ||||
| Gelatin nanofiber membrane | 147 ± 13 s | 238 ± 40 mg | ||||
| Control: Gauze | 237 ± 25 s | 420 ± 91 mg | ||||
| Cryogel | Rabbit liver defect hemorrhage | 25 wt% Gelatin, 8 wt% Dopamine | 83 s | 1.2 g | [ | |
| Control: Hemostatic sponge | 222 s | 4 g ± 1.5 g | ||||
| Swine subclavian artery transection | 25 wt% Gelatin, 8 wt% Dopamine | 5.8 ± 1.4 min | 193 ± 81 ml | |||
| Control: Gauze | 25.4 ± 7.7 min | 487 ± 142 ml | ||||
| Particle | Rabbit Liver incision | Porous Gelatin microspheres (PGMs) | 95.7 s | [ | ||
| Control: Chitosan Hemostasis Powder (CHP) | 113 s | |||||
| Control: Yunnan Baiyao | 130 s | |||||
| Rabbit Ear incision | Gelatin microspheres w/surgical gauze | 45.3 s | ||||
| Control: CHP | 52.3 s | |||||
| Control: Yunnan Baiyao | 86.3 s | |||||
| Fibrin | Hydrogel | Human Vascular Surgery | 3 ml fibrin sealant | 3 min: 46.4% of patients; 4 min: 62.7%; | [ | |
| 5 min: 74.5%; | ||||||
| 7 min: 100% | ||||||
| Control: Manual compression | 3 min: 26.3% of patients; 4 min: 31.6%; | |||||
| 5 min: 49.1%; | ||||||
| 10 min: 100% | ||||||
| Foam | Rabbit Liver Partial Resection | Fibrin Foam | 50 ± 10 ml | [ | ||
| Control: No treatment | 122 ± 11.5 ml | |||||
| Film | Swine Spleen Incision | Fibrin patch | 3 min: 86% success rate; 10 min: 100% | [ | ||
| Control: TachoSil® | 3 min: 0% success rate; 10 min: 4% | |||||
| Keratin | Hydrogel | Rat Intracranial hemorrhage model (rebleeding) | 0.2 U collagenase, then Keratin hydrogel | 23.05 mm3 ± 9.67 mm3 | [ | |
| Control: 0.2 U collagenase | 122.09 mm3 ± 25.25 mm3 | |||||
| 0.4 U collagenase, then keratin hydrogel | 42.09 mm3 ± 7.81 mm3 | |||||
| Control: 0.4 U collagenase | 170.46 mm3 ± 25.25 mm3 | |||||
| 0.6 U collagenase, then keratin hydrogel | 60.87 mm3 ± 16.43 mm3 | |||||
| Control: 0.6 U collagenase | 231.86 mm3 ± 32.28 mm3 | |||||
| Film | Rat liver puncture model | Full-length Keratin + PCL sheet | 69 s | 459 mg | [ | |
| Rod domain Keratin + PCL sheet | 60 s | 368 mg | ||||
| Alpha helical Keratin + PCL sheet | 41 s | 308 mg | ||||
| PCL nanofiber sheet | 155 s | 671 mg | ||||
| Control: Gauze | 168 s | 856 mg | ||||
| Silk Fibroin (SF) | Powder | Murine hepatic injury model | LMSF powder | 120.6 ± 23.7 s | 0.39 ± 0.04 g | [ |
| Control: No treatment | 300 s | 0.73 ± 0.04 g | ||||
| Control: Arista® | 110.5 ± 30.1 s | 0.37 ± 0.05 g | ||||
| Control: Surgicel® | 102.8 ± 22.5 s | 0.32 ± 0.04 g | ||||
| Sponge | Rabbit liver trauma model | SF-PEG sponge | 136.17 ± 62.27 s | 2.16 ± 1.27 g | [ | |
| Control: No treatment | 557.75 ± 42.38 s | 7.92 ± 0.8 g | ||||
| Control: Gelatin sponge | 249.83 ± 29.18 s | 4.97 ± 1.44 g | ||||
| 3D scaffold | Rabbit ear artery hemorrhage model | TEMPO-oxidized cellulose nanofiber-5 wt% SF scaffolds with thrombin (TOCN-SF5-Th) | 110 ± 5 s* | [ | ||
| TEMPO-oxidized cellulose nanofiber with thrombin (TOCN-Th) | 225 ± 5 s* | |||||
| Rat-tail amputation model | TOCN-SF5-Th | 133 ± 14 s | 0.59 ± 0.01 g | |||
| TOCN-Th | 300 ± 6 s | 2.3 ± 0.08 g | ||||
| Control: Floseal® | 120 ± 6 s | 0.45 ± 0.08 g | ||||
| Rat liver avulsion model | TOCN-SF5-Th | 140 ± 5 s | 0.84 ± 0.08 g | |||
| TOCN-Th | 370 ± 6 s | 2.0 ± 0.08 g | ||||
| Control: Floseal® | 140 ± 6 s | 0.75 ± 0.08 g | ||||
| 3D scaffold | Rat tail truncation model | Tannic acid-SF with diclofenac potassium | 160 ± 72 s | 0.06 ± 0.03 g | [ | |
