Kamel Guedri1, Arshad Khan2, Taza Gul3, Safyan Mukhtar4, Wajdi Alghamdi5, Mansour F Yassen6,7, Elsayed Tag Eldin8. 1. Mechanical Engineering Department, College of Engineering and Islamic Architecture, Umm Al-Qura University, P.O. Box 5555, Makkah, 21955, Saudi Arabia. 2. College of Aeronautical Engineering, National University of Sciences and Technology (NUST), Sector H-12, Islamabad, 44000, Pakistan. 3. Department of Mathematics, City University of Science and IT, Peshawar, 25000, Pakistan. 4. Department of Basic Sciences, Preparatory Year Deanship King Faisal University, P.O. Box 400, Hofuf, Al-Ahsa, 31982, Saudi Arabia. 5. Department of Information Technology, Faculty of Computing and Information Technology, King Abdulaziz University, Jeddah, 80261, Saudi Arabia. 6. Department of Mathematics, College of Science and Humanities in Al-Aflaj, Prince Sattam Bin Abdulaziz University, Al-Aflaj, 11912, Saudi Arabia. 7. Department of Mathematics, Faculty of Science, Damietta University, New Damietta34517Damietta, Egypt. 8. Faculty of Engineering and Technology, Future University in EgyptNew Cairo, 11835, Egypt.
Abstract
The growth of hybrid nanofluids can be connected to their enhanced thermal performance as pertains to the dynamics of automobile coolant among others. In addition to that, the thermal characteristics of water-based nanofluids carrying three different types of nanoparticles are incredible. Keeping in view this new idea, the current investigation explores ternary hybrid nanofluid flow over a stretching sheet. Joule heating and viscous dissipation are addressed in the heat equation. Three distinct kinds of nanoparticles, namely, magnesium oxide, copper, and MWCNTs, are suspended in water to form a ternary hybrid nanofluid with the combination MgO-Cu-MWCNTs-H2O. To stabilize the flow of the ternary hybrid nanofluid, transverse magnetic and electric fields have been considered in the fluid model. The production of entropy has been analyzed for the modeled problem. A comparative study for ternary, hybrid, and traditional nanofluids has also been carried out by sketching statistical charts. The equations that govern the problem are shifted to dimension-free format by employing transformable variables, and then they are solved by the homotopy analysis method (HAM). It has been revealed in this work that the flow of fluid opposes by magnetic parameter and supports by electric field the volumetric fraction of ternary hybrid nanofluid, while thermal profiles are gained by the growing values of these parameters. Boosting values of the electric field, magnetic parameters, and Eckert number support the Bejan number and oppose the production of entropy. Statistically, it has been established in this work that a ternary hybrid nanofluid has a higher thermal conductivity than hybrid or traditional nanofluids.
The growth of hybrid nanofluids can be connected to their enhanced thermal performance as pertains to the dynamics of automobile coolant among others. In addition to that, the thermal characteristics of water-based nanofluids carrying three different types of nanoparticles are incredible. Keeping in view this new idea, the current investigation explores ternary hybrid nanofluid flow over a stretching sheet. Joule heating and viscous dissipation are addressed in the heat equation. Three distinct kinds of nanoparticles, namely, magnesium oxide, copper, and MWCNTs, are suspended in water to form a ternary hybrid nanofluid with the combination MgO-Cu-MWCNTs-H2O. To stabilize the flow of the ternary hybrid nanofluid, transverse magnetic and electric fields have been considered in the fluid model. The production of entropy has been analyzed for the modeled problem. A comparative study for ternary, hybrid, and traditional nanofluids has also been carried out by sketching statistical charts. The equations that govern the problem are shifted to dimension-free format by employing transformable variables, and then they are solved by the homotopy analysis method (HAM). It has been revealed in this work that the flow of fluid opposes by magnetic parameter and supports by electric field the volumetric fraction of ternary hybrid nanofluid, while thermal profiles are gained by the growing values of these parameters. Boosting values of the electric field, magnetic parameters, and Eckert number support the Bejan number and oppose the production of entropy. Statistically, it has been established in this work that a ternary hybrid nanofluid has a higher thermal conductivity than hybrid or traditional nanofluids.
The exclusion of extraneous
heat from different manufacturing procedures,
transmission systems, and power plant equipment has been very challenging.
Fluids that are based upon thermal flow such as ethylene glycol, water,
and oils, etc. are termed as base fluid. These fluids have low thermal
conductance that restrains their performance in different applications
at the industrial level. The thermal conductance of these fluids can
be enhanced by spreading solid particles as also proposed by Jawad
et al.[1] These particles are, for example,
carbon, silver, magnesium oxide, copper oxide, alumina, titanium oxide,
and graphene, etc. Such a combination of the base fluid and solid
nanoparticles is termed as nanofluid. For its numerous applications
in industry and engineering, nanofluid is a wide subject of deliberation
for engineers and scientists. This type of material contains nanosized
particles in the base fluid. Nanofluids normally have enhanced thermal
conductance as necessary for various heat transmission systems. Algehyne
et al.[2] inspected MHD radiative nanofluid
flow with a modified Buongiorno model past a curved slippery surface.
It has also been observed that nanofluids could replace the prevailing
cooling system in various areas of engineering such as transportation,
electronics, energy, and manufacturing processes as discussed by Sajid
and Ali.[3] In this work it is revealed that
the heat transfer efficiency is enhanced for both plates of the channel
respectively by 7.10% (at the upper plate) and 4.11% (at the lower
plate). Rasool et al.[4] discussed numerically
the EMHD nanofluid flow over a Riga plate placed horizontally in a
permeable medium. Wakif et al.[5] explored
nanofluid flow past an isothermal stretching surface using a modified
Buongiorno model. Shah et al.[6] studied
the heat transfer rate for gold blood nanoparticles using thermal
radiation. The authors have considered the fluid flow in a channel
with suction as well as injection effects on both plates of the channel.With the passage of time, investigators came to know that the suspension
of two different kinds of nanoparticles in a pure fluid such as engine
oil, ethylene glycol, and water enhances the thermal characteristics
of the base fluid. Such fluids are termed as hybrid nanofluids. These
fluids have different applications in industry and engineering such
as coolant in machines and manufacturing processes, heated pipes,
ventilation processes, heat exchanger, automotive industry, ships,
biomedicines, cooling of the nuclear system, and cooling of refrigeration
systems, etc. Shah et al.[7] deliberated
thermal augmented EMHD micropolar hybrid nanofluid flow on a horizontal
surface. Islam et al.[8] surveyed the thermal
flow for micropolar hybrid nanofluid (GO + Cu + H2O) flow
amid two plates. The efficiency of hybrid nanofluid has been analyzed
by Khashi’ie et al.[9] with nanoparticles
of copper and alumina in a base fluid taken as water. The entropy
production along with heat transmission for a MHD hybrid nanofluid
(Al2O3 + Cu + H2O) flow was examined
by Perveen et al.[10] using different flow
conditions. Bhatti et al.[11] investigated
numerically hybrid nanofluid flow through an elastic circular and
non-Darcy medium. A comparative analysis was conducted in this study
in the absence of nanoparticles.Recently scientists and researchers
have developed a new class
of nanofluid by suspending three unlike types of nanoparticles in
the pure fluid. This innovative class of nanofluid is called a ternary
hybrid nanofluid. The higher demand for the cooling agent in the combination
of high thermal capability at the industrial level has attracted researchers
to modify the existing nanofluid, as a result of which trihybrid nanofluid
has been introduced with enhanced thermal characteristics. With this
thinking, further experimental investigations have been conducted
to enhance further the thermal characteristics of an existing hybrid
nanofluid by suspending three unlike kinds of solid nanoparticles
in pure fluid, leading to the ternary hybrid nanofluid. Sang et al.[12] used CNTs and carbonate nanoparticles to enhance
the thermal conductivity and specific heat for solar power systems.
Mousavi et al.[13] examined the dynamics
of a trihybrid nanofluid by suspending magnesium oxide, copper oxide,
and titanium oxide in water. Sahoo and Kumar et al.[14] tried to promote an innovative correlation to improve the
viscosity of trihybrid nanofluid. From the outcome of their work,
it was revealed that the dynamic viscosity was enhanced and declined
for augmentation in volume fraction and temperature, respectively.