| Control: Gauze | 680 ± 60 s | 0.58 ± 0.10 g | ||||
| Engineered Polypeptides | Spongy film | Murine liver trauma model | Fusion protein 96R | 15.85 ± 1.21 s | [ | |
| Control: RADA-16 lyophilized on gauze | 14.44 ± 1.33 s | |||||
| Control: No treatment | 37.00 ± 1.75 s | |||||
| Hydrogel | Rat liver trauma model | RADA16-1 | <20 s | [ | ||
| Control: No treatment | >180 s | |||||
| Hydrogel | Mice Liver Hemorrhaging Model | R-Gel-4 | 14 ± 4 s | [ | ||
| V-Gel-4 | 18 ± 2 s | |||||
| Control: Fibrin glue | 64 ± 10 s | |||||
| Control: No treatment | 170 ± 10 s | |||||
| Bio-glue | Pig heart model | Cationic supercharged polypeptides (SUP) glue | 75 ± 5 s* | [ | ||
| Control: Histoacryl® | 110 ± 40 s* | |||||
| Pig liver model | SUP glue | 45 ± 10 s* | ||||
| Control: Histoacryl® | 100 ± 25 s* | |||||
| Pig kidney model | SUP glue | 30 ± 12 s* | ||||
| Control: Histoacryl® | 35 ± 10 s* | |||||
| Hydrogel | Mouse liver bleeding model | Methacrylated elastin-like polypeptides | 55.3 mg | [ | ||
| Control: No treatment | 214.5 mg | |||||
|
| High viscosity solution | Murine liver trauma model | PPDAC-PPDAL | 0.36 ± 0.13 g | [ | |
| Control: No treatment | 1.72 ± 0.63 g | |||||
| High viscosity solution | Hemorrhaging liver rat model | BPEDAC-BPEDAL | 0.54 ± 0.11 g | [ | ||
| Control: No treatment | 1.76 ± 0.56 g |
Data extrapolated from figures.
Figure 3.In vivo hemostasis studies using polysaccharide-based hemostats. (A) Standard gauze, (B) SF-coated bacterial cellulose/chitosan, (C) SF-coated Vit K/bacterial cellulose/chitosan, (D) SF-coated protamine sulfate/bacterial cellulose/chitosan applied to the bleeding site in a diabetic rat femoral artery model. Images adapted with permission from Karahaliloglu et al. [79], (E) creation of liver injury in the exposed left medial lobe of a New Zealand rabbit, (F) treatment of the injury site with aldehyde dextran (PDA) sponges. Hemostasis was maintained after removing the PDA sponge (G) and even after squeezing the wound (H). Images adapted with permission from Liu et al. [84]. (I) Liver hemorrhage model of factor VIII-deficient hemophilia mice with no treatment (NT), and HA-serotonin hemostatic adhesives. Image adapted with permission from An et al. [99]. (J) Six-millimeter cardiac puncture injury in pig hearts followed by treatment with methacrylated HA show rapid hemostasis and sealing following UV-induced polymerization. Image adapted with permission from Hong et al. [101].
Figure 4.(A) Ultralight gelatin nanofiber sponge. (B) Compressibility and recovery properties of the gelatin nanofiber sponge. (C) In vivo rabbit model evaluation of the hemostatic capacity of the ultralight gelatin sponge in comparison to sponge, gauze and commercial product. Image adapted with permission from Xie et al. [117]. (D) Fibrin pad (subcutaneously implanted; on the left), shows good vascularization after implantation day 14 compared to the control on the right. Image adapted with permission from Harmon et al. [123]. (E) Human hair hemostatic keratin hydrogels for the treatment of intracerebral hemorrhage were tested in the rabbit model. (F) Keratin solution and hydrogel showing gelation properties, scanning electron microscope (SEM) images of the gels. Images adapted from He et al. [128].