The density property of different nanofluids was introduced by employing
equilibrium molecular dynamic simulations as investigated by Abbasi
et al.,[15] and it was highlighted in this
work that the density of nanofluid is influenced significantly by
the shape and size of nanoparticles.Fluid flows due to stretching
sheets have received considerable
attention of scientists due to their applications in the fields of
engineering and industry. These applications include hot rolling,
extrusion of the sheet, shrink wrapping, bundle wrapping, manufacturing
of foam, purification of crude oil, and electronic devices cooling,
etc. Due to the stretching surface, the boundary layer flow plays
a vital role in the production of paper, fabrication of glass, and
the nuclear reactor, etc. The revolutionary work was initiated by
Sakiadis[16,17] in 1961 by presenting the idea of boundary
layer flow past a stretching surface. Afterward, Crane[18] extended this idea and determined the exact
solution for the stretching sheet. Since then, various investigators
have comprehended the idea of stretching sheets for different flows.
Khan et al.[19] applied the curved stretching
sheet to optimize the entropy generation for a nanofluid. The authors
of this investigation have addressed the impact of various flow conditions
upon the flow system and have revealed that thermal flow has an upsurge
with a hike in Brownian motion and thermophoretic parameters, while
entropy generation is augmented with larger values of the curvature
parameter. The production of entropy has also been minimized by Hayat
et al.[20] with the help of a stretching
sheet by using Darcy-Forchheimer nanoparticles with slip conditions.
Raza et al.[21] investigated the creation
of irreversibility by considering the nonlinear thermally radiative
flow of a nanofluid upon the curved stretching surface. In this work,
the curvilinear coordinate system was implemented to tackle the governing
equations. Rasool et al.[22] scrutinized
the irreversibility and chemically reactive MHD fluid flow over a
nonlinear stretched sheet. Hayat et al.[23,24] discussed
separately the axisymmetric MHD fluid flow over a stretched cylinder
and between two sheets. Naseem et al.[25] used the influence of magnetic effects upon bioconvective nanofluid
flow over a stretching surface. Shafiq et al.[26] inspected MHD squeezing fluid flow upon a stretched surface using
non-Darcy phenomenon.The irreversibility analysis is used to
investigate the efficiency
of different thermo-dynamical systems in engineering, industrial,
and biomedical phenomenon. The production of entropy in a mechanical
system is based upon the second law of thermodynamics. The optimization
of entropy is employed to enhance the effectiveness of the thermo-dynamical
system. The entropy is normally caused by the occurrence of molecular
vibration, Joule heating, thermal radiation, chemical reaction, and
force of resistance to a fluid’s motion, etc. Principally Bejan[27,28] initiated theoretically the concept of production of irreversibility
problems. Afterward, numerous studies were conducted by different
researchers with the main focus on the optimization of entropy production
for different flow systems. Ahmad et al.[29] inspected convective flow of a power-law fluid over a vertical plate
by using effects of Brownian motion as well as thermophoresis to the
flow system. It was noticed in this study that Bejan number was reduced
and entropy production was increased with higher values of the radiation
parameter. Khan et al.[30] examined the creation
of irreversibility for the rotary motion of Casson nanofluid upon
a spinning and stretched cylinder. The authors of this study highlighted
that flow of fluid was enhanced and concentration had declined with
augmentation in Reynolds number. The entropy was also noticed to be
enhanced with advanced values of radiation parameter and Brinkman
number. Habib et al.[31] used the finite
difference method to solve the modeled problem for entropy generation
and thermal flow analysis in the power-law fluid and noticed that
higher values of magnetic parameters enhanced the entropy of the flow
system. Shashikumar et al.[32] inspected
the thermal flow and entropy production for MHD Williamson fluid flow
passing through a microchannel.The irreversibility phenomenon
that converts the work performed
by fluid particles by employing a shared force into thermal energy
is termed as viscous dissipation. It alters the thermal diffusion
by acting as a source of energy and affects thermal flow rate. Various
studies have been conducted by incorporating the effects of viscous
dissipation for fluid flow problems. To control the heat transmission
rate for fluid flow past a stretched sheet, Bataller[33] used a variable heat source with viscous dissipation and
observed that thermal profiles were supported by Eckert number, radiation,
and dissipation parameters. Zaydan et al.[34] inspected EMHD dissipative fluid flow past a heated Riga plate using
a heat source. Khan et al.[35] analyzed nanofluid
flow over a spinning needle employing viscous dissipation and magnetic
effects to the flow system. It was depicted in this analysis that
the flow characteristics of nanofluid were opposed by a volumetric
fraction and magnetic field, whereas thermal flow was supported by
upper values of Brownian motion and Eckert number. Bhatti et al.[36] settled mathematically a model for naturally
convective EMHD fluid flow through a microchannel consisting of non-Darcy
permeable medium with influence of viscous dissipation. Shafiq et
al.[37] investigated analytically a stretched
surface with the impact of viscous dissipation. Khan et al.[38] investigated thermal flow optimization for micropolar
fluid flow upon a needle using bioconvective and viscous dissipation
effects upon the flow system. Gul et al.[39] inspected thermal analysis for electroosmotic flow with viscous
dissipation through a vertical tube. Abbas et al.[40] deliberated mathematically nanofluid flow subject to viscous
dissipation and other flow conditions.From the cited literature
it was revealed that plenty of investigations
have been conducted to improve thermal conductivity of a pure fluid
by suspending two different kinds of nanoparticles in it, but very
few investigations have yet been conducted for ternary hybrid nanofluids.
The novelty of current work is described in the following list:Three different types of nanoparticles namely magnesium
oxide, copper, and MWCNTs are suspended in the base fluid (water)
to form ternary hybrid nanofluid.The
new combination MgO-Cu-MWCNTs-H2O has
been used for the first time in the current work. This new combination
helps in environmental purification and other appliances that require
cooling.For stabilization of the flow
of a trihybrid nanofluid,
the transverse magnetic and electric fields have been considered in
the fluid model.The main focus of this
work is to analyze the thermal
efficiency of ternary hybrid nanofluids and to carry out a comparative
study for ternary, hybrid, and traditional nanofluids. This comparison
will be expressed with the help of statistical charts.The production of entropy has also been analyzed for
the modeled problem.Heat transfer enhancement is the main objective of the
suggested
model. The core objective of the current work is to show that ternary
hybrid nanofluids can more reliably enhance heat transfer. Entropy
and Bejan number affect the proposed model under the impact of numerous
factors.According to the above objectives, possible research
questions
that can arise in the minds of the readers are the following:• Who cautions about this problem and why?•
What have others done?• How can you demonstrate that
your solution is a good one?
Problem Formulation
Two-dimensional
flow of the ternary hybrid nanofluid past a stretching
surface containing MgO, Cu, and MWCNTs nanoparticles has been considered
(Figure ). The transverse
magnetic and electric fields stabilize the ternary hybrid nanofluid
flow. Additionally, the Joule heating and viscous dissipation effects
are used in the energy equations. Lorentz force is used as a resistive
force to streamline the flow regime signified by J⃗ × B⃗ such that J⃗ is the current density and B⃗ is
the magnetic field effect. Furthermore, J⃗
is defined by the Ohm law J⃗ = σ(V⃗ × B⃗ + E⃗) where E⃗ is used for electric field
and σ is used for the electrical conductivity.
Figure 1
Geometrical view of the
flow problem.