Figure 5.(A) Platelet adhesion and fibrinogen concentration in response to silk fibroin and SF-PEG sponges. Image adapted from Wei et al. [134]. (B) SDS-PAGE showing three hemostatic peptides and their sponges after purification. Image adapted from Yang et al. [136]. (C) PDA–sodium alginate–polyacrylamide (PDA–SA–PAM) hydrogel network showing accelerated clotting time [144]. (D) The addition of polyDOPA to SA–PAM structure improves rheological properties drastically. Images adapted from Suneetha et al. [144]. (E) Hemostatic capacity of the triblock DOPA peptide. Image adapted from Lu et al. [142]. (F) Hemostatic OCMC and antimicrobial G3KP polysaccharide-peptide dendrimers for rapid curing tissue adhesive-hemostat development. Image adapted from Zhu et al. [147].
Classification of hemorrhage
| Parameter | Class | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| I | II | III | IV | |
| Blood loss (ml) | <750 | 750–1500 | 1500–2000 | >2000 |
| Blood loss (%) | <15% | 15–30% | 30–40% | >40% |
| Pulse rate (beats/min) | <100 | >100 | >120 | >140 |
| Blood pressure | Normal | Decreased | Decreased | Decreased |
| Respiratory rate (breaths/min) | 14–20 | 20–30 | 30–40 | >35 |
| Urine output (ml/hour) | >30 | 20–30 | 5–15 | Negligible |
| CNS symptoms | Normal | Anxious | Confused | Lethargic |
Figure 6.Examples of biopolymer-based hemostatic sponges. (A) SSAD (skin secretion of Andrias davidianus)-enabled cellulose hemostatic sponges. Image adapted with permission from Zheng et al. [183] Copyright 2021, Elsevier. (B) Demonstration of fabrication, blood clotting and the hemostatic mechanism of 3D gelatin nanofiber-based sponges. Image adapted with permission from Xie et al. [148] Copyright 2021, Wiley.
Figure 7.SEM images of fiber sheet and film hemostats. (A) PVP electrospun membranes, (B) halloysite electrospun membranes (1.5 g nanoclay), (C) palygorskite electrospun membranes (1.5 g nanoclay), (D) kaolinite electrospun membrane (1.5 g nanoclay), (E) kaolinite electrospun membrane (2.0 g nanoclay) and (F) kaolinite electrospun membrane (2.4 g nanoclay). The insets are the corresponding 5× magnification of the images (scale bar = 2 µm). Images adapted with permission from Cui et al. [228]. SEM images of anticoagulated whole blood in contact with (RADA16-I/dextran sulfate) 200 films (G and H) and (RADA16/HA) 200 films (I and J) show interaction of the films with the blood components (scale bar = 10 µm). Images adapted with permission from Hsu et al. [213].
Biopolymer-based hemostats currently on the market and in National Institutes of Health (NIH) clinical trials
| Product name | Main component(s) | Form of hemostat | Company/sponsor | Phase | References |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Floseal® | Gelatin matrix with thrombin | Gel Sealant | Baxter | On-market | [ |
| Surgicel® | ORC | Powder | Ethicon | On-market | [ |
| Surgifoam® | Gelatin | Sponge/powder | Johnson and Johnson | On-market | [ |
| Celox Granules | Chitosan | Powder | Celox Medical | On-market | [ |
| Spongostan™ | Gelatin | Sponge-like dressing | Ethicon | On-market | [ |
| BaneCel® | Oxidized cellulose | Gel Sealant | Unicare Biomedical | On-market | [ |
| HemCon® Bandage PRO | Chitosan | Sponge-like dressing | Tricol Biomedical | On-market | [ |
| Avitene™ | Collagen | Sheet/sponge | BD | On-market | [ |
| Gelfoam® | Gelatin | Sponge | Pfizer | On-market | [ |
| Tachosil® | Fibrin | Patch | Baxter | On-market | [ |
| Surgiflo® | Gelatin matrix with thrombin | Gel Sealant | Ethicon | On-market | [ |
| PeproStat | Recombinant human albumin (rHA) conjugated with fibrinogen-binding peptides | Liquid | Haemostatix Ltd | Phase 2 (NCT03131336) | [ |
| Evarrest® | Fibrin | Patch | Ethicon | Phase 3 (NCT03255174) | [ |
| Thrombi-Gel® | Thrombin-JMI (bovine-derived), carboxylmethylcellulose | Sponge/pad | Vascular Solutions LLC | Phase 4 (NCT00652314) | [ |
| Gelatin | |||||
| HEMOCOLLAGENE® | Collagen | Sponge | Septodont | N/A | [ |
| (NCT05171231) |