Geometrical view of the
flow problem.The equations that governed the flow problem can
be stated mathematically
as[41]The conditions at the boundaries are[41]Above u and v depict flow elements along the direction of x and y-axes and ρ represents ternary
hybrid nanofluid density, μ,
υ, α, (ρc) and σ are the dynamic viscosity, kinematic viscosity, thermal diffusivity,
heat capacitance, and electrical conductivity of the ternary hybrid
nanofluid, whereas E0 is the strength
of the electric field while B0 is magnetic
strength.It is to be noticed that the thermophysical characteristics
of
the ternary fluid are displayed as[42,43]The set of dimensionless variables is[43]Utilizing eqs in eqs –3) we haveThe related conditions at boundaries
areIn eqs and 12 Pr is Prandtl number, M is magnetic
factor, E is electric field parameter, and Ec is Eckert, these factors are defined mathematically as
Physical Quantities
In the current
investigation the main quantities of interest are expressed mathematically
as follows:Using eq to eq we have the modified format of the above quantities as follows:
Entropy Rate
In order to calculate
the production of entropy in the current
investigation, following the concept as presented by Bejan[44] and Hayat et al.,[45] the volumetric rate of dimensional entropy production can be expressed
mathematically asIncorporating eq in eq we haveHere is the entropy production rate and is the temperature difference parameter.
Bejan Number
The ratio of entropy produced
due to heat transmission to total
entropy of the flow system produced is the Bejan number. Mathematically
it can be described as
Method of Solution
For a solution of
nonlinear differential equations various solution
techniques have been used by different researchers. HAM[46,47] is one of such techniques employed for the solution of nonlinear
differential equations. Mathematica software is used to fulfill this
aim. This method requires some initial guesses and values of linear
operators which are discussed in the following lines.such thatwhere N and NΘ̑ are described asFor eqs and 7 the zeroth-order system is described
asRelated boundary conditions areFor ζ = 0, ζ = 1 we haveThe Taylor’s series expansion of F̑(η;ζ) and Θ̑(η;ζ)
about ζ = 0 is expressed asSubjected conditions areNowWhile
Discussion of Results
The current study
explores a trihybrid nanofluid over a stretching
sheet. Magnesium oxide, copper, and MWCNTs are suspended in the base
fluid (water) to form a ternary hybrid nanofluid with a combination
MgO-Cu-MWCNTs-H2O. In order to stabilize the flow of ternary
hybrid nanofluid, the transverse magnetic and electric fields have
been considered in the fluid model. The production of entropy has
been analyzed for the modeled problem. A comparative study for ternary,
hybrid, and traditional nanofluids has also been carried out by sketching
statistical charts. After seeking the HAM solution of the problem,
different graphical views have been obtained for various parameters
which have been encountered during the process of nondimensionalization.
In the following lines, some discussion has been carried out for explaining
these graphical views theoretically with impact upon velocity, temperature,
entropy, and Bejan number.
Variations in Velocity
The flow of
fluid in response to variations in different parameters is discussed
in Figures –4. From Figure , it is observed that when ϕ1 = ϕ2 = ϕ3 = 0.01, λ = 0.2, E = 0.2, and Ec = 1.0, then for variations
in the magnetic parameter M, velocity profiles decline.
Actually, the Lorentz force generates in the fluid flow system with
higher values of M which maximizes the resistive
force. Therefore, the velocity of ternary hybrid nanofluid decays
due to resistance in fluid motion. Figure presents the contribution of electric field E to velocity profiles f′(η)
when M = 0.1, Ec = 1.0, ϕ1 = ϕ2 = ϕ3 = 0.01, and λ
= 0.2. Since growth in E conveys a drop in the resistive
forces to fluid flow and causes an enhancement in the velocity profiles
for ternary, hybrid, and traditional nanofluids as portrayed in Figure . The effects of
nanoparticles of magnesium oxide (MgO), copper (Cu), and MWCNTs upon
velocity f′(η) are depicted in Figure . Since with augmentation
in the values of solid nanoparticles the dense behavior of a fluid
is enhanced, due to which resistive forces to motion are created,
and declines velocity.
Figure 2
Velocity profiles versus variations in magnetic
parameter M.
Figure 4
Velocity profiles versus variations in solid nanoparticles
ϕ1, ϕ2, ϕ3.
Figure 3
Velocity profiles versus variations in electric field
parameter E.
Velocity profiles versus variations in magnetic
parameter M.Velocity profiles versus variations in electric field
parameter E.Velocity profiles versus variations in solid nanoparticles
ϕ1, ϕ2, ϕ3.
Variations in Temperature
The influence
of different parameters upon profiles of temperature θ(η)
is presented in Figures –7. From Figure it is noticed that
for a growth in magnetic parameter (M) with E = 0.2, Ec = 1.0, ϕ1 =
ϕ2 = ϕ3 = 0.01, and λ = 0.2,
the thermal flow is boosted. Physically, for higher values of M there are much stronger resistive forces in the fluid
motion that generate more energy dissipation and ultimately enhance
the temperature. The electric field E acts as an
increasing agent for the thermal field, as maximum thermal diffusivity
takes place for higher values of E. Hence augmentation
in E corresponds to a growth in thermal profiles
when M = 0.2, Ec = 1.0, ϕ1 = ϕ2 = ϕ3 = 0.01, and λ = 0.2 as depicted
in Figure . The influence
of higher values of Eckert number (Ec) upon thermal
field is portrayed in Figure for fixed values of M = 0.2, Ec = 1.0, ϕ1 = ϕ2 = ϕ3 = 0.01, and λ = 0.2. Actually, for greater values of Ec, maximum heat energy transports from a region of higher
thermal flow to a region of lower one due to which more heat transfer
occurs. In this phenomenon the thermal profiles of a fluid increase
as portrayed in Figure .
Figure 5
Temperature profiles versus variations in magnetic parameter M.
Figure 7
Temperature profiles versus variations in Eckert number Ec.
Figure 6
Temperature profiles versus variations in electric field
parameter E.
Temperature profiles versus variations in magnetic parameter M.Temperature profiles versus variations in electric field
parameter E.Temperature profiles versus variations in Eckert number Ec.
Rate of Entropy Generation and Bejan Number
The impact upon entropy and Bejan number in response of variation
in different factors is presented in Figures –11. The effect of magnetic parameter (M) over entropy and Bejan number is presented in Figure (a,b). Physically
higher values of M offer more resistance to moving
particles of the ternary hybrid nanofluid; this resistance disturbs
the order of flow pattern and generates more entropy as depicted in Figure a. A reverse impact
of higher values of M upon Bejan number is observed
as depicted in Figure b with parameter values of E = 0.2,Ec = 1.0, ϕ1 = ϕ2 = ϕ3 = 0.01, and λ = 0.2.
Figure 8
(a) Entropy and (b) Bejan number versus variations
in magnetic
parameter M.
Figure 11
(a) Entropy and (b) Bejan number versus variations in
λ.
(a) Entropy and (b) Bejan number versus variations
in magnetic
parameter M.(a) Entropy and (b) Bejan number versus variations in
electric
parameter E.(a) Entropy and (b) Bejan number versus variations in
Eckert number Ec.(a) Entropy and (b) Bejan number versus variations in
λ.Figure panels
a and b portray the influence of electric parameters (E) upon the generation of entropy and Bejan number. From these figure,
it is obvious that higher values of E decay entropy
while the Bejan number increases, when M = 0.2, Ec = 1.0, ϕ1 = ϕ2 = ϕ3 = 0.01, and λ = 0.2.
Figure 9
(a) Entropy and (b) Bejan number versus variations in
electric
parameter E.
Figure panels
a and b reveal that augmenting values of Eckert number Ec decrease the values of entropy for E = 0.2, M = 1.0, ϕ1 = ϕ2 = ϕ3 = 0.01, and λ = 0.2, whereas for the growth in Ec the values of the Bejan number increase.
Figure 10
(a) Entropy and (b) Bejan number versus variations in
Eckert number Ec.
Figure panels
a and b portray that augmenting values of temperature difference parameter
λ boost the values of entropy generation for E = 0.2, M = 0.2, ϕ1 = ϕ2 = ϕ3 = 0.01, and Ec = 1.0,
whereas for the same range of these parameters the Bejan number decays
for higher values of λ as depicted in Figure b.In Chart the values
of ternary hybrid nanofluid have been calculated for skin friction
in response to variations in electric field parameters E with ϕ1 = ϕ2 = ϕ3 = 0.01 and M = 0.2. It has been noticed that for
a variation in the values of E from 0.2 to 0.6 the
values of skin friction coefficient vary from 0.52416 to 0.90166 for
MWCNTs nanoparticles. The values of skin friction vary from 0.62528
to 0.99642 for Cu + MWCNTs nanoparticles, whereas for the same range
of E for the ternary hybrid nanoparticles MgO + Cu
+ MWCNTs, the skin friction coefficient varies from 0.844944 to 1.144808.
Hence an increasing trend has been observed in skin friction coefficient
in response to variation in E from 0.2 to 0.6 and
is much better in the case of ternary hybrid nanoparticles.
Chart 1
: Comparison
of Ternary Hybrid Nanofluid for Skin Friction Using
Electric Field Parameter E
In Chart the values
of the ternary hybrid nanofluid have been calculated for skin friction
in response of variations in magnetic parameters M with ϕ1 = ϕ2 = ϕ3 = 0.01 and E = 0.2. It has been noticed that, for
variations in values of M from 0.2 to0.6 the values
of skin friction coefficient varies from 0.27043 to 0.22012 for MWCNTs nanoparticles, these values of skin friction vary
from 0.35223 to 0.29251 for Cu + MWCNTs nanoparticles , whereas, on
the same range of M for ternary hybrid nanoparticles
MgO + Cu + MWCNTs, the variations in skin friction coefficient are
from 0.37266 to 0.36263. A decaying trend has been observed in the
skin friction coefficient in response to variations in M from 0.2 to 0.6.
Chart 2
: Comparison of Ternary Hybrid Nanofluid for Skin
Friction Using
Magnetic Parameter M
In Chart the values
of the ternary hybrid nanofluid have been calculated for skin friction
in response of variations in volumetric fraction ϕ1, ϕ2, ϕ3 with M = 0.4, and E = 0.2. It has been observed that for
variations in the values of ϕ1, ϕ2, ϕ3 from 0.01 to 0.03, the values of skin friction
coefficient vary from 0.02033 to 0.27043 for MWCNTs nanoparticles
and from 0.19084 to 0.35223 for Cu + MWCNTs nanoparticles, whereas
on the same range of ϕ1, ϕ2, ϕ3 for ternary hybrid nanoparticles MgO + Cu + MWCNTs, the variations
in skin friction coefficient are from 0.20117 to 0.59266. An enhancing
behavior has been observed in the skin friction coefficient in response
to variations in ϕ1, ϕ2, ϕ3 from 0.01 to0.03.
Chart 3
: Comparison of Ternary Hybrid Nanofluid
for Skin Friction Using
Parameters ϕ1, ϕ2, ϕ3
In Chart the variations
in Nusselt number have been depicted in response to augmenting values
of electric field parameter E when ϕ1 = ϕ2 = ϕ3 = 0.01, Ec = 1, Pr = 6.2, and M = 0.2. It has been noticed
that for variations in electric field parameter E from the range 0.3 to 0.7, the rate of transfer of heat augments
from 0.98983 to 1.00288 for MWCNT nanoparticles. These values of heat
transmission rate vary from 1.07647 to 1.08511 for Cu + MWCNTs nanoparticles,
whereas on the same range of E for MgO + Cu + MWCNTs
nanoparticles, the variations in Nusselt number are from 1.26630 to
1.48799. An enhancing behavior has been observed in Nusselt number
in response to variations in E from 0.3 to 0.7. Moreover,
the maximum heat transfer rate has been observed in the case of ternary
hybrid nanofluid which is the main motivation in the current work.
Chart 4
: Comparison of Ternary Hybrid Nanofluid for Nusselt Number Using
Electric Field Parameter E
In Chart the variations
in Nusselt number are presented in response to augmenting values of
the magnetic parameter M when ϕ1 = ϕ2 = ϕ3 = 0.01, Ec = 1, Pr = 6.2, and E = 0.2. For variations in E from a range 0.3 to 0.7, the Nusselt number varies from
0.97542 to 1.10288 for MWCNT nanoparticles, these variations in Nusselt
number are from 1.05425 to1.20272 for Cu + MWCNTs nanoparticles, whereas
on the same range of magnetic parameter for MgO + Cu + MWCNTs nanoparticles,
the variations in Nusselt number are from 1.22967 to 1.70560. Once
again an augmenting behavior has been noticed in Nusselt number.
Chart 5
: Comparison of Ternary Hybrid Nanofluid for Nusselt Number Using
the Parameter M
In Chart the variations
in Nusselt number are portrayed in the reaction of augmenting values
of Eckert number Ec when ϕ1 = ϕ2 = ϕ3 = 0.01, M = E = 0.2, and Pr = 6.2. The value of Nusselt number changes
from 2.11613 to 2.19041 for MWCNT nanoparticles, when Ec varies from 0.3 to 0.7. For the same range of Ec, the Nusselt number changes from 2.14045 to 2.22012 for Cu + MWCNTs
nanoparticles. It has also been observed that for MgO + Cu + MWCNTs
nanoparticles the Nusselt number varies from 2.35534 to 3.58053 when Ec varies from 0.3 to 0.7. In this case, a huge change has
been observed in Nusselt number in the case of the ternary hybrid
nanofluid.
Chart 6
: Comparison of Ternary Hybrid Nanofluid for Nusselt
Number Using
the Parameter Ec
In Chart the variations
in Nusselt number are depicted in response to augmenting values of
volume fraction of nanoparticles ϕ1, ϕ2, ϕ3 when Ec = 1, M = E = 0.2, and Pr = 6.2. The value of
the Nusselt number changes from 0.75064 to 0.89446 for MWCNT nanoparticles,
when ϕ1 = ϕ2 = ϕ3 varies from 0.01 to 0.03. For the same range of ϕ1 = ϕ2 = ϕ3, the Nusselt number
varies from 0.83379 to 0.95953 for Cu + MWCNTs nanoparticles. It has
also been observed that for MgO + Cu + MWCNTs nanoparticles, the Nusselt
number varies from 0.88431 to1.35299 when ϕ1 = ϕ2 = ϕ3 varies from 0.01 to 0.03. Again an
augmentation in heat transfer rate has been noticed for the ternary
hybrid nanofluid.
Chart 7
: Comparison of Ternary Hybrid Nanofluid for Nusselt
Number Using
ϕ1,ϕ2,ϕ3
Conclusions
The current study investigates
ternary hybrid nanofluid flow over
a stretching sheet with some flow conditions. Magnesium oxide, copper,
and MWCNTs are suspended in the base fluid (water) to form a ternary
hybrid nanofluid with a combination MgO–Cu–MWCNTs–H2O. In order to stabilize the flow of ternary hybrid nanofluid,
the transverse magnetic and electric fields have been considered in
the fluid model. The production of entropy has been analyzed for the
modeled problem. A comparative study for ternary, hybrid, and traditional
nanofluids has also been carried out by sketching statistical charts.
After complete insight of the investigation the following points have
been observed:Flow of fluid decays for growth in the magnetic parameter
and volumetric fraction of ternary hybrid nanofluid.Higher values of the electric field parameter support
the fluid motion for all types of nanoparticles.For growth in the magnetic parameter, there is much
stronger resistive force in the fluid motion that generates more energy
dissipation and ultimately enhances the temperature of the fluid.
Thermal profiles are also supported by augmentation in the electric
field parameter.For a growth in Eckert
number, maximum heat diffusivity
takes place that augments the thermal profiles of the ternary hybrid
nanofluid.Augmenting values of the magnetic
parameter, electric
field factor, and Eckert number support the expansion in the Bejan
number and oppose the production of entropy. Whereas augmentation
in temperature difference parameter enhances the production of irreversibility
and decays the Bejan number.With the
help of statistical chart, it has established
that skin friction coefficient augments with growing values of electric
field parameter and volumetric fractions of solid nanoparticles, whereas
it decays with growth in magnetic parameter.Thermal flow rate grows up more rapidly with variations
of different substantial parameters in the case of ternary hybrid
nanofluid MgO + Cu + MWCNTs as compared to hybrid nanofluid Cu + MWCNTs
or traditional nanofluid MWCNTs. Therefore, the ternary hybrid nanofluid
has the highest thermal conductivity than hybrid or traditional nanofluids.In the future the influence of mixed convection,
Brownian
motion, and thermophoresis effects will be added with inclusion of
a concentration equation.